Abstract
Over the past years, a number of probabilistic measures of coherence have been proposed. As shown in the paper, however, many of them do not conform to the intuitition that equivalent testimonies are highly coherent, regardless of their prior probability.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Bartelborth T. (1996). Begründungsstrategien. Ein Weg durch die analytische Erkenntnistheorie. Akademie-Verlag, Berlin
Bovens L., Hartmann S. (2003a). Solving the riddle of coherence. Mind 112, 601–633
Bovens L., Hartmann S. (2003b). Bayesian epistemology. Oxford University Press, New York and Oxford
Bovens L., Olsson E.J. (2000). Coherentism, reliability and Bayesian networks. Mind 109, 685–719
Bovens L., Olsson E.J. (2002). Believing more, risking less: On coherence, truth and non-trivial extensions. Erkenntnis 57, 137–150
Carnap R. (1950). Logical foundations of probability. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Christensen D. (1999). Measuring confirmation. The Journal of Philosophy 96, 437–461
Douven, I., & Meijs, W. (2007). Measuring coherence. Synthese (Forthcoming), DOI: 10.1007/s11229-006-9131-z.
Eells E., Fitelson B. (2002). Symmetries and asymmetries in evidential support. Philosophical Studies 107, 129–142
Finch H.A. (1960). Confirming power of observations metricized for decisions among hypotheses. Philosophy of Science 27, 293–307
Fitelson B. (1999). The plurality of Bayesian measures of confirmation and the problem of measure sensitivity. Philosophy of Science, 66 (Proceedings), S362–S378
Fitelson, B. (2001). Studies in Bayesian confirmation theory. Ph.D. thesis, University of Wisconsin at Madison. Online: http://fitelson.org/thesis.pdf.
Fitelson B. (2003). A probabilistic theory of coherence. Analysis 63, 194–199
Fitelson, B. (2004). Two technical corrections to my coherence measure. Online: http://fitelson.org/ coherence2.pdf.
Gillies D. (1986). In defense of the Popper-Miller argument. Philosophy of Science 53, 110–113
Good I.J. (1984). The best explicatum for weight of evidence. Journal of Statistical Computation and Simulation 19, 294–299
Horwich, P. (1998). Wittgensteinian Bayesianism. In: Curd M., Cover J.A. (eds). Philosophy of science: The central issues. Norton, New York and London, pp. 607–624
Jeffrey R. (1992). Probability and the art of judgement. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Kemeny J., Oppenheim P. (1952). Degrees of factual support. Philosophy of Science 19, 307–324
Klein P., Warfield T.A. (1994). What price coherence? Analysis 54, 129–132
Kyburg H.E., Jr. (1983). Recent work in inductive logic. In: Machan T., Lucey K. (eds). Recent work in philosophy. Rowman & Allanheld, Totowa/NJ, pp. 87–150
Levi I. (1962). Corroboration and rules of acceptance. British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 13, 307–313
Lewis, C. I. (1946). An analysis of knowledge and valuation. Chicago: Open Court.
Milne P. (1996). log[p(h/eb)/p(h/b)] is the one true measure of confirmation. Philosophy of Science 63, 21–26
Moretti L., Akiba K. (2007). Probabilistic measures of coherence and the problem of belief individuation. Synthese 154, 73–95
Nozick R. (1981). Philosophical explanations. Harvard University Press, Cambridge/MA
Olsson E.J. (2002). What is the problem of coherence and truth?. The Journal of Philosophy 94, 246–272
Olsson E.J. (2005). Against coherence. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Olsson E.J., Shogenji T. (2004). Can we trust our memories? C. I. Lewis’s coherence argument. Synthese 142, 21–41
Popper K.R. (1954). Degree of confirmation. British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 5, 143–149
Rescher N. (1958). Theory of evidence. Philosophy of Science 25, 83–94
Rosenkrantz R. (1994). Bayesian confirmation: Paradise regained. British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 45, 467–476
Schlesinger G. (1995). Measuring degrees of confirmation. Analysis 55, 208–212
Shogenji T. (1999). Is coherence truth conducive? Analysis 59, 338–345
Siebel M. (2005a). Against probabilistic measures of coherence. Erkenntnis 63, 335–360
Siebel, M. (2005b). Thagard’s measure of coherence: Corrected and compared with probabilistic accounts. Manuscript.
Thagard P. (1992). Conceptual revolutions. Princeton University Press, Princeton
Thagard P., Verbeurgt K. (1998). Coherence as constraint satisfaction. Cognitive Science 22, 1–24
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Siebel, M., Wolff, W. Equivalent testimonies as a touchstone of coherence measures. Synthese 161, 167–182 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-006-9155-4
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-006-9155-4