Abstract
We analyze the cost of curtailing the active power output of a wind farm to provide secondary frequency regulation capacity. We calculate the regulation capacity available and its cost by simulating the active power output of a curtailed 100-MW wind farm with a hybrid of real wind speed data and simulated high-frequency turbulence. We find that a curtailed wind farm can provide secondary frequency regulation capacity at a cost lower than conventional generators in less than 1 % of the 1,440 1-h intervals studied. Although the operating cost of curtailing a wind farm for frequency regulation capacity is high, the capital cost of installing the hardware and software to enable curtailment for frequency regulation is low. For that reason, we suggest that it is reasonable that grid operators require wind farms to have the capability to curtail for frequency regulation, but we recommend that capability should be rarely used.
Similar content being viewed by others
Abbreviations
- \(R_\mathrm{max}(k)\) :
-
Max available upregulation capacity in \(k\mathrm{th}\) interval (MW-h)
- \(R (k|\Delta )\) :
-
Upregulation capacity in \(k\mathrm{th}\) interval, given curtailment of \(\Delta \) (MW-h)
- \(\Delta \) :
-
Curtailment of wind farm power output below the possible power output (MW)
- LOL:
-
Lower operating limit: minimum curtailed power (p.u.)
- \(P_\mathrm{poss}(t)\) :
-
Instantaneous possible power output of wind farm (MW)
- \(P_\mathrm{curt}(k|\Delta )\) :
-
Instantaneous curtailed power output of wind farm, given curtailment of \(\Delta \) (MW)
- \(P_{\mu }\)(k):
-
Mean wind farm power in the \(k\mathrm{th}\) interval (MW)
- \(P_\mathrm{COV}\)(k):
-
Coefficient of variation of wind farm power in the \(k\mathrm{th}\) interval (MW)
- \(E_{loss}(k|\Delta )\) :
-
Energy production lost to curtailment in the \(k\mathrm{th}\) interval (MWh)
- \(t\) :
-
Time (s)
- \(T\) :
-
Duration of frequency-regulation dispatch intervals (s)
- \(k\) :
-
Index of dispatch intervals
- \(AC (k|\Delta )\) :
-
Average (opportunity) cost of up-regulation capacity (MWh/MW-h)
- \(MC (k|\Delta )\) :
-
Marginal (opportunity) cost of up-regulation capacity (MWh/MW-h)
References
Brooks, D.: Evaluation of the Effectiveness of Automatic Generation Control (AGC) Alterations for Improved Control with Significant Wind Generation. Electric Power Research Institute, Palo Alto (2009)
Evaluation of the Impacts of Wind Generation on HELCO AGC and System Performance-Phase 2. Electric Power Research Institute, Palo Alto (2009)
Katzenstein, W., Apt, J.: Air emissions due to wind and solar power. Environ. Sci. Technol. 43, 253–258 (2009)
Tsili, M., Patsiouras, C., Papathanassiou, S.: Grid code requirements for large wind farms: a review of technical regulations and available wind turbine technologies. In: Proceedings of EWEC (2008)
Ramtharan, G., Jenkins, N., Ekanayake, J.: Frequency support from doubly fed induction generator wind turbines. IET Renew. Power Gener. 1, 3 (2007)
Singh, B., Singh, S.: Wind power interconnection into the power system: a review of grid code requirements. Electr. J. 22, 54–63 (2009)
EirGrid: EirGrid Grid Code: WFPS1, Controllable Wind Farm Power Station Grid Code Provisions, version 3.3. (2009)
de Almeida, R., Lopes, J.: Participation of doubly fed induction wind generators in system frequency regulation. IEEE Trans. Power Syst. 22, 944–950 (2007)
Holdsworth, L., Ekanayake, J., Jenkins, N.: Power system frequency response from fixed speed and doubly fed induction generator-based wind turbines. Wind Energy 7, 21–35 (2004)
Jecu, C., Teninge, A., Roye, D., Bacha, S., Belhomme, R., Bousseau, P.: Contribution to frequency control through wind turbine inertial energy storage. Presented at the 2008 European Wind Energy Conference & Exhibition, Brussels (2008)
Lubosny, Z., Bialek, J.: Supervisory control of a wind farm. IEEE Trans. Power Syst. 22, 985–994 (2007)
Rawn, B., Lehn, P., Maggiore, M.: Control methodology to mitigate the grid impact of wind turbines. IEEE Trans. Energy Convers. 22, 431–438 (2007)
