Abstract
This study aims to evaluate the cost-effectiveness of surgical resection (S) and Cesium-131 (Cs-131) [S + Cs-131] intraoperative brachytherapy versus S and stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) [S + SRS] for the treatment of brain metastases. Treatment records as well as hospital and outpatient charts of 49 patients with brain metastases between 2008 and 2012 who underwent S + Cs-131 (n = 24) and S + SRS (n = 25) were retrospectively reviewed. Hospital charges were compared for the single treatment in question. Means and curves of survival time were defined by the Kaplan–Meier estimator, with the cost analysis focusing on the time period of the relevant treatment. Quality adjusted life years (QALY) and Incremental cost-effectiveness ratios (ICER) were calculated for each treatment option as a measure of cost-effectiveness. The direct hospital costs of treatments per patient were: S + Cs131 = $19,271 and S + SRS = $44,219. The median survival times of S + Cs-131 and S + SRS were 15.5 and 11.3 months, and the 12 month survival rates were 61 % and 49 % (P = 0.137). The QALY for S + SRS when compared to S + Cs-131 yielded a p < 0.0001, making it significantly more cost-effective. The ICER also revealed that when compared to S + Cs-131, S + SRS was significantly inferior (p < 0.0001). S + Cs-131 is more cost-effective compared with S + SRS based on hospital charges as well as QALYs and ICER. Cost effectiveness, in addition to efficacy and risk, should factor into the comparison between these two treatment modalities for patients with surgically resectable brain metastases.
Similar content being viewed by others
Abbreviations
- Cs-13:
-
Cesium-131
- I-125:
-
Iodine-125
- ICER:
-
Incremental cost-effectiveness ratio
- KPS:
-
Karnofsky performance status
- LINAC:
-
Linear accelerators
- QALY:
-
Quality adjusted life year
- SRS:
-
Stereotactic radiosurgery
- S:
-
Surgical resection
- WBRT:
-
Whole brain radiotherapy
References
Counsell CE, Collie DA, Grant R (1996) Incidence of intracranial tumours in the Lothian region of Scotland, 1989–90. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 61:143–150
Walker AE, Robins M, Weinfeld FD (1985) Epidemiology of brain tumors: the national survey of intracranial neoplasms. Neurology 35:219–226
Bradley KA, Mehta MP (2004) Management of brain metastases. Semin Oncol 31:693–701
Cappuzzo F, Mazzoni F, Maestri A, Di Stefano A, Calandri C, Crino L (2000) Medical treatment of brain metastases from solid tumours. Forum (Genova) 10:137–148
Varlotto JM, Flickinger JC, Niranjan A, Bhatnagar A, Kondziolka D, Lunsford LD (2005) The impact of whole-brain radiation therapy on the long-term control and morbidity of patients surviving more than one year after gamma knife radiosurgery for brain metastases. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys 62:1125–1132
Cairncross JG, Posner JB (1983) The management of brain metastases. In: Walker MD (ed) Oncology of the nervous system. Cancer treatment and research. Martinus Nijhoff, Boston, pp 341–377
Berry HC, Parker RG, Gerdes AJ (1974) Irradiation of brain metastases. Acta Radiol Ther Phys Biol 13:535–544
Kurtz JM, Gelber R, Brady LW, Carella RJ, Cooper JS (1981) The palliation of brain metastases in a favorable patient population: a randomized clinical trial by the Radiation Therapy Oncology Group. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys 7:891–895
Order SE, Hellman S, Von Essen CF, Kligerman MM (1968) Improvement in quality of survival following whole-brain irradiation for brain metastasis. Radiology 91:149–153
