Abstract
Using analyses that control for phylogeny, we examine whether the shapes of horns and antlers in ungulates are related to style of fighting, environmental factors, mating and social systems, or are simply arbitrary. Many of the predictions that relate horn shape to species' fighting tactics and to their mating and social systems are supported. Bovids with tips facing inwards are likely to wrestle with their horns, be monogamous and solitary, whereas those with tips facing out tend to be polygynous and live in large groups. Smooth horns are used for stabbing, and are found in females of polygynous species living in large groups. In female bovids, twisted horns are found in large species and are used in wrestling whereas, in male bovids, straight horns are found in solitary species. Finally, deer with more than five antler tines tend to be large and to fight by fencing. There was little support for shape of horns and antlers being related to environmental factors, nor were shapes arbitrary as might be expected if they had arisen through female choice. Body size had little effect on these results. In general, monogamous solitary bovids have straight inwardly facing horns whereas polygynous group-living species demonstrate a wide variety of horn shapes.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Alvarez F (1990) Horns and fighting in male Spanish ibex, Capra pyrenaica. J Mammal 71:608–614
Andersson M (1994) Sexual selection. Princeton University Press, Princeton
Armstrong DM, Choate JR, Jones JJ Jr (1985) Guide to the mammals of the plains states. University of Nebraska Press, Lincoln, Neb
Bennett CL, Green MN, Lindsey SL (1999) The okapi: mysterious animal of Congo-Zaire. University of Texas Press, Austin, Tex
Berger J, Cunningham C (1995) Predation, sensitivity, and sex: why female black rhinoceroses outlive males. Behav Ecol 6:57–64
Berger J, Gompper ME (1999) Sex rations in extant ungulates: products of contemporary predation or past life histories. J Mammal 80:1084–1113
Binyuan G, Schaller, GB (1994) Ungulates in Northwest Tibet. Natl Geogr Res Explor 10:266–293
Blank DA, Kingswood SC (1996) Gazella subgutterosa. Mamm Species 518:1–10
Bowyer RT, Ledie DM Jr (1992) Ovis dalli. Mamm Species 393:1–7
Bubenik AB (1983) The behavioral aspects of anterogenesis. In: Brown RD (ed) Antler development in Cervidae. Caesar Kleberg Wildlife Research Institute, Kingsville, Tex, pp 389–449
Caro TM, Graham CM, Stoner CJ, Vargas JK (2003) Adaptive significance of antipredator behaviour in artiodactyls. Anim Behav (in press)
Chapman D, Chapman N (1975) Fallow deer: their history, distribution, and biology. Dalton, Lavenham
Cloudsley-Thompson JL (1980) Tooth and claw: defensive strategies in the animal world. Dent, London
Clutton-Brock TH (1982) The functions of antlers. Behaviour 79:108–125
Clutton-Brock TH, Albon SD, Harvey PH (1980) Antlers, body size and breeding group size in the Cervidae. Nature 285:565–567
Colbert EH (1955) The evolution of vertebrates. Wiley, New York
Dagg AI (1971) Giraffa camelopardalis. Mamm Species 5:1–8
Dagg AI, Foster JB (1976) The giraffe: its biology, behavior, and ecology. Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York
Danilkin AA (1996) Behavioral ecology of Siberian and European roe deer. Chapman & Hall, London
Darwin C (1871) The descent of man, and selection in relation to sex, 2nd edn. Murray, London
Eberhard WG (1979) The function of horns in Podischnus agenov (Dynastinae) and other beetles. In: Blum MS, Blum NA (eds) Sexual selection and reproductive competition in insects. Academic, New York, pp 231–258
Emlen DJ (2001) Costs and the diversification of exaggerated animal structures. Science 291:1534–1536
Espmark Y (1964) Studies in dominance-subordination relationship in a group of semi-domestic reindeer (Rangifer tarandus L.). Anim Behav 12:420–426
Estes RD (1991) The behavior guide to African mammals. University of California Press, Berkeley
Flerox KK (1952) Fauna of U.S.S.R.: mammals. USSR Academy of Sciences, Moscow
Franzmann AW (1981) Alces alces. Mamm Species 154:1–7
Freckleton RP, Harvey PH, Pagel M (2002) Phylogenetic analysis and comparative data: a test and review of evidence. Am Nat 160:712–726
Geist V (1966) The evolution of horn-like organs. Behaviour 27:175–214
Geist V (1987) On speciation in ice age mammals, with special reference to cervids and caprids. Can J Zool 65:1067–1084
