Abstract
Brain strain is increasingly being used in helmet design and safety performance evaluation as it is generally considered as the primary mechanism of concussion. In this study, we investigate whether different helmet designs can meaningfully alter brain strains using two commonly used metrics, peak maximum principal strain (MPS) of the whole brain and cumulative strain damage measure (CSDM). A convolutional neural network (CNN) that instantly produces detailed brain strains is first tested for accuracy for helmeted head impacts. Based on N = 144 impacts in 12 impact conditions from three random and representative helmet models, we conclude that the CNN is sufficiently accurate for helmet testing applications, for elementwise MPS (success rate of 98.6%), whole-brain peak MPS and CSDM (coefficient of determination of 0.977 and 0.980, with root mean squared error of 0.015 and 0.029, respectively). We then apply the technique to 23 football helmet models (N = 1104 impacts) to reproduce elementwise MPS. Assuming a concussion would occur when peak MPS or CSDM exceeds a threshold, we sweep their thresholds across the value ranges to evaluate the number of predicted hypothetical concussions that different helmets sustain across the impact conditions. Relative to the 12 impact conditions tested, we find that the “best” and “worst” helmets differ by an average of 22.5% in terms of predicted concussions, ranging from 0 to 42% (the latter achieved at the threshold value of 0.28 for peak MPS and 0.4 for CSDM, respectively). Such a large variation among helmets in strain-based concussion predictions demonstrate that helmet designs can still be optimized in a clinically meaningful way. The robustness and accuracy of the CNN tool also suggest its potential for routine use for helmet design and safety performance evaluation in the future. The CNN is freely available online at https://github.com/Jilab-biomechanics/CNN-brain-strains.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Allison, M. A., Y. S. Kang, J. H. Bolte IV., M. R. Maltese, K. B. Arbogast, J. H. Bolte, M. R. Maltese, and K. B. Arbogast. Validation of a helmet-based system to measure head impact biomechanics in ice hockey. Med. Sci. Sports Exerc. 46:115–123, 2014
Anderson, E. D., J. S. Giudice, T. Wu, M. B. Panzer, and D. F. Meaney. Predicting concussion outcome by integrating finite element modeling and network analysis. Front. Bioeng. Biotechnol. 8:309, 2020
Bailey, A. M., T. L. McMurry, J. M. Cormier, J. R. Funk, J. R. Crandall, C. D. Mack, B. S. Myers, and K. B. Arbogast. Comparison of laboratory and on-field performance of American Football Helmets. Ann. Biomed. Eng. 48:2531–2541, 2020
Bailey, A. M., E. J. Sanchez, G. Park, L. F. Gabler, J. R. Funk, J. R. Crandall, M. Wonnacott, C. Withnall, B. S. Myers, and K. B. Arbogast. Development and evaluation of a test method for assessing the performance of American Football Helmets. Ann. Biomed. Eng. 48:2566–2579, 2020
Barlow, K. M., S. Crawford, A. Stevenson, S. S. Sandhu, F. Belanger, and D. Dewey. Epidemiology of postconcussion syndrome in pediatric mild traumatic brain injury. Pediatrics. 126:e374–e381, 2010
Bartsch, A. J., D. Hedin, J. Alberts, E. C. Benzel, J. Cruickshank, R. S. Gray, K. Cameron, M. N. Houston, T. Rooks, G. McGinty, E. Kozlowski, S. Rowson, J. C. Maroon, V. J. Miele, J. C. Ashton, G. P. Siegmund, A. Shah, M. McCrea, and B. Stemper. High energy side and rear American Football Head impacts cause obvious performance decrement on video. Ann. Biomed. Eng. 48:2667–2677, 2020
Beckwith, J. G., R. M. Greenwald, and J. J. Chu. Measuring head kinematics in football: correlation between the head impact telemetry system and Hybrid III headform. Ann. Biomed. Eng. 40:237–248, 2012
Bian, K., and H. Mao. Mechanisms and variances of rotation-induced brain injury: a parametric investigation between head kinematics and brain strain. Biomech. Model. Mechanobiol. 2020. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10237-020-01341-4
Bland, M. L., C. McNally, D. S. Zuby, B. C. Mueller, and S. Rowson. Development of the STAR evaluation system for assessing bicycle helmet protective performance. Ann. Biomed. Eng. 48:47–57, 2020
