Abstract
Complexity is an accepted characteristic of social-ecological systems. However, its analysis has been mostly theoretical with few empirical studies. Complex systems share three features: radical openness (the system cannot be understood unless an extended, global, environment is considered), radical uncertainty (emergence and non-linearity make them impossible to be fully predictable) and contextuality (no unique way to know them). Social-ecological systems listed as important under international treaties, such as wetlands within the Ramsar Convention, share these features, which can be explored using case studies. In this article, we explore the complexities derived from the 2004 ecological change (i.e. the local collapse of an emblematic bird species) in the Carlos Anwandter Sanctuary, a Chilean coastal wetland, by means of two ten-year windows (scientific publications and Internet web pages). We based our analysis on the question: what is the state of knowledge, ten years after its ecological change? Results show many answers; science has several hypotheses with low testing possibilities. Still, civil society decided that only one (a forestry company guilty of producing the change) is valid. We discuss the role of international organizations when dealing with social-ecological conflicts and identify the conundrum that can develop in response to how these are handled.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Allan C (2009) Reviewing adaptive management through a wicked lens. In: Lane M, Robinson C, Taylor B (eds) Contested country: local and regional natural resources management in Australia. CSIRO Publishing, Brisbane, pp 215–226
Audouin M, Preiser R, Nienaber S, Downsborough L, Lanz J, Mavengahama S (2013) Exploring the implications of critical complexity for the study of social-ecological systems. Ecology and Society 18(3):12. doi:10.5751/ES-05434-180312
Bennett EM, Cramer W, Begossi A, Cundill G, Díaz S, Egoh BN, Geijzendorffer IR, Krug CB, Lavorel S, Lazoz E, Lebel L, Martín-López B, Meyfroidt P, Mooney HA, Nel JL, Pascual U, Payet K, Pérez Harguindeguy N, Peterson GD, Prieur-Richard H-A, Reyers B, Roebeling P, Seppelt R, Solan M, Tschakert P, Tscharntke T, Turner BL II, Verburg PH, Viglizzo EF, White PC, Woorward G (2015) Linking biodiversity, ecosystem services, and human well-being: three challenges for designing research for sustainability. Current Opinion in Environment Sustainability 14:76–85
Bio-Bio (2013) Fallo-Celco. http://media.biobiochile.cl/wp-content/uploads/2013/07/Fallo-Celco.pdf
Capra F, Luisi PL (2014) The systems view of life. A unifying vision. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Carpenter SR, Stanley EH, Vander Zanden MJ (2011) State of the world’s freshwater ecosystems: physical, chemical, and biological changes. Annual Review of Environment and Resources 36:75–99
CCS (2016a) Consejo Científico Social. Humedal Río Cruces. http://www.humedalriocruces.cl
CCS (2016b) UACh entregó diagnóstico del estado del humedal del Río Cruces. http://www.humedalriocruces.cl/uach-entrego-diagnostico-del-estado-del-humedal-del-rio-cruces/
CEACHILE (2012) Humedales del Río Cruces. http://www.ceachile.cl/Cruces/not23_10.htm
CELCO (2013) Arauco. Declaración Pública. http://www.futurorenovable.cl/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/Declaración-Pública-Arauco.png
CH_RC (2016) Sistematización consultas públicas. Programa de Desarrollo Comunitario Humedal Río Cruces. http://www.comunidadhumedal.cl/documentos/
Chu D, Strand R, Fjelland R (2003) Theories of complexity. Common denominators of complex systems. Complexity 8:19–30
