Abstract
What do human beings use conditional reasoning for? A psychological consequence of counterfactual conditional reasoning is emotional experience, in particular, regret and relief. Adults’ thoughts about what might have been influence their evaluations of reality. We discuss recent psychological experiments that chart the relationship between children’s ability to engage in conditional reasoning and their experience of counterfactual emotions. Relative to conditional reasoning, counterfactual emotions are late developing. This suggests that children need not only competence in conditional reasoning, but also to engage in this thinking spontaneously. Developments in domain general cognitive processing (the executive functions) allow children to develop from conditional reasoning to reasoning with counterfactual content and, eventually, to experiencing counterfactual emotions.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Amsel, E., and D. Smalley, Beyond really and truly: Children’s counterfactual thinking about pretend and possible worlds, in P. Mitchell and K. J. Riggs (eds.), Children’s Reasoning and Mind. Psychology Press, Brighton, England, 2000.
Au T.K.: Chinese and english counterfacutals: The sapir-whorf hypothesis revisited. Cognition 15, 155–187 (1983)
Beck S.R., Carrol D.J., Brundson V.E.A., Gryg C.: Supporting children’s counterfactual thinking with alternative modes of responding. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology 108, 190–202 (2011)
Beck S.R., Riggs K.J., Gorniak S.L.: Relating developments in children’s counterfactual thinking and executive functions. Thinking and Reasoning 15, 337–354 (2009)
Beck S.R., Riggs K.J., Gorniak S.L.: effect of causal chain length on counterfactual conditional reasoning. British Journal of Developmental Psychology 28, 505–521 (2010)
Beck S.R., Robinson E.J., Caroll D.J., Apperly I.A.: Children’s thinking about counterfactuals and future hypotheticals as possibilities. Child Development 77, 413–426 (2006)
Burns P., Riggs K.J., Beck S.R.: Executive control and the experience of regret. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology 111, 501–515 (2012)
Byrne R. M. J.,The rational imagination: How people create alternatives to reality, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, 2005.
Carlson S.M., Moses L.J.: Individual differences in inhibitory control and children’s theory of mind. Child Development 72, 1032–1053 (2001)
Craft J.L., Simon J.R.: Processing symbolic information from a visual display: Interference from an irrelevant directional cue. Journal of Experimental Psychology 83, 415–420 (1970)
Donaldson M.: Childrenís Minds. Fontana Books, London (1978)
Edgington, D., Estimating conditional chances and evaluating counterfactuals. Studia Logica, 2013. doi:10.1007/s11225-013-9514-3.
Frosch C.A., McCormack T., Lagnado D.A., Burns P.: Are causal structure and intervention judgments inextricably linked? a developmental study. Cognitive Science 36, 261–285 (2012)
German T.P.: Children’s causal reasoning: Counterfactual-thinking occurs for ‘negative’ outcomes only. Developmental Science 2, 442–447 (1999)
German T.P., Nichols S.: Children’s counterfactual inferences about long and short causal chains. Developmental Science 6, 514–523 (2003)
Goldinger S.D., Kleider H.M., Azuma T., Beike D.: “Blaming the victim” under memory load. Psychological Science 14, 81–85 (2003)
Guajardo N.R., Parker J., Turley-Ames K.J.: Associations among false belief understanding, counterfactual reasoning, and executive function. British Journal of Developmental Psychology 29, 681–702 (2009)
Guttentag R., Ferrell J.: Children’s understanding of anticipatory regret and disappointment. Cognition & Emotion 22, 815–832 (2008)
Guttentag R.E., Ferrell J.: Reality compared with its alternatives: Age differences in judgments of regret and relief. Developmental Psychology 40, 764–775 (2004)
Harris P.L., German T.P., Mills P.: Children’s use of counterfactual-thinking in causal reasoning. Cognition 61, 233–259 (1996)
Iatridou S.: The grammatical ingredients of counterfactuality. Linguistic Inquiry 31, 231–270 (2000)
Leahy, B., E. Rafetseder, and J. Perner, Basic conditional reasoning: How children mimic counterfactual reasoning. Studia Logica, 2013. doi:10.1007/s11225-013-9510-7.
Lewis, D., Counterfactuals, Basil Blackwell, Oxford, UK, 1973.
Meehan, J. E., and R. M. J. Byrne, Children’s counterfactual thinking: The temporal order effect, in B. G. Bara, L. Barsalou, and M. Bucciarelli (eds.), 27th Annual Conference of the Cognitive Science Society, Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Mahwah, NJ, 2005, pp. 1467–1473.
O’Connor E., McCormack T., Feeney A.: The development of regret. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology 111, 120–127 (2012)
Perner, J., About + belief + counterfactual, in P. Mitchell and K. J. Riggs (eds.), Children’s reasoning and the mind, Psychology Press, Hove, UK, 2000, pp. 367–401.
Powell, N. L., R. E. Guttentag, K. A. Quinn., and S. R. Beck, The role of reasoning in moral judgments: Evidence from regret and blame. Manuscript in preparation. 2013.
Rafetseder E., Cristi-Vargas R., Perner J.: Counterfactual reasoning: developing a sense of “nearest possible world”. Child Development 81, 376–389 (2010)
Rafetseder E., Perner J.: When the alternative would have been better: Counterfactual reasining and the emerge of regret. Cognition and Emotion 26, 800–819 (2012)
Rafetseder E., Schwitalla M., Perner J.: Counterfactual reasoning: From childhood to adulthood. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology 114, 389–404 (2013)
Riggs K.J., Peterson D.M., Robinson E.J., Mitchell P.: errors in false belief tasks symptomatic of a broader difficulty with counterfactuality?. Cognitivice Development 13, 73–90 (1998)
Robinson, E. J., and S. R. Beck, What is difficult about counterfactual reasoning?, in P. Mitchell and K. J. Riggs (eds.), Children’s reasoning and the mind, Psychology Press, Hove, 2000.
Roese N.J.: Counterfactual thinking. Psychological Bulletin 121, 133–148 (1997)
Sweeney K., Vohs K.: On near misses and completed tasks: The nature of relief. Psychological Science 23, 464–468 (2012)
Weisberg D.P., Beck S.R.: The development of children’s regret and relief. Cognition and Emotion 26, 820–835 (2012)
Weisberg D.P., Beck S.R.: Children’s thinking about their own and other’s regret and relief. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology 106, 184–191 (2010)
Wells G.L., Gavanski I.: Mental simulation of causality. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 56, 161–169 (1989)
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Beck, S.R., Weisberg, D.P., Burns, P. et al. Conditional Reasoning and Emotional Experience: A Review of the Development of Counterfactual Thinking. Stud Logica 102, 673–689 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11225-013-9508-1
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11225-013-9508-1