Skip to main content
Log in

Reflecting Before, During, and After the Heat of the Moment: A Review of Four Approaches for Supporting Health Staff to Manage Stressful Events

  • Critical Perspectives
  • Published:
Journal of Bioethical Inquiry Aims and scope Submit manuscript

Abstract

Being a healthcare professional in both paediatric and adult hospitals will mean being exposed to human tragedies and stressful events involving conflict, misunderstanding, and moral distress. There are a number of different structured approaches to reflection and discussion designed to support healthcare professionals process and make sense of their feelings and experiences and to mitigate against direct and vicarious trauma. In this paper, we draw from our experience in a large children’s hospital and more broadly from the literature to identify and analyse four established approaches to facilitated reflective discussions. Each of the four approaches seeks to acknowledge the stressful nature of health professional work and to support clinicians from all healthcare professions to develop sustainable skills so they continue to grow and thrive as health professionals. Each approach also has the potential to open up feelings of uncertainty, frustration, sorrow, anguish, and moral distress for participants. We argue, therefore, that in order to avoid unintentionally causing harm, a facilitator should have specific skills required to safely lead the discussion and be able to explain the nature, scope, safe application, and limits of each approach. With reference to a hypothetical but realistic clinical case scenario, we discuss the application and key features of each approach, including the goals, underpinning theory, and methods of facilitation.

This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.

Access this article

Price excludes VAT (USA)
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.

Instant access to the full article PDF.

Institutional subscriptions

Fig 1
Fig 2
Fig 3
Fig 4

Similar content being viewed by others

References

  • Agich, G.J. 1995. Authority in ethics consultation. The Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics 23(3): 273–283.

  • Alden, L.E., M. Regambal, and J. Laposa. 2008. The effects of direct versus witnessed threat on emergency department healthcare workers: implications for PTSD criterion A. Journal of Anxiety Disorders 22(8): 1337–1346.

  • Atallah, F., A. McCalla., S. Karakash, and H. Minkoff. 2016. Please put on your own oxygen mask before assisting others: A call to arms to battle burnout. American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology 215(6): 731.e1–731.e6.

  • Battin, M. 2013. Bioethics. International Encyclopedia of Ethics.

  • Bledsoe, B. 2003. Critical incident stress management: Benefit or risk for emergency services? Prehospital Emergency Care 7(2): 272–279.

  • Bloom, S. L. 2004. Neither liberty nor safety: The impact of fear on individuals, institutions, and societies, Part I. Psychotherapy and Politics International 2(2): 78–98.

  • Bond, M., and S. Holland. 2011. Skills of clinical supervision for nurses: A practical guide for supervisees, clinical supervisors and managers. McGraw-Hill Education.

  • Boss, R.D., G. Geller, and P. Donohue. 2015. Conflicts in learning to care for critically ill newborns: It makes me question my own morals. Journal of Bioethical Inquiry 12(3): 437–448.

  • Breen, L.J., M. O’Connor, L. Hewitt, and E. Lobb. 2014. The “specter” of cancer: Exploring secondary trauma for health professionals providing cancer support and counseling. Psychological Services 11(1): 60.

  • Burbules, N., and S. Rice. 1991. Dialogue across differences: Continuing the conversation. Harvard Educational Review 61(4): 393–417.

  • Chaukos, D., H. Vestal, C. Bernstein, et al. 2018. An ounce of prevention: A public health approach to improving physician well-being. Academic Psychiatry 42(1): 150–154.

  • Costello, S. 2020. Review of Supporting vulnerable babies and young children: Interventions for working with trauma, mental health, illness and other complex challenges, edited by W. Bunston and S. Jones. The British Journal of Social Work 51(6): 2264–2266.

  • Cotton, P. 2014. Workplace psychological health and wellbeing: An overview of key trends. InPsych 36(6): 9.

    Google Scholar 

  • Couper, K., and G. Perkins. 2013. Debriefing after resuscitation. Current Opinion in Critical Care 19(3): 188–194.