Patchell RA, Tibbs PA, Walsh JW, Dempsey RJ, Maruyama Y, Kryscio RJ, Markesbery WR, Macdonald JS, Young B (1990) A randomized trial of surgery in the treatment of single metastases to the brain. N Engl J Med 322:494–500
Vecht CJ, Haaxma-Reiche H, Noordijk EM, Padberg GW, Voormolen JH, Hoekstra FH, Tans JT, Lambooij N, Metsaars JA, Wattendorff AR, Brand R, Hermans J (1993) Treatment of single brain metastasis: radiotherapy alone or combined with neurosurgery. Ann Neurol 33:583–590
Chang EL, Wefel JS, Hess KR, Allen PK, Lang FF, Kornguth DG, Arbuckle RB, Swint JM, Shiu AS, Maor MH, Meyers CA (2009) Neurocognition in patients with brain metastases treated with radiosurgery or radiosurgery plus whole-brain irradiation: a randomised controlled trial. Lancet Oncol 10:1037–1044. doi:10.1016/S1470-2045(09)70263-3
Crossen JR, Garwood D, Glatstein E, Neuwelt EA (1994) Neurobehavioral sequelae of cranial irradiation in adults: a review of radiation-induced encephalopathy. J Clin Oncol 12:627–642
DeAngelis LM, Delattre JY, Posner JB (1989) Radiation-induced dementia in patients cured of brain metastases. Neurology 39:789–796
Nieder C, Schwerdtfeger K, Steudel WI, Schnabel K (1998) Patterns of relapse and late toxicity after resection and whole-brain radiotherapy for solitary brain metastases. Strahlenther Onkol 174:275–278
Aoyama H, Shirato H, Tago M, Nakagawa K, Toyoda T, Hatano K, Kenjyo M, Oya N, Hirota S, Shioura H, Kunieda E, Inomata T, Hayakawa K, Katoh N, Kobashi G (2006) Stereotactic radiosurgery plus whole-brain radiation therapy vs stereotactic radiosurgery alone for treatment of brain metastases: a randomized controlled trial. JAMA 295:2483–2491
Chidel MA, Suh JH, Reddy CA, Chao ST, Lundbeck MF, Barnett GH (2000) Application of recursive partitioning analysis and evaluation of the use of whole brain radiation among patients treated with stereotactic radiosurgery for newly diagnosed brain metastases. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys 47:993–999
Frazier JL, Batra S, Kapor S, Vellimana A, Gandhi R, Carson KA, Shokek O, Lim M, Kleinberg L, Rigamonti D (2010) Stereotactic radiosurgery in the management of brain metastases: an institutional retrospective analysis of survival. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys 76:1486–1492. doi:10.1016/j.ijrobp.2009.03.028
Kocher M, Maarouf M, Bendel M, Voges J, Müller RP, Sturm V (2004) Linac radiosurgery versus whole brain radiotherapy for brain metastases: a survival comparison based on the RTOG recursive partitioning analysis. Strahlenther Onkol 180:263–267
Rades D, Pluemer A, Veninga T, Hanssens P, Dunst J, Schild SE (2007) Whole-brain radiotherapy versus stereotactic radiosurgery for patients in recursive partitioning analysis classes 1 and 2 with 1 to 3 brain metastases. Cancer 110:2285–2292
Sneed PK, Suh JH, Goetsch SJ, Sanghavi SN, Chappell R, Buatti JM, Regine WF, Weltman E, King VJ, Breneman JC, Sperduto PW, Mehta MP (2002) A multi-institutional review of radiosurgery alone versus radiosurgery with whole brain radiotherapy as the initial management of brain metastases. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys 53:519–526
Andrews DW, Scott CB, Sperduto PW, Flanders AE, Gaspar LE, Schell MC, Werner-Wasik M, Demas W, Ryu J, Bahary JP, Souhami L, Rotman M, Mehta MP, Curran WJ Jr (2004) Whole brain radiation therapy with or without stereotactic radiosurgery boost for patients with one to three brain metastases: phase III results of the RTOG 9508 randomised trial. Lancet 363:1665–1672
