Abstract
The use of data in decision-making by the Massachusetts Prevention Planning Group (MPPG) wasassessed using multiple methods: in-depth interviews, member surveys, directed observations, and archival review. Three factors known to influence group decision-making were of interest: (1) member characteristics, (2) group structure, and (3) data inputs. Membership characteristics were not related to reliance on data. However, group structure factors and data inputs were directly related to reliance on data. Most members accepted an advisory role and felt participation was worthwhile. About half were dissatisfied with decision-making processes, citing member conflicts and distrust. Incompleteness of data, inadequate presentation quality, and lengthy intervals between presentations and actual decision-making were identified as deficits. Although most members reported skills with HIV- and intervention-related data, most also reported deficiencies in interpreting evaluation and cost-effectiveness studies. Member trust and use of data in decision-making could be improved by clarifying decision-making structures and processes, assuring high-quality data presentations, and supporting or training members to better interpret and use data.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Academy for Educational Development (AED)/Center for Community-Based Health Strategies (1994). HIV prevention community planning: An orientation guide. Washington, DC: Authors.
Academy for Educational Development (AED)/National Alliance of State and Territorial AIDS Directors (1996). HIV Prevention Priorities: How community planning groups decide. Washington, DC: Authors.
Adler, P., and Adler, P. (1994). Observational techniques. In N. K. Denzin and Y. S. Lincoln (Eds.), Handbook of Qualitative Research (pp. 377–392). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
Amaro, H., McGuire, J., and Weissman, G. (1999). Participation of Latino community-based organizations in the RWCA process: A study of two metropolitan areas. Free Inquiry in Creative Sociology, 27(2), 29–44.
Batelle (1995). HIV prevention community planning case studies. Arlington, VA: Author.
Bennett, R. H. (1998). The importance of tacit knowledge in strategic deliberations and decisions. Management Decision, 36, 589–597.
Bernard, H. R. (2002). Research methods in anthropology: Qualitative and quantitative methods. Walnut Creek, CA: Altamira Press.
Bertrand, J. T., Magnani, R. J., and Knowles, J. C. (1993). Handbook of Indicators for Family Planning Program Evaluation. Chapel Hill, NC: The Evaluation Project.
Bloom, B. L. (1984). Community Mental Health. Monterey, CA: Brooks Cole.
Boston University School of Public Health/HIV/AIDS Bureau, Massachusetts Department of Public Health (1999). HIV prevention indicators study report. Prepared for the Centers of Disease Control and the Massachusetts HIV Prevention Planning Group.
Bowen, G. S., Marconi, K., Kohn, S., Bailey, D. M., Goosby, E. P., Shorter, S., and Niemcryk, S. (1992). First year of AIDS services delivery under Title I of the Ryan White CARE Act. Public Health Reports, 105, 491–499.
Brooks, A. K. (1994). Power and production of knowledge: Collective team learning in work organizations. Human Resource Development Quarterly, 5, 213–235.
Butterfoss, F. D., Goodman, R. M., and Wandersman, A. (1996). Community coalitions for prevention and health promotion: Factors predicting satisfaction, participation, and planning. Health Education Quarterly, 23, 65–79.
Campion, M. A., Medsker, G. J., and Higgs, A. C. (1993). Relations between work group characteristics and effectiveness: Implications for designing effective work groups. Personnel Psychology, 46, 823–850.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) (1997). Summary of major findings from years two and three of HIV prevention community planning. Summary Report. Atlanta, GA: Centers for Disease Control.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) (1998). Guidance, HIV prevention community planning for HIV prevention cooperative agreement recipients. Atlanta, GA: Centers for Disease Control.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) (1999). Compendium of HIV prevention interventions with evidence of effectiveness. HIV/AIDS Prevention Research Synthesis Project. Retrieved from: http://www.cdc.gov/nchstp/od/news/HIVconpendium.pdf
Cherniss, C., and Deegan, G. (2000). The creation of alternative settings. In J. Rapapport, and E. Seidman (Eds.), Handbook of Community Psychology (pp. 359–377). New York: Kluwer Academic/Plenum.
