Abstract
The aim of this study is to show that surgical treatment of early-stage squamous cell carcinomas of the oropharynx gives identical, if not better, oncological results than the classic radiotherapy treatment in terms of locoregional control and survival. Fifty-three patients (32 T1, 21 T2, all N0) were operated on during the years 1995–2000. Surgical treatment consisted in a resection by the transoral approach in 43 patients (81.13%); ten patients (18.87%) benefited from a pharyngectomy with (seven) or without (three) mandibular resection. A level I to V selective neck dissection was performed on 35 patients, and 5 patients underwent a level II to V selective neck dissection. The 1-, 3- and 5-year overall survival rates were 100, 94.6 and 73%, respectively. There was no significant difference concerning the tumor stage (P=0.69), the initial localization (P=0.64), the macroscopic aspect (P=0.65) and the management undertaken in the different centers (P=0.19). The 5-year rate of specific survival was 100%. The 1-, 3- and 5-year locoregional control rates were 96.22, 92.45 and 88.68, respectively. The oncological occurrences observed were 2 persistent diseases, 5 local recurrences, 11 second primary cancers and 0 nodal recurrences. Seven local failures were observed, all of which were controlled after a second treatment. Eleven patients presented second primary cancers; three died, two are alive with an extension of this second localization, and six are alive and free of disease. The locoregional control provided by surgery alone on T1-T2 N0 oropharyngeal cancers is as good as radiotherapy. Moreover surgery alone makes it possible to spare patients the complications and aftereffects of radiotherapy. It also makes it possible during the recurrences to operate on patients in non-irradiated areas with lower morbidity and mortality. It is all the more beneficial since it will be possible to resort to radiotherapy after surgery if need be.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Baitani JP, Asselain B, Jaulerry C, Brunin F, Bernier J, Pontvert D, Lave CA (1989) A multivariate primary tumour control analysis in 465 patients treated by radical radiotherapy for cancer of the tonsillar region: clinical and treatment parameters as prognostic factors. Radiother Oncol 1989 14:265–77
Beutter P, Pinlong E (1995) Cancers de la région amygdalienne. Encycl Méd Chir, Oto-rhino-laryngologie, 20–595 A-10. Elsevier, Paris, p 12
Cuisnier O., Righini Ch., Bolla M., Colonna M., Reyt E. (2002) Radiothérapie exclusive dans le traitement des carcinomes précoces de la région amygdalienne : à propos de 95 cas. In: Beauvillain de Montreuil C (ed) Cancers de l’oropharynx. Éditions EDK, pp 57–71
Eschwege F, Lusinchi A, Wibault P (1990) Radiothérapie en ORL. Editions techniques. Encycl Méd Chir, Oto-rhino-laryngologie, 20–901-G-10, 6–1990. Paris, France, p 10
Galati LT, Myers EN, Johnson JT (2000) Primary surgery as treatment for early squamous cell carcinoma of the tonsil. Head Neck 22:294–296
Gehanno P, Depondt J, Guedon C, Kebaili C, Koka V (1993) Primary and salvage surgery for cancer of the tonsillar region: a retrospective study of 120 patients. Head Neck 15:185–189
Johansen LV, Overgaard J, Overgaard M, Birkler N, Fisker A (1990) Squamous cell carcinoma of the oropharynx: an analysis of 213 consecutive patients schelduled for primary radiotherapy. Laryngoscope 100:985–990
Johansen LV, Grau C, Overgaard J (2000) Squamous cell carcinoma of the oropharynx—an analysis of treatment results in 289 consecutive patients. Acta Oncol 39:985–994
Le Clech G, Feat S, Mohr E, Godey B (2002) Exérèse par les voies naturelles des tumeurs oropharyngées. In: Beauvillain de Montreuil C (eds) Cancers de l’oropharynx. Éditions EDK, Pairs, pp 107–111
Lee WR, Mendenhall WM, Parsons JT, Millon RR, Cassisi NJ, Stringer SP (1993) Carcinoma of the tonsillar region: a multivariate analysis of 243 patients treated with radical radiotherapy. Head Neck 15:283–288
Leroux-Robert J, Guerrier Y (1981) Complications et séquelles de l’irradiation des tumeurs cervicofaciales. Actualités de Carcinologie Cervico-Faciales. Masson et Cie, Paris, pp 228–235
Lusinchi A, Wibault P, Marandas P, Kunkler I, Eschwege F (1989) Exclusive radiation therapy: the treatment of early tonsillar tumors. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys 17:273–277
Mendenhall WM, Amdur RJ, Stringer SP, Villaret DB, Cassisi NJ (2000) Radiation therapy for squamous cell carcinoma of the tonsillar region: a preferred alternative to surgery? J Clin Oncol 18:2219–2225
Meyza JW, Towpik E (1991) Surgical and cryosurgical salvage of oral and oropharyngeal cancer recurring after radical radiotherapy. Eur J Surg Oncol 17:567–570
O’Sullivan B, Warde P, Grice B, Goh C, Payne D, Liu FF, Waldron J, Bayley A, Irish J, Gullane P, Cummings B (2001) The benefits and pitfalls of ipsilateral radiotherapy in carcinoma of the tonsillar region. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys 51:332–343
Parsons JT, Mendenhall WM, Stringer SP, Amdur RJ, Hinerman RW, Villaret DB, Moore-Higgs GJ, Greene BD, Speer TW, Cassisi NJ, Million RR (2002) Squamous cell carcinoma of the oropharynx: surgery, radiation therapy, or both. Cancer 94:2967–2980
Perez CA, Carmichael T, Devineni VR et al (1991) Carcinoma of the tonsillar region : a non randomized comparison of irradiation alone or combined surgery: long term results. Head Neck 13:282–290
Pignat JC, Poupart M, Cosmidis A (2002) Tumeurs T1 T2 N0 de l’oropharynx opérées sans radiothérapie complémentaire : à propos de 19 patients de 1995 à 2000. In: Beauvillain de Montreuil C (ed) Cancers de l’oropharynx.” Éditions EDK, Paris, pp 113–116
Regueiro CA, Aragon G, Millan I, Valcarcel FJ, de la Torre A, Magallon R (1994) Prognostic factors for local control, regional control and survival in oropharyngeal squamous cell carcinoma. Eur J Cancer 30A:2060–1067
Righini C, Cuisnier O, Blanchet C, Bolla M, Reyt E (2001) La bucco-pharyngectomie transmandibulaire après échec de la radiothérapie dans les cancers de l’oropharynx. In: Baillet F (ed) Traitement des récidives locorégionales des cancers des VADS. Éditions EDK, pp165–164
Rodriguez J, Point D, Brunin F, Jaulerry C, Brugere J (1996) Chirurgie de l’oropharynx après radiothérapie. Bull Cancer Radiother 83:24–30
The BS, Woo SY, Butler EB (1999) Intensity modulated radiation therapy (IMRT): a new promising technology in radiation oncology. Oncologist 4:433–442
Teh BS, Mai WY, Grant WH 3rd, Chiu JK, Lu HH, Carpenter LS, Woo SY, Butler EB (2002) Intensity modulated radiotherapy (IMRT) decreases treatment-related morbidity and potentially enhances tumor control. Cancer Invest 20:437–451
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
This is a study by the Groupement d’Etudes des Tumeurs de la Tête et du Cou (GETTEC), the president of which is Dr. Dominique de Raucourt.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Cosmidis, A., Rame, JP., Dassonville, O. et al. T1-T2 NO oropharyngeal cancers treated with surgery alone. A GETTEC study. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol 261, 276–281 (2004). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00405-003-0694-8
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00405-003-0694-8