Cassidy, J. D., L. J. Carroll, P. M. Peloso, J. Borg, H. von Holst, L. Holm, J. Kraus, and V. Coronado. Incidence, risk factors and prevention of mild traumatic brain injury: results of the WHO Collaborating Centre Task Force on Mild Traumatic Brain Injury. J. Rehabil. Med. 43(43):28–60, 2004
Clark, J. M., A. Post, T. B. Hoshizakib, and M. D. Gilchrista. Distribution of brain strain in the cerebrum for laboratory impacts to ice hockey goaltender masks. J. Biomech. Eng.140:121007, 2018
Cobb, B. R., A. M. Zadnik, and S. Rowson. Comparative analysis of helmeted impact response of Hybrid III and National Operating Committee on Standards for Athletic Equipment headforms. Proc. Inst. Mech. Eng. Part P. 230:50–60, 2016
CPSC. Safety Standard for Bicycle Helmets Final Rule (16 CFR Part 1203). United States Consumer Product Safety Commission. 1998
Cripton, P. A., D. M. Dressler, C. A. Stuart, C. R. Dennison, and D. Richards. Bicycle helmets are highly effective at preventing head injury during head impact: Head-form accelerations and injury criteria for helmeted and unhelmeted impacts. Accid. Anal. Prev. 70:1–7, 2014
DiGiacomo, G., S. Tsai, and M. Bottlang. Impact performance comparison of advanced snow sport helmets with dedicated rotation-damping systems. Ann. Biomed. Eng. 2021. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10439-021-02723-0
Dompier, T. P., Z. Y. Kerr, S. W. Marshall, B. Hainline, E. M. Snook, R. Hayden, and J. E. Simon. Incidence of concussion during practice and games in youth, high school, and collegiate American football players. JAMA Pediatr. 169:659–665, 2015
European Committee for Standardization, C. E. 1078: Helmets for pedal cyclists and for users of skateboards and roller skates. 1997
Fahlstedt, M., F. Abayazid, M. B. Panzer, A. Trotta, W. Zhao, M. Ghajari, M. D. Gilchrist, S. Ji, S. Kleiven, X. Li, A. N. Annaidh, and P. Halldin. Ranking and rating bicycle helmet safety performance in oblique impacts using eight different brain injury models. Ann. Biomed. Eng. 49:1097–1109, 2021
Funk, J. R., S. M. Duma, S. J. Manoogian, and S. Rowson. Biomechanical risk estimates for mild traumatic brain injury. Annu. Proc. 51:343, 2007
Gabler, L. F., J. R. Crandall, and M. B. Panzer. Development of a second-order system for rapid estimation of maximum brain strain. Ann. Biomed. Eng. 2018. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10439-018-02179-9
Ghazi, K., S. Wu, W. Zhao, and S. Ji. Instantaneous whole-brain strain estimation in dynamic head impact. J. Neurotrauma. 38:1023–1035, 2021
Graham, R., F. P. Rivara, M. A. Ford, C. M. Spicer, and R. Graham. Sports-related concussions in youth. 2014, 239 pp
Greenwald, R. M., J. T. Gwin, J. J. Chu, and J. J. Crisco. Head impact severity measures for evaluating mild traumatic brain injury risk exposure. Neurosurgery. 62:789–798, 2008
Hernandez, F., L. C. Wu, M. C. Yip, K. Laksari, A. R. Hoffman, J. R. Lopez, G. A. Grant, S. Kleiven, and D. B. Camarillo. Six degree-of-freedom measurements of human mild traumatic brain injury. Ann. Biomed. Eng. 43:1918–1934, 2015
Høye, A. Bicycle helmets—To wear or not to wear? A meta-analyses of the effects of bicycle helmets on injuries. Accid. Anal. Prev. 117:85–97, 2018
Ji, S., H. Ghadyani, R. Bolander, J. Beckwith, J. C. Ford, T. McAllister, L. A. Flashman, K. D. Paulsen, K. Ernstrom, S. Jain, R. Raman, L. Zhang, and R. M. Greenwald. Parametric comparisons of intracranial mechanical responses from three validated finite element models of the human head. Ann. Biomed. Eng. 42:11–24, 2014
Ji, S., M. Ghajari, H. Mao, R. H. Kraft, M. Hajiaghamemar, M. B. Panzer, R. Willinger, M. D. Gilchrist, S. Kleiven, and J. D. Stitzel. Use of brain biomechanical models for monitoring impact exposure in contact sports. Ann. Biomed. Eng. 13(5):1121–1136, 2022
Ji, S., and S. S. Margulies. In vivo pons motion within the skull. J. Biomech. 40:, 2007
Ji, S., W. Zhao, J. C. Ford, J. G. Beckwith, R. P. Bolander, R. M. Greenwald, L. A. Flashman, K. D. Paulsen, and T. W. McAllister. Group-wise evaluation and comparison of white matter fiber strain and maximum principal strain in sports-related concussion. J. Neurotrauma. 32:441–454, 2015
