Abstract
During 2009, while we were celebrating Charles Darwin and his The origin of species, sadly, little was said about the critical contribution of Alfred Russel Wallace (1823–1913) to the development of the theory of evolution. Like Darwin, he was a truly remarkable nineteenth century intellect and polymath and, according to a recent book by Roy Davies (The Darwin conspiracy: origins of a scientific crime), he has a stronger claim to the Theory of Evolution by Natural Selection than has Darwin. Here we present a critical comparison between the contributions of the two scientists. Sometimes referred to as ‘The other beetle-hunter’ and largely neglected for many decades, Wallace had a far greater experience of collecting and investigating animals and plants from their native habitats than had Darwin. He was furthermore much more than a pioneer biogeographer and evolutionary theorist, and also made contributions to anthropology, ethnography, geology, land reform and social issues. However, being a more modest, self-deprecating man than Darwin, and lacking the latter’s establishment connections, Wallace’s contribution to the theory of evolution was not given the recognition it deserved and he was undoubtedly shabbily treated at the time. It is time that Wallace’s relationship with Darwin is reconsidered in preparation for 2013, the centenary of Wallace’s death, and he should be recognized as at least an equal in the Wallace-Darwin theory of evolution.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Anonymous 2008 Wallace defends Darwin’s priority — 50 years on; in Survival of the fittest: celebrating 150 th anniversary of the Darwin-Wallace Theory of Evolution (eds) B Gardiner, R Milner and M Morris (London: The Linnean Society)
Beddall B G 1968 Wallace, Darwin and the theory of natural selection: a study in the development of ideas and attitudes; J. Hist. Biol. 1 261–324
Brackman A C 1980 A delicate arrangement: the strange case of Charles Darwin and Alfred Russel Wallace (New York: Times Books)
Brooks J L 1984 Just before the origin: Alfred Russel Wallace’s theory of evolution (New York: Columbia University Press)
Browne E J 2002 The power of place. Vol. 2 of Charles Darwin (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press)
Chambers R 1844 Vestiges of the natural history of creation (London: John Churchill)
Claridge M 2008 Alfred Russel Wallace — a Welsh entomologist!; in The Linnean Society. Special issue No 9: Survival of the fittest (eds) B Gardiner, R Milner and M Morris (London: the Linnean Society) pp 17–24
Davies R 2008 The Darwin conspiracy: origins of a scientific crime (London: Golden Square Books)
Darlington C D 1959 Darwin’s place in history (Oxford: Blackwell)
Desmond A and Moore J 1991 Darwin (London: Michael Joseph)
Eisley L C 1979 Darwin and the mysterious Mr. X: new light on the evolutionists (London: J M Dent)
Eiseley L C 2009 Darwin’s century: evolution and the men who discovered it (New York: Barnes and Noble, reprint of the first edition of 1958)
Fichman M 2004 An elusive Victorian: the evolution of Alfred Russel Wallace (Chicago: Chicago University Press)
Hughes R E 1989 Alfred Russel Wallace; some notes on the Welsh connection; Br. J. Hist. Sci. 22 401–418
Hughes R E 1991 Alfred Russel Wallace (1823–1913): the making of a scientific non-conformist; Proc. R. Inst. 63 175–183
Marchant J 1916 Alfred Russel Wallace: letters and reminiscences, 2 volumes (London: Cassell)
McKinney H L 1966 Alfred Russel Wallace and the discovery of natural selection; J. Hist. Med. Allied Sci. 21 333–357
Michaux B 2000 http://people.wku.edu/charles.smith/wallace/S020.htm
Michaux B 2008 Alfred Russel Wallace, biogeographer; in Natural selection and beyond: the intellectual legacy of Alfred Russel Wallace (eds) C H Smith and G Beccaloni (Oxford: Oxford University Press)
Moore J 2006 Wallace in wonderland; Ann. Hist. Philos. Biol. 11 139–154
Nanjundiah V 2009 The origin of species after 150 years: one hundred and fifty years without Darwin are enough; Resonance 14 124–153
Raby R 2001 Alfred Russel Wallace: a life ( London: Chatto and Windus)
Slotten R A 2004 The heretic in Darwin’s court: the life of Alfred Russel Wallace (New York: Columbia University Press)
Smith C H (ed.) 1991 Alfred Russel Wallace: an anthology of his shorter writings (Oxford: Oxford University Press)
Smith C H 2008 Wallace’s unfinished business; in Natural selection and beyond: the intellectual legacy of Alfred Russel Wallace (eds) C H Smith and G Beccaloni (Oxford: Oxford University Press)
Smith C H and Beccaloni G (eds) 2008 Natural selection and beyond: the intellectual legacy of Alfred Russel Wallace (Oxford: Oxford University Press)
Sulloway F J 2009 Why Darwin rejected intelligent design; J. Biosci. 34 173–183
Wallace A R 1855 On the law that has regulated the introduction of a new species; Ann. Mag. Nat. Hist. 16 184–196
Wallace A R 1858 Note on the theory of permanent and geographical varieties; Zoologist 16 5887–5888
Wallace A R 1876 The geographical distribution of animals, with a study of the relations of living and extinct faunas as elucidating the past changes of the earth’s surface, 2 vols (London: Macmillan)
Wallace A R 1880 Island life (London: Macmillan)
Wallace A R 1889 Darwinism: an exposition of the theory of natural selection with some of its applications (London: Macmillan)
Wallace A R 1901 Miracles and modern spiritualism; Reprint of 1896 rev. 3rd edition (London: Nichols)
Wallace A R 1908 My life (London: Chapman and Hall, reprinted Elibron Classics series 2005) Web citation: http://www.papuaweb.org
Wilson J G 2000 The forgotten naturalist: in search of Alfred Russel Wallace (Kew, Victoria: Australian Scholarly Publishing)
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Lloyd, D., Wimpenny, J. & Venables, A. Alfred Russel Wallace deserves better. J Biosci 35, 339–349 (2010). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12038-010-0039-x
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12038-010-0039-x