Collins, C., and Frank, P. (1996). Improving the use of behavioral research in the CDC’s HIV prevention community planning process: A qualitative study of participants in year 2 of CDC’s HIV prevention community planning. (Monograph Series. Occasional paper No. 1). University of California: Center for AIDS Prevention Studies.
Cox, F. M., and Garvin, C. (1974). Community organization practice: 1865–1973. In F. M. Cox, J. L. Erlich, J. Rothman and J. E. Tropman (Eds.), Strategies of Community Organization: A Book of Readings (pp. 39–58). Itasca, IL: Peacock.
Dearing, J. W., Larson, S., Randall, L. M., and Pope, R. S. (1998). Local reinvention of the CDC HIV prevention community planning initiative. Journal of Community Health, 23, 113–126.
Dennis, A. R. (1996). Information exchange and use in group decision making: You can lead a group to information, but you can’t make it think. MIS Quarterly, 20, 433–455.
Devine, D. J. (1999). Effects of cognitive ability, task sharing, and conflict on group decision-making effectiveness. Small Group Research, 30, 608–634.
Driskell, J. E., Hogan, R., and Salas, E. A. F. (1987). Personality and group performance. In C. Hendrick (Ed.), Group Processes and Intergroup Relations. Review of Personality and Social Psychology (pp. 91–112). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
El-Shinnawy, M., and Vinze, A. S. (1998). Polarization and persuasive argumentation: A study of decision making in group settings. Management Information Systems, 22, 165–198.
Gans, H. J. (1973). More equality. New York: Parthenon.
Gold, R. L. (1958). Roles in sociological field observations. Social Forces, 36, 217–223.
Goldstein, E., Wrubel, J., Faigeles, B., and DeCarlo, P. (1998). Sources ofinformation for HIV prevention programs managers: A national survey. AIDS, Education, and Prevention, 10, 63–74.
Holtgrave, D. R. (1994). Setting priorities and community planning for HIV prevention programs. AIDS and Public Policy Journal, 9, 145–151.
Isenberg, D. J. (1986). Group polarization: A critical review and meta analysis. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 50, 1141–1151.
Janis, I., and Mann, L. (1977). Decision making: A psychological analysis of conflict, choice, and commitment. New York: Free Press.
Kelly, J., and McGrath, J. (1985). Effects of time limits and task types on task performance and interaction of four-person groups. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 49, 395–407.
Kreuter, M. W. (1992). PATCH: its origin, basic concepts, and links to contemporary public health policy. Journal of Health Education, 23, 135–139.
Marx, R., Katz, M. H., Park, M.-S., and Gurley, R. J. (1997). Meeting the service needs of HIV-infected persons: Is the Ryan White CARE Act succeeding? Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndromes and Human Retrovirology, 14, 44–55.
McGuire, W. (1981). Theoretical foundations of campaigns. In R. E. Rice, and W. J. Paisley, (Eds.), Public Communication Campaigns (pp. 41–70). Beverly Hills, CA: Safe Publications.
McKinney, M. M., Wieland, M. K., Bowen, G. S., Goosby, E. P., and Marconi, K. (1993). States’ responses to Title II of the Ryan White CARE Act. Public Health Reports, 108, 4–11.
Meyerson, M., and Banfield, E. C. (1955). Politics, planning, and the public interest. Glencoe, IL: Free Press.
Morrill, A. D., Amaro, H., Blake, S. M., Cranston, K., Logan, J., Dai, J., Krech, L., and Dunn, S. (2004). HIV prevention community planning: Enhancing data-informed decision-making. AIDS and Behavior, this issue.
Moynihan, D. P. (1969). Maximum feasible misunderstanding. New York: Free Press.
National Alliance of State and Territorial AIDS Directors (NASTAD) (1996). HIV prevention priorities: How community planning groups decide. Washington, DC: NASTAD.
Neal, J. J., and McNaghten, A. D. (1998). Trends in the use of epidemiological data in HIV prevention community planning in the United States, 1994 through 1997. Presentation at the XII International Conference on AIDS, Geneva.
