Abstract
The Correctional Service of Canada (CSC) has received international praise for its new policies with female prisoners serving federal sentences of two or more years. Regarded as progressive, even radical, other countries have looked toward Canada for inspiration in the design of their own policies [Carlen, (2002) Criminal Justice 2(2)]. CSC’s “women-centered” mental health agenda, however, while rhetorically progressive, remains consistent with disciplinary processes which prioritize self-regulation and aim to correct or normalize those considered failed citizens [Kemshall, (2002), The Howard Journal 41(1), 41–58]. Using Nicolas Rose’s concept of governance through self-regulation [Rose 1991, b Rose (1996). Inventing Ourselves: Psychology, Power and Personhood. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; Rose (2000). British Journal of Criminology 40, 321–339] as a theoretical framework, we argue that correctional mental health practices privileges a psychological discourse which serves to regulate women prisoners as opposed to empowering or supporting them. We examine the over use of psychiatric labelling of women, such as that of Boderline Personality Disorder, and the resulting treatment regime, Dialectical Behavior Therapy, to illustrate that the CSC has constructed women prisoners as disorderly and disordered and thus in need of taming. This discussion is followed by recommendations for new directions in feminist mental health treatment for women in prison that more adequately confront the inherent tensions and contradictions of prison therapeutic services and that incorporate multi-faceted understandings of the mental health needs of women offenders. We conclude with some policy and research implications of adopting a feminist informed mental health correctional strategy.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
D.A. Andrews J. Bonta (1998) The Psychology of Criminal Conduct. Anderson Publishing Company Cincinnati, OH
K. Blanchette (1997) ArticleTitleClassifying female offenders for correctional research interventions Forum on Corrections Research 9 IssueID1 36–41
B. Bloom (Eds) (2003) Gendered Justice: Addressing Female Offenders Carolina Academic Press Durham
A.C. Burke (2002) Triple jeopardy: Women marginalized by substance abuse, poverty, and incarceration J. Fiqueira-McDonough R. Sarri (Eds) Women at the Margins: Neglect, Punishment, and Resistance Haworth Press New York 175–201
Canadian Association of Elizabeth Fry Societies (2003). Submission of the Canadian Association of Elizabeth Fry Societies (CAEFS) to the Canadian Human Rights Commission for the Special Report on the Discrimination on the Basis of Sex, Race and Disability Faced by Federally Sentenced Women.
Canadian Human Rights Commission (2003). Protecting Their Rights: A Systemic Review of Human Rights in Correctional Services for Federally Sentenced Women.
Carlen, P. (2002). Controlling measures: The repackaging of common sense opposition to women’s imprisonment in England and Canada. Criminal Justice 2(2).
S. Covington B. Bloom (2003) Gendered justice: Women in the criminal justice system B. Bloom (Eds) Gendered Justice: Addressing Female Offenders Carolina Academic Press Durham 3–23
C. Dowden D. Andrews (1999) ArticleTitleWhat works for female offenders: A meta-analytic review Crime & Delinquency 45 IssueID4 438–452
Elizabeth Fry Society of Greater Vancouver (2001). Discussion Paper: The Intensive Treatment Program for Female Offenders in BCCW: A Critique and Recommendation. >New Westminster: Elizabeth Fry Society of Greater Vancouver.