CONAF (2016) Santuario de la naturaleza Carlos Anwandter. Informe monitoreo avifauna Abril 2016. Parques Nacionales. Centro de Documentación. Corporación Nacional Forestal. Ministerio de Agricultura. Gobierno de Chile. http://www.conaf.cl/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/Abril-2-2016.pdf
Cox B (2013) Condenan a Celulosa Arauco por desastre ambiental en Río Cruces de Valdivia el 2004. http://olca.cl/articulo/nota.php?id=103354
Delgado LE, Marín VH (2005) FES-sistema: un concepto para la incorporación de las sociedades humanas en el análisis medioambiental de Chile. Revista Ambiente y Desarrollo de CIPMA 2:18–22
Delgado LE, Marín VH (2013) Interannual changes in the habitat area of the black-necked swan, Cygnus melancoryphus, in the Carlos Anwandter sanctuary, southern Chile: a remote sensing approach. Wetlands 33:91–99
Delgado LE, Marín VH, Bachmann PL, Torres-Gomez M (2009) Conceptual models for ecosystem management through the participation of local social actors: the Río cruces wetland conflict. Ecology and Society 14(1):50
Delgado LE, Sepúlveda MB, Marín VH (2013) Provision of ecosystem services by the Aysén watershed, Chilean Patagonia, to rural households. Ecosystem Services 5:102–109
Delgado LE, Tironi A, Vila I, Verardi G, Ibañez C, Agüero B, Marín VH (2014) El Humedal del Río Cruces, Valdivia, Chile: una síntesis ecosistémica. Latin American Journal of Aquatic Research 42:937–949
EMOL (2013) Condenan a Celulosa Arauco por daño ambiental que provocó muerte de cisnes en Valdivia. http://www.emol.com/noticias/nacional/2013/07/27/611350/condenan-a-celulosa-arauco-por-dano-ambiental-que-provoco-muerte-de-cisnes-en-valdivia.html
EMOL (2016) Penetración de internet en Chile alcanza el 84% con un fuerte uso de las redes móviles. http://www.emol.com/noticias/Tecnologia/2016/12/15/835694/Penetracion-de-internet-en-Chile-alcanza-el-84-con-fuerte-uso-de-las-redes-moviles.html
Finlayson CM (1996a). The Montreux record: a mechanism for supporting the wise use of wetlands. In Proceedings of the 6th meeting of the conference of the contracting parties of the convention on wetlands. Technical sessions: reports and presentations, 19–27 March 1996, Brisbane, Qld, Australia. Vol. 10/12 B, pp. 32–37. (Ramsar convention bureau: gland, Switzerland)
Finlayson CM (1996b) Framework for designing a monitoring programme. In: Monitoring Mediterranean wetlands: a methodological guide. (ed) P. T. Vives, pp. 25–34. MedWet publication, wetlands international: Slimbridge, UK; and ICN: Lisbon, Portugal
Finlayson CM (2012) Forty years of wetland conservation and wise use. Aquatic Conservation: Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems 22:139–143
Finlayson CM, Davidson N, Pritchard D, Milton R, MacKay H (2011) The Ramsar convention and ecosystem-based approaches for the wise use and sustainable development of wetlands. Journal of International Wildlife Law and Policy 14:176–198
Finlayson CM, Capon SJ, Rissik D, Pittock J, Fisk G, Davidson NC, Bodmin KA, Papas P, Robertson HA, Schallenberg M, Saintilan N, Edyvane K, Bino G (2017) Adapting policy and management for the conservation of important wetlands under a changing climate. Marine and Freshwater Research. doi:10.1071/MF16244
Frame B, Brown J (2008) Developing post-normal technologies for sustainability. Ecological Economics 65:225–241
Gell PA, Finlayson CM, Davidson NC (2016) Understanding change in the ecological character of Ramsar wetlands: perspectives from a deeper time – synthesis. Marine and Freshwater Research 67:869–879
Geymonat L (2006) Historia de la filosofía y de la ciencia. Crítica S. L, Barcelona