Nel, D., Pitt, L. F., Berthon, P., and Prendergast, G. (1996). Social decision schemes and group processes: Some impacts on decision making. Journal of Managerial Psychology, 11, 4–17.
Orenstein, D., Nelson, C., Speers, M., Brownstein, J. N., and Ramsey, D. C. (1992). Synthesis of the four PATCH evaluations. Journal of Health Education, 23, 187–192.
QSR N. Vivo (1999). NUD* IST Vivo, Version 1.2. Australia: Qualitative Solutions and Research.
Rappaport, J. (1977). Community psychology: Values, research, and action. New York: Holt, Rinehart, and Winston.
Renaud, M., and Kresse, E. (1996). HIV prevention community planning profiles: Assessing the impact. Washington, DC: United States Conference of Mayors.
Research Triangle Institute (1999). Final report: An assessment to determine program evaluation technical assistance needs, wants, resources, services, service gaps, and preferred methods of responding to technical assistance requests of health departments, community planning groups, community-based organizations, and CDC staff in the context of HIV prevention. Research Triangle, NC: Author.
Rothman, J. (1974). Three models of community organization practice. In F. M. Cox, J. L. Erlich, J. Rothman, and J. E. Tropman, Strategies of Community Organization: A Book of Readings (pp. 22–38). Itasca, IL: Peacock.
Roussus, S., and Fawcett, S. (2000). A review of collaborative partnerships as a strategy for improving community health. Annual Review of Public Health, 21, 369–402.
Rugg, D. L., Heitgerd, J. L., Cotton, D. A., Broyles, S., Freeman, A., Lopez-Gomez, A. M., Cotton-Oldenburg, N. U., and Page-Shafer, K. (2000). CDC HIV prevention indicators: Monitoring and evaluating HIV prevention in the USA. AIDS, 14, 2003–2013.
Sayles, L. R. (1964). Managerial Behavior: Administration in Complex Organizations. New York: McGraw-Hill.
Schietinger, H., Coburn, J., and Levi, J. (1995). Community planning for HIV prevention: Findings from the first year. AIDS and Public Policy Journal, 10, 140–147.
Simon, H. A. (1981). The sciences of the artificial. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Steckler, A., Orrville, K., Eng, E., and Dawson, L. (1992). Summary of a formative evaluation of PATCH. Journal of Health Education, 23, 174–178.
Tversky, A., and Kahneman, D. (1974). Judgment under uncertainty: Heuristics and biases. Science, 185, 1124–1131.
United States Conference of Mayors (1994). HIV prevention community profiles: Assessing the year one. Washington, DC: Author.
United States Conference of Mayors (1998). HIV prevention community profiles: Assessing the process and the evolving effects. Washington, DC: Author.
Valdiserri, R. O., Robinson, C., Lin, L. S., West, G. R., and Holtgrave, D. R. (1997). Determining allocations for HIV-prevention interventions: Assessing a change in federal funding policy. AIDS and Public Policy Journal, 12, 138–148.
Valdiserri, R. O., and West, G. R. (1994). Barriers to the assessment of unmet need in planning HIV/AIDS prevention programs. Public Administration Review, 54, 25–30.
Vojtecky, M. A. (1982). Status and control in voluntary community health planning groups. Medical Care, 20, 1168–1177.
Weiss, C. H. (1980). Social science research and decision-making. New York: Columbia University.
Weissman, G., McClain, M., Hines, R., Harder, P., Gross, M., Marconi, K. M., and Bowen, G. S. (1994). Creating an agenda for research and evaluation: HIV service delivery, the Ryan White Act, and beyond. Journal of Public Health Policy, 15, 329–344.
Yorges, S. L., Weiss, H. M., and Strickland, O. J. (1999). The effect of leader outcomes on influence, attributions, and perception of charisma. Journal of Applied Psychology, 84, 428–436.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Amaro, H., Blake, S.M., Morrill, A.C. et al. HIV Prevention Community Planning: Challenges and Opportunities for Data-Informed Decision-Making. AIDS Behav 9 (Suppl 2), S9–S27 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10461-005-3942-8
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10461-005-3942-8