  • DiCicco-Bloom, B. and B. Crabtree. 2006. The qualitative research interview. Medical Education 40(4): 314–321.

  • Dyrbye, L.N., and T. Shanafelt. 2011. Physician burnout: A potential threat to successful health care reform. JAMA 305(19): 2009–2010.

  • Dyrbye, L.N., T. Shanafelt, C. Sinsky, et al. 2017. Burnout among health care professionals: A call to explore and address this underrecognized threat to safe, high-quality care. Discussion Paper, National Academy of Medicine, Washington. NAM Perspectives, July 5.

  • Edwards, M.P., S. McClement, and L. Read. 2013. Nurses’ responses to initial moral distress in long-term care. Journal of Bioethical Inquiry 10(3): 325–336.

  • Emmerich, N., G. Gormley, and M. McCullough. 2018. Ethics of healthcare simulation. In Healthcare simulation education: Evidence, theory and practice, edited by D. Nestel, M. Kelly, B. Jolly and M. Watson, 119–126. John Wiley and Sons.

  • Epstein, E.G., and A.B. Hamric. 2009. Moral distress, moral residue, and the crescendo effect. Journal of Clinical Ethics 20(4): 330–342.

  • Everly, G.S., and J. Mitchell. 2000. The debriefing “controversy” and crisis intervention: A review of lexical and substantive issues. International Journal of Emergency Mental Health 2(4): 211–226.

  • Fonagy, P., G. Gergely, and E. Jurist. 2018. Affect regulation, mentalization and the development of the self. Routledge.

  • Fonagy, P., and M. Target. 2005. Bridging the transmission gap: An end to an important mystery of attachment research? Attachment & Human Development 7(3): 333-343.

  • Foster, A. 2001. The duty to care and the need to split. Journal of Social Work Practice15(1): 81–90.

  • Gasdaglis, K. 2019. Moral regret and moral feeling(s). Inquiry 64(4) 424–452.

  • Gilkerson, L. 2004. Reflective supervision in infant-family programs: Adding clinical process to nonclinical settings. Irving B. Harris Distinguished Lecture. Infant Mental Health Journal 25(5): 424–439.

  • Gillam, L., C. Delany, M. Guillemin, and S. Warmington. 2014. The role of emotions in health professional ethics teaching. Journal of Medical Ethics 40(5): 331–335.

  • Gillon, R. 1997. “Futility”—too ambiguous and pejorative a term? Journal of Medical Ethics 23(6): 339.

  • Guidry-Grimes, L., M. Warren, H. Lipman, et al. 2019. Clarifying a clinical ethics service’s value, the visible and the hidden. Journal of Clinical Ethics 30(3): 251–261.

  • Hartwell, S. 2004. Moral growth or moral angst? A clinical approach. Clinical Law Review 11: 115.

  • Heffron, M.C., D. Reynolds, and B. Talbot. 2016. Reflecting together: Reflective functioning as a focus for deepening group supervision. Infant Mental Health Journal 37(6): 628–639.

  • Imbulana, D.I., P.G. Davis, and T.M. Prentice. 2021. Interventions to reduce moral distress in clinicians working in intensive care: A systematic review. Intensive and Critical Care Nursing 66: 103092.

  • Jameton, A. 1984. Nursing practice: The ethical issues. Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey: Prentice-Hall.

  • Jennings, M.L., and S. Slavin. 2015. Resident wellness matters: Optimizing resident education and wellness through the learning environment. Academic Medicine 90(9): 1246–1250.

  • Kelly, L. 2020. Burnout, compassion fatigue, and secondary trauma in nurses: Recognizing the occupational phenomenon and personal consequences of caregiving. Critical Care Nursing Quarterly 43(1): 73–80.

  • Kessler, D.O., A. Cheng, and P. Mullan. 2015. Debriefing in the emergency department after clinical events: A practical guide. Annals of Emergency Medicine 65(6): 690–698.

  • Komesaroff, P. 1995. Troubled bodies: Critical perspectives on postmodernism. In From bioethics to microethics: Ethical debate and clinical medicine, edited by P. Komesaroff, 62–86. Melbourne: Melbourne University Press.