Gonzalez AL, Farina JM (2013) Changes in the abundance and distribution of black-necked swans (Cygnus Melancoryphus) in the Carlos Anwandter nature sanctuary and adjacent wetlands, Valdivia, Chile. Waterbirds 36:507–514
Guimarães Pereira Â, Guedes Vaz S, Tognetti S (2006) Interfaces between science and society. Greenleaf Publishing, Sheffield
Hauenstein E (2004) Antecedentes sobre Egeria densa (Cluchecillo), hidrófita importante en la alimentación del cisne de cuello negro. Gestión Ambiental 10:89–95
Hesselink F, Goldstein W, van Kempen PP, Garnett T, Dela J (2006) Communication, education and public awareness (CEPA). A toolkit for National Focal Points and NBSAP coordinators. Convention on Biological Diversity, IUCN, CEC. http://www.ramsar.org/sites/default/files/documents/library/cepa_toolkit_english.pdf
Hettiarachchi M, Morrison TH, McAlpine C (2015) Forty-three years of Ramsar and urban wetlands. Global Environmental Change 32:57–66
Horwitz P, Finlayson CM, Weinstein P (2012) Healthy wetlands, healthy people. A review of wetlands and human health interactions. Ramsar technical report N° 6. http://www.ramsar.org/sites/default/files/documents/pdf/lib/rtr6-health.pdf
Ibelings BW, Portielje R, Lammens EHRR, Noordhuis R, van den Berg MS, Joosse W, Meijer ML (2007) Resilience of alternative stable states during the recovery of shallow lakes from eutrophication: Lake Veluwe as a case stiudy. Ecosystems 10:4–16
Jones N, Clark JRA, Panteli M, Proikaki M, Dimitrakopoulos PG (2012) Local social capital and the acceptance of protected area policies: an empirical study of two Ramsar river delta ecosystems in northern Greece. Journal of Environmental Management 96:55–63
Kay JJ (2000) Ecosystems as self-organising holarchic open systems: narratives and the law of thermodynamics. In: Jørgensen SE, Müller F (eds) Handbook of ecosystem theories. Lewis Publishers, Boca Raton, pp 135–159
Kopf RK, Finlayson CM, Humphries P, Sims NC, Hladyz S (2015) Anthropocene baselines: assessing change and managing biodiversity in human-dominated aquatic ecosystems. Bioscience 65:798–811
La Nación (2005) Último informe ambiental culpa a Celulosa Arauco. http://www.lanacion.cl/noticias/pais/ultimo-informe-ambiental-culpa-a-celulosa-arauco/2005-02-20/212211.html
Lagos NA, Paolini P, Jaramillo E, Lovengreen C, Duarte C, Contreras H (2008) Environmental processes, water quality degradation, and decline of waterbird populations in the Rio cruces wetland, Chile. Wetlands 28:938–950
Liu J, Dietz TH, Carpenter SR, Alberti M, Folke C, Moran E, Pell AN, Deadman P, Kratz T, Lubchenco J, Ostrom E, Ouyang ZH, Provencher W, Redman CHL, Schneider SH, Taylor WW (2007) Complexity of coupled human and natural systems. Science 317:1513–1516
Lopetegui EJ, Vollmann RS, Cifuentes HC, Valenzuela CD, Suarez NL, Herbach EP, Huepe JU, Jaramillo GV, Leischner BP, Riveros RS (2007) Emigration and mortality of black-necked swans (Cygnus Melancoryphus) and disappearance of the macrophyte Egeria Densa in a Ramsar wetland site of southern Chile. Ambio 37:607–609
Lynch AJJ, Kalumanga E, Ospina GA (2016) Socio-ecological aspects of sustaining Ramsar wetlands in three biodiverse developing countries. Marine and Freshwater Research 67:850–868
Marín VH, Delgado LE (2013) From ecology to society and back: the (in)convenient hypothesis syndrome. International Journal of Sustainable Development 16:46–65
Marín V, Tironi A, Delgado L, Contreras M, Novoa F, Torres-Gómez M, Garreaud R, Vila I, Serey I (2009) On the sudden disappearance of Egeria Densa from Ramsar wetland site of southern Chile: a climate event trigger model. Ecological Modelling 220:1752–1763