Ji, S., W. Zhao, Z. Li, and T. W. McAllister. Head impact accelerations for brain strain-related responses in contact sports: a model-based investigation. Biomech. Model. Mechanobiol. 13:1121–1136, 2014
Ji, S., Q. Zhu, L. Dougherty, and S. S. S. Margulies. In vivo measurements of human brain displacement. Stapp Car Crash J. 48:527–539, 2004
King, A. I., K. H. Yang, L. Zhang, W. Hardy, and D. C. Viano. Is head injury caused by linear or angular acceleration? 2003
Kleiven, S. Predictors for traumatic brain injuries evaluated through accident reconstructions. Stapp Car Crash J. 51:81–114, 2007
Levy, M. L., B. M. Ozgur, C. Berry, H. E. Aryan, and M. L. J. Apuzzo. Birth and evolution of the football helmet. Neurosurgery. 55:656–662, 2004
Li, X., Z. Zhou, and S. Kleiven. An anatomically accurate and personalizable head injury model: significance of brain and white matter tract morphological variability on strain. Biomech. Model. Mechanobiol. 2020. https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.05.20.105635
Liu, Y., A. G. Domel, S. A. Yousefsani, J. Kondic, G. Grant, M. Zeineh, and D. B. Camarillo. Validation and comparison of instrumented mouthguards for measuring head kinematics and assessing brain deformation in football impacts. Ann. Biomed. Eng. 48:2580–2598, 2020
Mao, H., L. Zhang, B. Jiang, V. Genthikatti, X. Jin, F. Zhu, R. Makwana, A. Gill, G. Jandir, A. Singh, and K. Yang. Development of a finite element human head model partially validated with thirty five experimental cases. J. Biomech. Eng. 135:111002–111015, 2013
McCrea, M., T. Hammeke, G. Olsen, P. Leo, and K. Guskiewicz. Unreported concussion in high school football players: implications for prevention. Clin J Sport Med. 14:13–17, 2004
McIntosh, A. S., and A. Lai. Motorcycle helmets: head and neck dynamics in helmeted and unhelmeted oblique impacts. Traffic Inj. Prev. 14:835–844, 2013
McKee, A., T. Stein, C. Nowinski, R. Stern, D. Daneshvar, and V. E. Alvarez. The spectrum of disease in chronic traumatic encephalopathy. Brain. 136:43–64, 2013
Meaney, D. F., B. Morrison, and C. R. Bass. The mechanics of traumatic brain injury: a review of what we know and what we need to know for reducing its societal burden. J. Biomech. Eng. 136:1–8, 2014
Mez, J., D. Daneshvar, V. Kiernan, P. T. Abdolmohammadi, B. Alvarez, et al. Clinicopathological evaluation of chronic traumatic encephalopathy in players of American football. JAMA. 318:360–370, 2017
Miller, L. E., J. E. Urban, E. M. Davenport, A. K. Powers, C. T. Whitlow, J. A. Maldjian, and J. D. Stitzel. Brain strain: computational model-based metrics for head impact exposure and injury correlation. Ann. Biomed. Eng. 49:1083–1096, 2021
Miller, L. E., J. E. Urban, and J. D. Stitzel. Development and validation of an atlas-based finite element brain model model. Biomech. Model. 15:1201–1214, 2016
Miller, L., C. Kuo, L. C. Wu, J. Urban, D. Camarillo, and J. D. Stitzel. Validation of a custom instrumented retainer form factor for measuring linear and angular head impact kinematics. J. Biomech. Eng. 140:1–6, 2018
National Operating Committee on Standards for Athletic Equipment. Standard performance specification for newly manufactured baseball/softball batter’s helmets NOCSAE doc ( ND ) 022- 10m12. 6–11, 2019
National Operating Committee on Standards for Athletic Equipment. Standard Performance Specification for Newly Manufactured Baseball/Softball Batter’s Helmets. NOCSAE DOC (ND) 022-20, 2020
National Operating Committee on Standards for Athletic Equipment. Standard Performance Specification for Newly Manufactured Football Helmets. NOCSAE DOC (ND)002-17m21, 2021
Pellman, E. J., D. C. Viano, A. M. Tucker, I. R. Casson, J. F. Waeckerle, J. C. Maroon, M. R. Lovell, M. W. Collins, D. F. Kelly, A. B. Valadka, R. C. Cantu, J. E. Bailes, and M. L. Levy. Concussion in professional football: reconstruction of game impacts and injuries. Neurosurgery. 53:799–814, 2003
Rowson, S., E. T. Campolettano, S. M. Duma, B. Stemper, A. Shah, J. Harezlak, L. Riggen, J. P. Mihalik, A. Brooks, K. L. Cameron, S. J. Svoboda, M. N. Houston, T. McAllister, S. Broglio, and M. McCrea. Concussion risk between individual football players: survival analysis of recurrent events and non-events. Ann. Biomed. Eng. 48:2626–2638, 2020