M. Foucault (1977) Discipline and Punish. The Birth of the Prison. Vintage New York
K. Fox (2001) Self-change and resistance in prison J. Gubrium J. Holstein (Eds) Institutional Selves. Troubled Identities in a Postmodern World. Oxford University Press Oxford 176–192
K. Fox (1999a) ArticleTitleChanging violent minds: Discursive correction and resistance in the cognitive treatment of violent offenders in prison Social Problems 46 IssueID1 88–103
K. Fox (1999b) ArticleTitleReproducing criminal types: Cognitive treatment for violent offenders in prison The Sociological Quarterly 40 IssueID3 435–453
K. Gorman (2001) ArticleTitleCognitive behaviourism and the Holy Grail: The quest for a universal means of managing offender risk Probation Journal 48 IssueID1 3–9 Occurrence Handle10.1177/026455050104800102
K. Hannah-Moffat (1995) ArticleTitle‘Feminine-fortresses: Women-centred prisons? The Prison Journal 75 IssueID2 135–164 Occurrence Handle10.1177/0032855595075002002
K. Hannah-Moffat (2000) ArticleTitlePrisons That Empower: Neoliberal Governance in Canadian Women’s Prisons British Journal of Criminology 40 IssueID3 510–531
K. Hannah-Moffat (2001) Punishment in Disguise. Penal Governance and Federal Imprisonment of Women in Canada. University of Toronto Press Toronto
K. Hannah-Moffat (2002) Creating choices: Reflecting on choices P. Carlen (Eds) Women and Punishment. The Struggle for Justice. Willan Cullompton, Devon 199–219
K. Hannah-Moffat M. Shaw (2000a) ArticleTitleThinking about cognitive skills? think again!. Criminal Justice Matters 39 8–9
K. Hannah-Moffat M. Shaw (Eds) (2000b) An Ideal Prison? Critical Essays on Women’s Imprisonment in Canada Fernwood Halifax
D. Henderson J. Schaeffer L. Brown (1998) ArticleTitleGender-appropriate mental health services for incarcerated women: Issues and challenges Family Community Health 21 IssueID3 42–53
J. Heney C. Kristiansen (1998) An analysis of the impact of prison on women survivors of childhood sexual abuse J. Harden M. Hill (Eds) Breaking the Rules: Women in Prison and Feminist Therapy Harrington Park Press New York 29–44
J. Herman (1997) Trauma and Recovery Basic Books New York
M.A. Jimenez (1997) ArticleTitleGender and psychiatry: Psychiatric conceptions of mental disorders in women, 1960–1994 Affilia 12 IssueID2 154–175
H. Kemshall (2002) ArticleTitleEffective practice in probation: An example of “advanced liberal” responsibilisation The Howard Journal 41 IssueID1 41–58
K. Kendall (2002) Time to think again about cognitive behavioral programmes P. Carlen (Eds) Women and Punishment. The Struggle for Justice. Willan Cullompton, Devon 182–198
K. Kendall (2000) Psy-ence fiction: Inventing the mentally disordered female prisoner K. Hannah-Moffat M. Shaw (Eds) An Ideal Prison? Critical Essays on Women’s Imprisonment in Canada Fernwood Halifax 82–93
K. Kendall (1994) ArticleTitleTherapy behind prison walls: A contradiction in terms Prison Service Journal 96 2–11
K. Kendall S. Pollack (2003) Cognitive behavioralism in women’s prisons: A critical analysis of therapeutic assumptions and practices B. Bloom (Eds) Gendered Justice. Addressing Female Offenders. Carolina Academic Press Durham, NC 69–96
J. Laishes (2002) The 2002 Mental Health Strategy for Female Offenders Mental Health, Health Services, Correctional Service of Canada Ottawa
M. Linehan (1993a) Cognitive-Behavioral Treatment of Borderline Personality Disorder The Guilford Press New York
M. Linehan (1993b) Skills Training Manual for Treating Borderline Personality Disorder The Guilford Press New York
M. Linehan H. Heard (1992) Dialectical behavior therapy for borderline personality disorder J. Clarkin E. Marziali H. Munroe-Bloom (Eds) Borderline Personality Disorder: Clinical and Empirical Perspectives The Guilford Press New York 248–267
Loucks, A. and Zamble, E. (1999). Predictors of recidivism in serious female offenders: Canada searches for predictors common to both men and women. Corrections Today, >February, 26–32.