  • Lane, P.S. 1994. Critical incident stress debriefing for health care workers. OMEGA: Journal of Death and Dying 28(4): 301–315.

  • Lützén, K., and B. Ewalds-Kvist. 2013. Moral distress and its interconnection with moral sensitivity and moral resilience: Viewed from the philosophy of Viktor E. Frankl. Journal of Bioethical Inquiry 10(3): 317–324.

  • McCullough, L.B. 2020. In response to COVID-19 pandemic physicians already know what to do. The American Journal of Bioethics 20(7): 9–12.

  • McDougall, R., C. Delany, and L. Gillam, eds. 2016. When doctors and parents disagree: Paediatrics, ethics and the zone of parental discretion. New South Wales: Federation Press.

  • McDougall, R., C. Delany, M. Spriggs, and L. Gillam. 2014. Collaboration in clinical ethics consultation: A method for achieving “balanced accountability.” American Journal of Bioethics 14(6): 47–48.

  • McDougall, R., C. Shadbolt, and L. Gillam. 2020. The practice of balancing in clinical ethics case consultation. Clinical Ethics 15(1): 49–55.

  • McMillan, J. 2018. The methods of bioethics: An essay in meta-bioethics. Oxford University Press.

  • Menzies, I.E.P. 1960. A case-study in the functioning of social systems as a defence against anxiety: A Report of a Study on the Nursing Service of a General Hospital. Human Relations 13(2): 95–121.

  • Meziane, D., M.P. Ramirez-Garcia, and M.L. Fortin. 2018. A reflective practice intervention to act on the moral distress of nurses providing end-of-life care on acute care units. International Journal of Palliative Nursing 24(9): 444–451.

  • Mezirow, J. 1991. Transformative dimensions of adult learning. ERIC.

  • Mihailescu, M., and E. Neiterman. 2019. A scoping review of the literature on the current mental health status of physicians and physicians-in-training in North America. BMC Public Health 19(1): 1363.

  • Mitchell, J. T. 1983. When disaster strikes … the critical incident stress debriefing process. JEMS 8(1): 36–39.

  • Mitchell, J. T, and G. Everly. 1995. Critical incident stress debriefing (CISD) and the prevention of work-related traumatic stress among high risk occupational groups. In Psychotraumatology: Key papers and core concepts in post-traumatic stress, edited by G.S. Everly, Jr. and J.M. Lating, 267–280. Plenum Press.

  • Mullan, P.C., D. Kessler, and A. Cheng. 2014. Educational opportunities with postevent debriefing. JAMA 312(22): 2333–2334.

  • Morley, G., R. Field, C. Horsburgh, and C. Burchill. 2021. Interventions to mitigate moral distress: A systematic review of the literature. International Journal of Nursing Studies 121: 103984.

  • Morley, G., and C. Horsburgh. 2021. Reflective debriefs as a response to moral distress: Two case study examples. HEC Forum. ePub ahead of print, Januart 26. doi: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10730-021-09441-z

  • Newson, A.J. 2015. The value of clinical ethics support in Australian health care. Medical Journal of Australia 202(11): 568–569.

  • Nordentoft, H.M. 2008. Changes in emotion work at interdisciplinary conferences following clinical supervision in a palliative outpatient ward. Qualitative Health Research 18(7): 913–927.

  • Nussbaum, M.C. 1994. The therapy of desire: Theory and practice in Hellenistic ethics. Princeton University Press.

  • O’Keeffe, M.J., and D. Shelton. 2007. Personal supervision for paediatricians. Journal of Paediatrics and Child Health 43(3): 103–106.

  • Obholzer, A. and V. Zagier Roberts. 2003. The unconscious at work: Individual and organizational stress in the human services. Routledge.

  • Panagioti, M., K. Geraghty, J. Johnson, et al. 2018. Association between physician burnout and patient safety, professionalism, and patient satisfaction: A systematic review and meta-analysis. JAMA Internal Medicine 178(10): 1317–1331.