Rowson, S., and S. M. Duma. Development of the STAR evaluation system for football helmets: integrating player head impact exposure and risk of concussion. Ann. Biomed. Eng. 39:2130–2140, 2011
Rowson, S., and S. M. Duma. Brain injury prediction: assessing the combined probability of concussion using linear and rotational head acceleration. Ann. Biomed. Eng. 41:873–882, 2013
Rowson, S., S. M. Duma, R. M. Greenwald, J. G. Beckwith, J. J. Chu, K. M. Guskiewicz, J. P. Mihalik, J. J. Crisco, B. J. Wilcox, T. W. McAllister, A. C. Maerlender, S. P. Broglio, B. Schnebel, S. Anderson, and P. G. Brolinson. Can helmet design reduce the risk of concussion in football? J. Neurosurg. 120:919–922, 2014
Rowson, S., S. M. Duma, B. D. Stemper, A. Shah, J. P. Mihalik, J. Harezlak, L. D. Riggen, C. C. Giza, J. P. DiFiori, A. Brooks, K. Guskiewicz, D. Campbell, G. McGinty, S. J. Svoboda, K. L. Cameron, S. P. Broglio, T. W. McAllister, and M. McCrea. Correlation of concussion symptom profile with head impact biomechanics: a case for individual-specific injury tolerance. J. Neurotrauma. 35:681–690, 2018
Rowson, B., S. Rowson, and S. M. Duma. Hockey STAR: a methodology for assessing the biomechanical performance of hockey helmets. Ann. Biomed. Eng. 43:2429–2443, 2015
Sanchez, E. J., L. F. Gabler, A. B. Good, J. R. Funk, J. R. Crandall, and M. B. Panzer. A reanalysis of football impact reconstructions for head kinematics and finite element modeling. Clin. Biomech. 64:82–89, 2018
Stemper, B. D., et al. Comparison of head impact exposure between concussed football athletes and matched controls: evidence for a possible second mechanism of sport-related concussion. Ann. Biomed. Eng. 2018. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10439-018-02136-6
Takhounts, E. G., S. A. Ridella, R. E. Tannous, J. Q. Campbell, D. Malone, K. Danelson, J. Stitzel, S. Rowson, and S. Duma. Investigation of traumatic brain injuries using the next generation of simulated injury monitor (SIMon) finite element head model. Stapp Car Crash J. 52:1–31, 2008
Tyson, A. M., and S. Rowson. Varsity Football Helmet STAR Protocol. 2018
Versace, J. A review of the severity index. 1971. https://doi.org/10.4271/710881
Viano, D. C., I. R. Casson, E. J. Pellman, L. Zhang, A. I. King, and K. H. Yang. Concussion in professional football: brain responses by finite element analysis: part 9. Neurosurgery. 57:891–915, 2005
Wu, S., W. Zhao, K. Ghazi, and S. Ji. Convolutional neural network for efficient estimation of regional brain strains. Sci. Rep. 9:17326, 2019
Wu, S., W. Zhao, and S. Ji. Real-time dynamic simulation for highly accurate spatiotemporal brain deformation from impact. Comput. Methods Appl. Mech. Eng.394:114913, 2022
Wu, S., W. Zhao, B. Rowson, S. Rowson, and S. Ji. A network-based response feature matrix as a brain injury metric. Biomech Model Mechanobiol. 19:927–942, 2020
Wu, S., W. Zhao, J. Ruan, S. Barbat, and S. Ji. Instantaneous brain strain estimation for automotive head impacts via deep learning. Stapp Car Crash J. 65:1–8, 2021
Zhao, W., and S. Ji. Brain strain uncertainty due to shape variation in and simplification of head angular velocity profiles. Biomech. Model. Mechanobiol. 16:449–461, 2017
Zhao, W., and S. Ji. White matter anisotropy for impact simulation and response sampling in traumatic brain injury. J. Neurotrauma. 36:250–263, 2019
Zhao, W., and S. Ji. Displacement- and strain-based discrimination of head injury models across a wide range of blunt conditions. Ann. Biomed. Eng. 20:1661–1677, 2020
Conflict of interest
The authors declare no competing interests.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Associate Editor Stefan M. Duma oversaw the review of this article.
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Ghazi, K., Begonia, M., Rowson, S. et al. American Football Helmet Effectiveness Against a Strain-Based Concussion Mechanism. Ann Biomed Eng 50, 1498–1509 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10439-022-03005-z
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10439-022-03005-z