Dissociating explicit timing from temporal expectation with fMRI
Introduction
The cognitive neuroscience of interval timing (i.e. timing in the range of several hundred milliseconds to minutes) is plagued by several neuroanatomical dichotomies. Is there a left- or right-sided hemispheric lateralisation for timing [1, 2]? Are there anatomical differences in the processing of subsecond versus suprasecond durations [3, 4]? Do distinct neural systems subserve perceptual versus motor timing [4, 5]? More generally, is there one ubiquitous task-independent timing network, or is timing represented locally in functionally specific areas [6, 7, 8]? We attempt to resolve some of these puzzles by deconstructing the monolithic term ‘timing’ and making clear the functional (and neural) distinction between explicit and implicit timing of stimulus duration or inter-stimulus intervals (Figure 1). Our aim is to show that some of the apparent inconsistency, and consequent confusion, has arisen from a conflation of these processes. Specifically, we use results from the functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) literature, highlighting those studies appearing within the past three years, to illustrate their discrete neural signatures. We restrict our discussion to metrical representations of time. The neural correlates of ordinal representations of time have recently been outlined by Battelli [9].
Section snippets
Explicit timing
The crucial distinction between explicit and implicit timing is whether or not the task instructions require subjects to provide an overt estimate of duration. In tasks of explicit timing, estimates of stimulus duration or inter-stimulus interval (ISI) are given either in the form of a perceptual discrimination (‘perceptual timing’), in which subjects typically state whether one stimulus duration or ISI is shorter or longer than another (Figure 2a); or in the form of a motor response (‘motor
Neuroanatomical substrates of explicit timing
Numerous fMRI studies of perceptual [16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24•] or motor [26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31•, 32••, 33, 34] timing have consistently identified several key ‘timing areas’: supplementary motor area (SMA), basal ganglia (BG), cerebellum and right inferior frontal and parietal cortices. The functional contribution, or necessity, of each to a timing network is still very much a matter of debate however.
Neuroanatomical substrates of implicit timing: temporal expectations
We restrict our review to studies of implicit perceptual timing, or ‘temporal expectations’ (Figure 1), and refer the reader to Ivry et al. [40] for a discussion of implicit motor (‘emergent’) timing.
Responses to sensory stimuli that appear when expected are quicker and more accurate than those appearing at unexpected intervals [15]. Such temporal expectations (also referred to as implicit timing [14], anticipation of event timing [41, 42] or future-oriented attending [12]) make use of timing
Hemispheric lateralisation for explicit timing and temporal expectation
Recently, Geiser et al. [59••] have directly compared implicit perceptual timing (i.e. temporal expectation) with explicit timing of a verbal rhythm task. They identified a clear-cut hemispheric lateralisation, with right-sided temporo-parietal areas being activated by explicit timing of temporally predictable rhythmic speech patterns, while their left-sided homologues were activated by implicit temporal processing of the same stimuli. This experiment exemplifies, at least for perceptual timing
Conclusions
We aimed to imbue some clarity into the disparate findings in the timing literature by re-classifying it into those studies in which timing is the explicit task goal versus those in which timing is conducted implicitly in order to achieve a motor or perceptual goal. Explicit timing almost invariably engages BG, while activation of SMA, inferior frontal cortex and cerebellum, although common, depends more upon the specific task-context. Implicit perceptual timing activates a different set of
References and recommended reading
Papers of particular interest, published within the period of review, have been highlighted as:
• of special interest
•• of outstanding interest
Acknowledgement
JTC is partly funded by a grant from the Agence Nationale de la Recherche, Programme 2007 Neurosciences, Neurologie & Psychiatrie.
References (62)
- et al.
Remembering the time: a continuous clock
Trends Cogn Sci
(2006) The representation of temporal information in perception and motor control
Curr Opin Neurobiol
(1996)- et al.
Distinct systems for automatic and cognitively controlled time measurement: evidence from neuroimaging
Curr Opin Neurobiol
(2003) - et al.
The neural representation of time
Curr Opin Neurobiol
(2004) - et al.
The ‘when’ pathway of the right parietal lobe
Trends Cogn Sci
(2007) - et al.
Cerebellar activation during discrete and not continuous timed movements: an fMRI study
Neuroimage
(2007) - et al.
Expectancy, attention, and time
Cognit Psychol
(2000) - et al.
Brain activation patterns during measurement of sub- and supra-second intervals
Neuropsychologia
(2003) - et al.
Effect of task difficulty on the functional anatomy of temporal processing
Neuroimage
(2006) - et al.
Basal ganglia and supplementary motor area subtend duration perception: an fMRI study
Neuroimage
(2003)
Time perception: manipulation of task difficulty dissociates clock functions from other cognitive demands
Neuropsychologia
The substantia nigra pars compacta and temporal processing
J Neurosci
A parametric fMRI investigation of context effects in sensorimotor timing and coordination
Neuropsychologia
Effector-independent voluntary timing: behavioural and neuroimaging evidence
Eur J Neurosci
The role of the cerebellum in subsecond time perception: evidence from repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation
J Cogn Neurosci
Attentional modulation in visual cortex depends on task timing
Nature
A representation of the hazard rate of elapsed time in macaque area LIP
Nat Neurosci
The roles of timing and task order during task switching
Neuroimage
Rhythm and beat perception in motor areas of the brain
J Cogn Neurosci
Difficulty of perceptual spatiotemporal integration modulates the neural activity of left inferior parietal cortex
Neuroscience
Learning of sequences of finger movements and timing: frontal lobe and action-oriented representation
J Neurophysiol
Functional organization of the lateral premotor cortex: fMRI reveals different regions activated by anticipation of object properties, location and speed
Brain Res Cogn Brain Res
The neural correlate of speech rhythm as evidenced by metrical speech processing
J Cogn Neurosci
The left parietal and premotor cortices: motor attention and selection
Neuroimage
Dynamics of hemispheric specialization and integration in the context of motor control
Nat Rev Neurosci
Where and when to pay attention: the neural systems for directing attention to spatial locations and to time intervals as revealed by both PET and fMRI
J Neurosci
Interval and ordinal properties of sequences are associated with distinct premotor areas
Cereb Cortex
The neural basis of temporal processing
Annu Rev Neurosci
Activation of the supplementary motor area and of attentional networks during temporal processing
Exp Brain Res
Dissociation of explicit and implicit timing in repetitive tapping and drawing movements
J Exp Psychol Hum Percept Perform
Attentional preparation based on temporal expectancy modulates processing at the perceptual level
Psychon Bull Rev
Cited by (416)
Time perception in stimulant-dependent participants undergoing repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation
2024, Behavioural Brain ResearchRoles of the cerebellum and basal ganglia in temporal integration: Insights from a synchronized tapping task
2024, Clinical NeurophysiologyAttention in flux
2023, NeuronEmbodying Time in the Brain: A Multi-Dimensional Neuroimaging Meta-Analysis of 95 Duration Processing Studies
2024, Neuropsychology ReviewPitch Improvement in Attentional Blink: A Study across Audiovisual Asymmetries
2024, Behavioral Sciences