Kondziolka D, Patel A, Lunsford LD, Kassam A, Flickinger JC (1999) Stereotactic radiosurgery plus whole brain radiotherapy versus radiotherapy alone for patients with multiple brain metastases. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys 45:427–434
Rades D, Kueter J, Pluemer A, Veninga T, Schild SE (2009) A matched-pair analysis comparing whole-brain radiotherapy plus stereotactic radiosurgery versus surgery plus whole-brain radiotherapy and a boost to the metastatic site for one or two brain metastases. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys 73:1077–1081. doi:10.1016/j.ijrobp.2008.05.035
Rades D, Kueter J, Veninga T, Gliemroth J, Schild SE (2009) Whole brain radiotherapy plus stereotactic radiosurgery (WBRT + SRS) versus surgery plus whole brain radiotherapy (OP + WBRT) for 1-3 brain metastases: results of a matched pair analysis. Eur J Cancer 45:400–404. doi:10.1016/j.ejca.2008.10.033
Gans JH, Raper DM, Shah AH, Bregy A, Heros D, Lally BE, Morcos JJ, Heros RC, Komotar RJ (2013) The role of radiosurgery to the tumor bed after resection of brain metastases. Neurosurgery 72:317–324. doi:10.1227/NEU.0b013e31827fcd60
Jarvis LA, Simmons NE, Bellerive M, Erkmen K, Eskey CJ, Gladstone DJ, Hug EB, Roberts DW, Hartford AC (2012) Tumor bed dynamics after surgical resection of brain metastases: implications for postoperative radiosurgery. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys 84:943–948. doi:10.1016/j.ijrobp.2012.01.067
Jagannathan J, Yen CP, Ray DK, Schlesinger D, Oskouian RJ, Pouratian N, Shaffrey ME, Larner J, Sheehan JP (2009) Gamma knife radiosurgery to the surgical cavity following resection of brain metastases. J Neurosurg 111:431–438. doi:10.3171/2008.11.JNS08818
Hartford AC, Galvin JM, Beyer DC, Eichler TJ, Ibbott GS, Kavanagh B, Schultz CJ, Rosenthal SA, American College of Radiology, American Society for Radiation Oncology (2012) American College of Radiology (ACR) and American Society for Radiation Oncology (ASTRO) Practice Guideline for Intensity-modulated Radiation Therapy (IMRT). Am J Clin Oncol35:612–617. doi: 10.1097/COC.0b013e31826e0515
Aoyama H, Shirato H, Onimaru R, Kagei K, Ikeda J, Ishii N, Sawamura Y, Miyasaka K (2003) Hypofractionated stereotactic radiotherapy alone without whole-brain irradiation for patients with solitary and oligo brain metastasis using noninvasive fixation of the skull. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys 56:793–800
Wernicke AG, Yondorf MZ, Peng L, Trichter S, Nedialkova L, Sabbas A, Kulidzhanov F, Parashar B, Nori D, Clifford Chao KS, Christos P, Kovanlikaya I, Pannullo S, Boockvar JA, Stieg PE, Schwartz TH (2014) Phase I/II study of resection and intraoperative cesium-131 radioisotope brachytherapy in patients with newly diagnosed brain metastases. J Neurosurg 121:338–348. doi:10.3171/2014.3.JNS131140
Dagnew E, Kanski J, McDermott MW, Sneed PK, McPherson C, Breneman JC, Warnick RE (2007) Management of newly diagnosed single brain metastasis using resection and permanent iodine-125 seeds without initial whole-brain radiotherapy: a two institution experience. Neurosurg Focus 22:E3
Huang K, Sneed PK, Kunwar S, Kragten A, Larson DA, Berger MS, Chan A, Pouliot J, McDermott MW (2009) Surgical resection and permanent iodine-125 brachytherapy for brain metastases. J Neurooncol 91:83–93. doi:10.1007/s11060-008-9686-2