  • Panagioti, M., E. Panagopoulou, P. Bower, et al. 2017. Controlled interventions to reduce burnout in physicians: A systematic review and meta-analysis. JAMA Internal Medicine 177(2): 195–205.

  • Parlakian, R. 2002. Reflective supervision in practice: Stories from the field. Zero to Three Center for Program Excellence.

  • Pawl, J.H. 1995. Educating and supporting the infant/family work force: Models, methods and materials. Zero to Three 15(3): 21–29.

  • Prentice, T., A. Janvier, L. Gillam and P.G. Davis. 2016. Moral distress within neonatal and paediatric intensive care units: A systematic review. Archives of Disease in Childhood 101(8): 701–708.

  • Prentice, T., L. Gillam, P. Davis, and A. Janvier. 2018. The use and misuse of moral distress in neonatology. Seminars in Fetal and Neonatal Medicine 23(1): 39–43.

  • Rose, S., J. Bisson, R. Churchill, and S. Wessely. 2002. Psychological debriefing for preventing post traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2: CD000560.

  • Rudolph, J.W., R. Simon, P. Rivard, R. Dufresne, and D. Raemer. 2007. Debriefing with good judgment: Combining rigorous feedback with genuine inquiry. Anesthesiology Clinics 25(2): 361–376.

  • Rushton, C.H., S. Swoboda, N. Reller, et al. 2021. Mindful ethical practice and resilience academy: Equipping nurses to address ethical challenges. American Journal of Critical Care 30(1): e1–e11.

  • Scher, S., and K. Kozlowska. 2018. Rethinking health care ethics. Springer Nature.

  • Schmutz, J. B., Z. Lei, W. Eppich, and T. Manser. 2018. Reflection in the heat of the moment: The role of in-action team reflexivity in health care emergency teams. Journal of Organizational Behavior 39(6): 749–765.

  • Shultz, J.M., and Forbes, D. 2014.Psychological first aid: Rapid proliferation and the search for evidence. Disaster Health 2(1): 3–12.

  • Siegel, D. J. 2007. Mindfulness training and neural integration: Differentiation of distinct streams of awareness and the cultivation of well-being. Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience 2(4): 259–263.

  • Terry, D., H. Nguyen, A. Perkins, and B. Peck. 2020. Supervision in healthcare: A critical review of the role, function and capacity for training. Universal Journal of Public Health 8(1): 1–14.

  • Udo, C., C. Melin-Johansson, and E. Danielson. 2011. Existential issues among health care staff in surgical cancer care—discussions in supervision sessions. European Journal of Oncology Nursing 15(5): 447–453.

  • Vaithilingam, N., S. Jain, and D. Davies. 2008. Helping the helpers: Debriefing following an adverse incident. The Obstetrician & Gynaecologist 10(4): 251–256.

  • Verkerk, M., and H. Lindemann. 2012. Toward a naturalized clinical ethics. Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 22(4): 289–306.

  • West, C.P., L. Dyrbye, P. Erwin, and T.Shanafelt. 2016. Interventions to prevent and reduce physician burnout: A systematic review and meta-analysis. The Lancet 388(10057): 2272–2281.

  • World Health Organization, War Trauma Foundation, and World Vision International. 2011. Psychological first aid: Guide for field workers. World Health Organization. https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789241548205. Accessed 3/11/21.

Download references

Author information

Authors and Affiliations

Authors

Corresponding author

Correspondence to C. Delany.

Additional information

Publisher’s note

Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.

Rights and permissions

Reprints and permissions

About this article

Check for updates. Verify currency and authenticity via CrossMark

Cite this article

Delany, C., Jones, S., Sokol, J. et al. Reflecting Before, During, and After the Heat of the Moment: A Review of Four Approaches for Supporting Health Staff to Manage Stressful Events. Bioethical Inquiry 18, 573–587 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11673-021-10140-0

Download citation

  • Received:

  • Accepted:

  • Published:

  • Issue Date:

  • DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11673-021-10140-0

Keywords

Navigation