M. Mauer M. Chesney-Lind (Eds) (2002) Invisible Punishment: The Collateral Consequences of Mass Imprisonment The New Press New York
J. McCorkel (2003) ArticleTitleEmbodied surveillance and the gendering of punishment Journal of Contemporary Ethnography 32 IssueID1 41–76
D. McDonagh C. Noel Wichmann (2002a) ArticleTitleMental health needs of women offenders: Needs analysis for the development of the intensive intervention Strategy Forum on Corrections Research 14 IssueID2 32–35
D. McDonagh K. Taylor K. Blanchette (2002b) ArticleTitleCorrectional adaptation of Dialectical Behaviour Therapy (DBT) for federally sentenced women Forum on Corrections Research 14 IssueID2 36–39
Motiuk, L. and K. Blanchette (1998) Assessing Female Offenders: What Works? >Paper presented at the Annual Conference of the International Community Corrections Association, September 27–30, Arlington Virginia.
S. Pollack (1994) ArticleTitleOpening the window on a very dark day: A program evaluation of the peer support team at the Kingston prison for women Forum on Correctional Research 6 IssueID1 36–38
S. Pollack (2000a) Dependency discourse as social control Kelly Hannah-Moffat Margaret Shaw (Eds) An Ideal Prison?: Critical Essays on Canadian Women’s Imprisonment. Fernwood Press Halifax 72–81
S. Pollack (2000b) ArticleTitleReconceptualizing women’s agency and empowerment: Challenges to self-esteem discourse and women’s lawbreaking Women & Criminal Justice 12 IssueID1 75–89
S. Pollack (2004) ArticleTitleAnti-oppressive Practice with Women in Prison: Discursive Reconstructions and Alternative Practices British Journal of Social Work 34 IssueID5 693–707
M. Rivera (2002) The chrysalis program: Feminist treatment community for individuals diagnosed as personality disordered M. Ballow L.S. Brown (Eds) Rethinking Mental Health and Disorder: Feminist Perspectives. Guilford Press NY 231–261
N. Rose (1996) Inventing Ourselves: Psychology, Power and Personhood Cambridge University Press Cambridge
N. Rose (1999a) Powers of Freedom. Reframing Political Thought. Cambridge University Press Cambridge
N. Rose (1999b) Governing the Soul. The Shaping of the Private Self. Free Association Books London
N. Rose (2000) ArticleTitleGovernment and Control British Journal of Criminology 40 321–339
M. Shaw (1992) ArticleTitleIssues of power and control: Women in prison and their defenders. British Journal of Criminology 32 IssueID4 438–452
Solicitor General Canada (1998) Women Offenders: The Corrections and Conditional Release Act Five Years Later. Toward Just, Peaceful and Safe Society. Solicitor General Canada Ottawa
InstitutionalAuthorNameTask Force on Federally Sentenced Women (1990) Report of the Task Force on Federally Sentenced Women–Creating Choices Ministry of the Solicitor General Ottawa
J. Ussher (2000) Women’s madness: A material-discursive-intrapsychic approach D. Fee (Eds) Pathology and the Postmodern: Mental Illness as Discourse and Experience Sage Publications London 207–230
S. Warner (1996) Visibly special? women, child sexual abuse and special hospitals C. Hemingway (Eds) Special Women? The Experience of Women in the Special Hospital System Avebury Aldershot, Hants England 59–76
S. Warner (2001) ArticleTitleDisrupting identity through visible therapy: A feminist post-structuralist approach to working with women who have experienced child sexual abuse Feminist Review 68 115–139
Jeannie Williams S. Scott S. Waterhouse (2001) ArticleTitleMental health services for ‘difficult’ women: Reflections on some recent developments Feminist Review 6 89–104
Wirth-Cauchon (2001) Women and Borderline Personality Disorder Rutgers University Press New Brunswick
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Additional information
An erratum to this article is available at http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s10612-007-9035-3.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Pollack, S. Taming The Shrew: Regulating Prisoners Through Women-Centered Mental Health Programming. Crit Crim 13, 71–87 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10612-004-6168-5
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10612-004-6168-5