Shaw E, Scott C, Souhami L, Dinapoli R, Kline R, Loeffler J, Farnan N (2000) Single dose radiosurgical treatment of recurrent previously irradiated primary brain tumors and brain metastases: final report of rtog protocol 90-05. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys 47:291–298
Dhabaan A, Schreibmann E, Siddiqi A, Elder E, Fox T, Ogunleye T, Esiashvili N, Curran W, Crocker I, Shu HK (2012) Six degrees of freedom cbct-based positioning for intracranial targets treated with frameless stereotactic radiosurgery. J Appl Clin Med Phys 13:3916. doi:10.1120/jacmp.v13i6.3916
Prabhu RS, Dhabaan A, Hall WA, Ogunleye T, Crocker I, Curran WJ, Shu HK (2013) Clinical outcomes for a novel 6 degrees of freedom image guided localization method for frameless radiosurgery for intracranial brain metastases. J Neurooncol 113:93–99. doi:10.1007/s11060-013-1093-7
Cho DY, Tsao M, Lee WY, Chang CS (2006) Socioeconomic costs of open surgery and gamma knife radiosurgery for benign cranial base tumors. Neurosurgery 58:866–873
Lee WY, Cho DY, Lee HC, Chuang HC, Chen CC, Liu JL, Yang SN, Liang JA, Ho LH (2009) Outcomes and cost-effectiveness of gamma knife radiosurgery and whole brain radiotherapy for multiple metastatic brain tumors. J Clin Neurosci 16:630–634. doi:10.1016/j.jocn.2008.06.021
Rutigliano MJ, Lunsford LD, Kondziolka D, Strauss MJ, Khanna V, Green M (1995) The cost effectiveness of stereotactic radiosurgery versus surgical resection in the treatment of solitary metastatic brain tumors. Neurosurgery 37:445–455
Picot J, Cooper K, Bryant J, Clegg AJ (2011) The clinical effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of bortezomib and thalidomide in combination regimens with an alkylating agent and a corticosteroid for the first-line treatment of multiple myeloma: a systematic review and economic evaluation. Health Technol Assess 15:1–204. doi:10.3310/hta15410
Cairncross JG, Kim JH, Posner JB (1980) Radiation therapy for brain metastases. Ann Neurol 7:529–541
Chow E, Davis L, Holden L, Tsao M, Danjoux C (2005) Prospective assessment of patient-rated symptoms following whole brain radiotherapy for brain metastases. J Pain Symptom Manage 30:18–23
Kondziolka D, Niranjan A, Flickinger JC, Lunsford LD (2005) Radiosurgery with or without whole-brain radiotherapy for brain metastases: the patients’ perspective regarding complications. Am J Clin Oncol 28:173–179
Patchell RA, Tibbs PA, Regine WF, Dempsey RJ, Mohiuddin M, Kryscio RJ, Markesbery WR, Foon KA, Young B (1998) Postoperative radiotherapy in the treatment of single metastases to the brain: a randomized trial. JAMA 280:1485–1489
Sawaya R, Hammoud M, Schoppa D, Hess KR, Wu SZ, Shi WM, Wildrick DM (1998) Neurosurgical outcomes in a modern series of 400 craniotomies for treatment of parenchymal tumors. Neurosurgery 42:1044–1055
Filley CM, Kleinschmidt-DeMasters BK (2001) Toxic leukoencephalopathy. N Engl J Med 345:425–432
Do L, Pezner R, Radany E, Liu A, Staud C, Badie B (2009) Resection followed by stereotactic radiosurgery to resection cavity for intracranial metastases. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys 73:486–491. doi:10.1016/j.ijrobp.2008.04.070
Jensen CA, Chan MD, McCoy TP, Bourland JD, Deguzman AF, Ellis TL, Ekstrand KE, McMullen KP, Munley MT, Shaw EG, Urbanic JJ, Tatter SB (2011) Cavity-directed radiosurgery as adjuvant therapy after resection of a brain metastasis. J Neurosurg 114:1585–1591. doi:10.3171/2010.11.JNS10939
Karlovits BJ, Quigley MR, Karlovits SM, Miller L, Johnson M, Gayou O, Fuhrer R (2009) Stereotactic radiosurgery boost to the resection bed for oligometastatic brain disease: challenging the tradition of adjuvant whole-brain radiotherapy. Neurosurg Foc 27:E7. doi:10.3171/2009.9.FOCUS09191