Vigueras-Rodríguez, A., Sørensen, P., Cutululis, N.A., Viedma, A., Gómez-Lázaro, E., Martin, S.: Application of ramp limitation regulations for smoothing the power fluctuations from offshore wind farms. Presented at the 2009 European Wind Energy Conference and Exhibition, Brussels (2009)
Kirby, B., Milligan, M., Ela, E.: Providing minute-to-minute regulation from wind plants. Presented at the 9th Annual International Workshop on Large-Scale Integration of Wind Power into Power Systems, Quebec October 19 (2010)
Parsons, B., Milligan, M., Zavadil, B., Brooks, D.: Grid impacts of wind power: a summary of recent studies in the United States. Wind Energy 7, 87–108 (2004)
Ela, E., Milligan, M., Parsons, B., Lew, D., Corbus, D.: The evolution of wind power integration studies: past, present, and future. Presented at the IEEE Power & Energy Society General Meeting, 2009, Calgary July (2009)
Rose, S., Apt, J.: Generating wind time series as a hybrid of measured and simulated data. Wind Energy 15, 699–715 (2012)
Veers, P.S.: Three-dimensional wind simulation. SAND88-0152. 40 (1988)
IEC 61400–1: Wind Turbine Design Requirements (ed. 3.0). International Electrotechnical Commission, pp. 22–31 (2005)
Sørensen, P., Cutululis, N.A., Vigueras-Rodríguez, A., Madsen, H., Pinson, P., Jensen, L.E., Hjerrild, J., Donovan, M.H.: Modelling of power fluctuations from large offshore wind farms. Wind Energy 11, 29–43 (2008)
De Tommasi, L., Gibescu, M., Brand, A.J.: A dynamic aggregate model for the simulation of short term power fluctuations. Procedia Comput. Sci. 1, 269–278 (2010)
Sørensen, P., Cutululis, N.A., Vigueras-Rodríguez, A., Jensen, L.E., Hjerrild, J., Donovan, M.H., Madsen, H.: Power fluctuations from large wind farms. IEEE Trans. Power Syst. 22, 958–965 (2007)
Jonkman, J., Butterfield, S., Musial, W., Scott, G.: Definition of a 5-MW reference wind turbine for offshore system development. National Renewable Energy Laboratory, Golden, CO (2009)
Grunnet, J.D., Soltani, M., Knudsen, T., Kragelund, M., Bak, T.: Aeolus toolbox for dynamics wind farm model, simulation and control. Presented at the 2010 European Wind Energy Conference & Exhibition, Warsaw April 22 (2010)
Elkraft, Eltra: Wind turbines connected to grids with voltage above 100 kV (2004)
Hansen, A.D., Sørensen, P., Iov, F., Blaabjerg, F.: Centralised power control of wind farm with doubly fed induction generators. Renew. Energy 31, 935–951 (2006)
Koenker, R., Bassett, G.: Regression quantiles. Econometrica 46, 33–50 (1978)
Koenker, R.: quantreg: Quantile Regression. http://CRAN.R-project.org/package=quantreg
R Core Team: R: a language and environment for statistical computing. http://www.R-project.org/
Vaz, S., Martin, C.S., Eastwood, P.D., Ernande, B., Carpentier, A., Meaden, G.J., Coppin, F.: Modelling species distributions using regression quantiles. J. Appl. Ecol. 45, 204–217 (2007)
ERCOT: Day-ahead ancillary services market clearing prices for capacity archives. http://www.ercot.com/mktinfo/prices/mcpc
Wiser, R., Bolinger, M.: 2010 Wind technologies market, report (2011)
Acknowledgments
This work was supported in part by the EPA STAR fellowship program, a grant from the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation and EPRI to the Carnegie Mellon Electricity Industry Center, and by the Doris Duke Charitable Foundation, the Department of Energy National Energy Technology Laboratory, the R.K. Mellon Foundation and the Heinz Endowments for support of the RenewElec program at Carnegie Mellon University. This research was also supported in part by the Climate and Energy Decision Making (CEDM) center. This Center has been created through a cooperative agreement between the National Science Foundation (SES-0949710) and Carnegie Mellon University.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Electronic supplementary material
Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Rose, S., Apt, J. The cost of curtailing wind turbines for secondary frequency regulation capacity. Energy Syst 5, 407–422 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12667-013-0093-1
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12667-013-0093-1