Marín VH, Delgado LE, Vila I, Tironi A, Barrera V, Ibañez C (2014) Regime shifts of Cruces River wetland ecosystem: current conditions, future uncertainties. Latin American Journal of Aquatic Research 42:160–171
Mauerhofer V, Kim RE, Stevens C (2015) When implementation works: a comparison of Ramsar convention implementation in different continents. Environmental Science & Policy 51:95–105
MEA (2005) Ecosystems and human well-being: wetlands and water synthesis. Millennium Ecosystem Assesment World Resources Institute, Washington, DC
Mulsow S, Grandjean M (2006) Incompatibility of sulphate compounds and soluble bicarbonate salts in the Rio cruces waters: an answer to the disappearance of Egeria Densa and black-necked swans in a RAMSAR sanctuary. Ethics in Science and Environmental Politics 6:5–11
Nelson TJ (2016) What is the role of consensus in science? http://www.randombio.com/consensus.html
OECD (2005) Environmental performance reviews. Chile. Conclusions and recommendations. Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development UN Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean. http://www.oecd.org/env/country-reviews/34856244.pdf
OECD (2017) Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development. http://www.oecd.org/
Opazo K (2014) Aplicación del ciclo adaptativo de Holling a los sistemas socio-ecológicos de la sub-cuenca del humedal del Río Cruces. Seminario de Título para optar al título de Biólogo Ambiental con mención en medio ambiente. Facultad de Ciencias, Universidad de Chile
Palma ATC, Schwarz AO, Farina JM (2013a) Experimental evidence of the tolerance to chlorate of the aquatic macrophyte Egeria Densa in a Ramsar wetland in southern Chile. Wetlands 33:129–140
Palma ATC, Schwarz AO, Henriquez L, Alvarez X, Farina JM (2013b) Do subtoxic levels of chlorate influence the desiccation tolerance of Egeria Densa? Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry 32:417–422
Palma-Fleming H, Foitzick M, Palma-Larrea X, Quiroz-Reyes E (2013) The fate of alpha-Pinene in sediments of a wetland polluted by bleached pulp mill effluent: is it a new clue on the "Carlos Anwandter" nature sanctuary wetland case, Valdivia, south of Chile? Water, Air, and Soil Pollution 224(10). doi:10.1007/s11270-013-1729-4
Pinochet D, Ramirez C, Mac Donald R, Riedel L (2005) Concentraciones de elementos minerales en Egeria densa Planch. colectada en el santuario de la Naturaleza Carlos Anwandter, Valdivia, Chile. Agro Sur 32:80–86
Preiser R (2012) The problem of complexity. Re-thinking the role of critique. Dissertation presented for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy at Stellenbosh University, South Africa
Ramírez C, Carrasco E, Silvana M, Palacios N (2006) La desaparición del luchecillo (Egeria densa) del Santuario del Río Cruces (Valdivia, Chile): Una hipótesis plausible. Ciencia & Trabajo 8:79–86
Ramsar (2010) Managing wetlands: frameworks for managing wetlands of international importance and other wetland sites. Ramsar handbooks for the wise use of wetlands, vol 18, 4th edn. Ramsar Convention Secretariat, Gland
Ramsar (2015) Informe Nacional a la COP12 de Ramsar. http://www.ramsar.org/sites/default/files/documents/2014/national-reports/COP12/cop12_nr_chile.pdf
Ramsar (2017) The Ramsar Convention on wetlands of International Importance. http://www.ramsar.org
Ravetz J (2006) Post-normal science and the complexity of transitions towards sustainability. Ecological Complexity 3:275–284
Risk MJ, Burchell M, de Roo K, Nairn R, Tubrett M, Forsterra G (2010) Trace elements in bivalve shells from the Río cruces, Chile. Aquatic Biology 10:85–97