Quigley MR, Fuhrer R, Karlovits SM, Karlovits BJ, Johnson M (2008) Single session stereotactic radiosurgery boost to the post-operative site in lieu of whole brain radiation in metastatic brain disease. J Neurooncol 87:327–332. doi:10.1007/s11060-007-9515-z
Blonigen BJ, Steinmetz RD, Levin L, Lamba MA, Warnick RE, Breneman JC (2010) Irradiated volume as a predictor of brain radionecrosis after linear accelerator stereotactic radiosurgery. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys 77:996–1001. doi:10.1016/j.ijrobp.2009.06.006
Vuong DA, Rades D, Le AN, Busse R (2012) The cost-effectiveness of stereotactic radiosurgery versus surgical resection in the treatment of brain metastasis in Vietnam from the perspective of patients and families. World Neurosurg 77:321–328. doi:10.1016/j.wneu.2011.05.050
Vuong DA, Rades D, van Eck AT, Horstmann GA, Busse R (2013) Comparing the cost-effectiveness of two brain metastasis treatment modalities from a payer’s perspective: stereotactic radiosurgery versus surgical resection. Clin Neurol Neurosurg 115:276–284. doi:10.1016/j.clineuro.2012.05.005
Mehta M, Noyes W, Craig B, Lamond J, Auchter R, French M, Johnson M, Levin A, Badie B, Robbins I, Kinsella T (1997) A cost-effectiveness and cost-utility analysis of radiosurgery versus resection for single-brain metastases. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys 39:445–454
Lal LS, Byfield SD, Chang EL, Franzini L, Miller LA, Arbuckle R, Reasonda L, Feng C, Adamus A, Swint JM (2012) Cost-effectiveness analysis of a randomized study comparing radiosurgery with radiosurgery and whole brain radiation therapy in patients with 1 to 3 brain metastases. Am J Clin Oncol 35:45–50. doi:10.1097/COC.0b013e3182005a8f
Evans C, Tavakoli M, Crawford B (2004) Use of quality adjusted life years and life years gained as benchmarks in economic evaluations: a critical appraisal. Health Care Manag Sci 7:43–49
Datta R, Jawahar A, Ampil FL, Shi R, Nanda A, D’Agostino H (2004) Survival in relation to radiotherapeutic modality for brain metastasis: whole brain irradiation versus gamma knife radiosurgery. Am J Clin Oncol 27:420–424
Kalkanis SN, Kondziolka D, Gaspar LE, Burri SH, Asher AL, Cobbs CS, Ammirati M, Robinson PD, Andrews DW, Loeffler JS, McDermott M, Mehta MP, Mikkelsen T, Olson JJ, Paleologos NA, Patchell RA, Ryken TC, Linskey ME (2010) The role of surgical resection in the management of newly diagnosed brain metastases: a systematic review and evidence-based clinical practice guideline. J Neurooncol 96:33–43. doi:10.1007/s11060-009-0061-8
Acknowledgments
Parts of this manuscript were presented at the Society for Neuro-Oncology in 2012, Washington, DC. Doctor Wernicke supported by the funds from the National Institute of Health CTSC KL2 Comparative Effectiveness Research Award UL1-TR000457.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflict of interest
None.
Additional information
The 1st authorship is shared between the authors A. Gabriella Wernicke and Menachem Z. Yondorf.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Wernicke, A.G., Yondorf, M.Z., Parashar, B. et al. The cost-effectiveness of surgical resection and cesium-131 intraoperative brachytherapy versus surgical resection and stereotactic radiosurgery in the treatment of metastatic brain tumors. J Neurooncol 127, 145–153 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11060-015-2026-4
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11060-015-2026-4