Rogers KH, Luton R, Biggs H, Biggs R, Blignaut S, Choles AG, Palmer CG, Tangwe P (2013) Fostering complexity thinking in action research for change in social–ecological systems. Ecology and Society 18(2):31
RSIS (2017) Carlos Anwandter sanctuary. Ramsar Sites Information Service. https://rsis.ramsar.org/ris/222
Sáez RE (2010) La OECD y el ingreso de Chile. Estudios Internacionales 166:93–112
SAG (2005) Evaluación de la condición Ambiental del Río Cruces, Informe Final Parte A. Servicio Agrícola Ganadero, Gobierno de Chile
San Martín C, Ramirez C, Carrasco E, Vidal O, Toledo G (2010) Efecto de la radiación solar en la desaparición de Egeria densa (Hydrocharitaceae) desde el humedal del río Cruces (Valdivia, Chile). Agro-Ciencia. Rev Chil Cs Agropec 26:15–24
Schaefer K, Einax JW (2010) Analytical and chemometric characterization of the Cruces River in South Chile. Environmental Science and Pollution Research 17:115–123
Schmitz OJ (2010) Resolving ecosystem complexity. Princeton University Press, Princeton
Schwarz AO, Urrutia H, Vidal JM, Pérez N (2012) Chlorate reduction capacity and characterisation of chlorate reducing bacteria communities in sediments of the río cruces wetland in southern Chile. Water Research 46:3283–3292
Sepúlveda C, Bettati B (2005) El desastre ecológico del Santuario del Río Cruces: Trizadura institucional y retroceso democrático. Revista Ambiente y Desarrollo 20-21(3–1):62–68
SER (2004) Society for Ecological Restoration International and IUCN Commission on Ecosystem Management. 2004. Ecological restoration, a means of conserving biodiversity and sustaining livelihoods. Society for Ecological Restoration International,IUCN, Tucson, Gland http://www.ser.org/docs/default-document-library/ser-iucn-global-rationale.pdf?sfvrsn=2
Summers RS (1999) Formal legal truth and substantive truth in judicial fact-finding- their divergence in some particular cases. Law and Philosophy 18:497–511
UACH (2005) Estudio sobre origen de mortalidades y disminución poblacional de aves acuáticas en el Santuario de la Naturaleza Carlos Anwandter en la provincia de Valdivia. http://www.sinia.cl/1292/articles-31665_segundoinformeCisnes.pdf
Van den Belt M (2004) Mediated modelling. A system dynamics approach to environmental concensus building. Island Press, Washington, DC
Vervoort JM, Keuskamp DH, Kok K, van Lammeren R, Stolk T, Veldkamp TA, Rekveld J, Schelfhout R, Teklenburg B, Cavalheiro Borges A, Jánoškóva A, Wits W, Assmann N, Abdi Dezfouli E, Cunningham K, Nordeman B, Rowlands H (2014) A sense of change: media designers and artists communicating about complexity in social-ecological systems. Ecology and Society 19(3):10
Waltner-Toews D, Kay JJ, Lister NME (2008) The ecosystem approach. Complexity, uncertainty, and managing for sustainability. Columbia University Press, New York
Yarrow M, Marín VH, Finlayson M, Tironi A, Delgado LE, Fischer F (2009) The ecology of Egeria densa Planchon (Liliopsida: Alismatales): a wetland ecosystem engineer. Revista Chilena de Historia Natural 82:299–313
Acknowledgements
This research was funded by Universidad de Chile (Enlace FONDECYT, VID 2015, grant number ENL001/15).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Annex I
Annex I
Table 2
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Marín, V.H., Delgado, L.E., Tironi-Silva, A. et al. Exploring Social-Ecological Complexities of Wetlands of International Importance (Ramsar Sites): the Carlos Anwandter Sanctuary (Valdivia, Chile) as a Case Study. Wetlands 38, 1171–1182 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1007/s13157-017-0935-z
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s13157-017-0935-z