Gould SJ (1974) The origin and function of "Bizarre" structures: antler size and skull size in the "Irish elk Megaloceros giganteus". Evolution 28:120–191
Gray GG, Simpson CD (1980) Armmotragus lervia. Mamm Species 144:1–7
Groves CP, Mendelssohn H, Yom-Tov Y (1995) Gazella gazella. Mamm Species 490:1–7
Grzimek B (1990) Grzimek's encyclopedia of mammals. McGraw-Hill, New York
Guiguet CJ, McTaggart Cowan I (1965) The mammals of British Columbia. Department of Recreation and Conservation, British Columbia
Harvey PH, Pagel MD (1991) The comparative method in evolutionary biology. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Henshaw J (1969) Antlers—bones of contention. Nature 224:1036–1037
Hoffman RS, Neas JF (1987) Budorcas taxicolor. Mamm Species 277:1–7
Hoffman RS, Rideout CB (1975) Oreamos americanos. Mamm Species 63:1–6
Hoffman RS, Wang X (1987) Pseudois nayaur and P. schaeferi. Mamm Species 278:1–6
Holmes F (1974) Following the roe: a natural history of the roe deer. Bartholomew, Edinburgh
Huntingford FA, Turner AK (1987) Animal conflict. Chapman & Hall, London
Jackson JE (1987) Ozotoceros bezoarticus. Mamm Species 295:1–5
Johnson RL, Lockard FR (1983) Mountain goats and mountain sheep of Washington. Washington Department of Game, Olympia, Wash
Junrang R, Mingjiang Q, Schaller GB (1991) Observations on the Tibetan antelope (Pantholops hodgsoni). Appl Anim Behav Sci 29:361–378
Kaji K, Koizumi T, Miura S, Ohtaishi N, Tokida K, Wu J (1993) Social organization and mating behavior of white-lipped deer in the Qinghai-Xizang plateau, China. In: Ohtaishi N, Sheng H-I (eds) Deer of China: biology and management. Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp 147–158
Kiltie RA (1985) Evolution and function of horns and hornlike organs in female ungulates. Biol J Linn Soc 24:299–320
Kingswood SC, Kumamoto AT (1996) Madoqua guentheri. Mamm Species 539:1–10
Kitchen DW (1974) Social behavior and ecology of pronghorn. Wildl Monogr 38:1–96
Kitchener A (1985) The effect of behaviour and body weight on the morphological design of horns. J Zool Lond 205:191–203
Kitchener A (1991) The evolution and mechanical design of horns and antlers. In: Rayner JMV, Wootton, RJ (eds) Biomechanics in evolution. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 229–253
Knight RR (1970) The Sun Elk River herd. Wildl Monogr 23:1–66
Krausman PR, Valdez R (1999) Mountain sheep of North America. University of Arizona Press, Tucson, Ariz
Lent PC (1988) Ovibos moschatus. Mamm Species 302:1–9
Lorch PD, Eadie JM (1999) Power of the concentrated changes test for correlated evolution. Syst Biol 48:170–191
Lundrigan B (1996) Morphology of horns and fighting behavior in the family Bovidae. J Mammal 77:462–475
Maddison WP (1990) A method for testing the correlated evolution of two binary characters: are gains and losses concentrated on certain branches of the phylogenetic tree? Evolution 44:539–557
Maddison WP, Maddison DR (1992) MacClade: analysis of phylogeny and character evolution. Sinauer, Sunderland, Mass
McClelland BE (1991) Courtship and antagonistic behavior in mouflon sheep. Appl Anim Behav Sci 29:67–85
Mungall EC, Sheffield WJ (1994) Exotics on the range: the Texas example. Texas A&M University Press, College Station, Tex
Nowak RM (1999) Walker's mammals of the world. John Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, Md
O'Gara BW (1978) Antilocapra americana. Mamm Species 90:1–7
Ortolani A (1999) Spots, stripes, tail tips and dark eyes: predicting the function of carnivore colour patterns using the comparative method. Biol J Linn Soc 67:433–476
Ortolani A, Caro TM (1996) The adaptive significance of color patterns in carnivores: phylogenetic tests of classic hypotheses. In: Gittleman J (ed) Carnivore behavior, ecology, evolution, vol 2. Comstock, Ithaca, N.Y., pp 132–188
Otte D, Stayman K (1979) Beetle horns: some patterns in functional morphology. In: Blum MS, Blum NA (eds) Sexual selection and reproductive competition in insects. Academic, New York, pp 259–292
Packer C (1983) Sexual dimorphism: the horns of African antelopes. Science 221:1191–1193
Ralls K (1973) Cephalophus maxwelli. Mamm Species 31:1–4
Rice WR (1989) Analyzing tables of statistical tests. Evolution 43:223–225
Richter W von (1974) Connochaetes gnou. Mamm Species 50:1–6
Roberts SC (1996) The evolution of hornedness in female ruminants. Behaviour 133:399–442
Schaffer WM (1968) Intraspecific combat and the evolution of the Caprini. Evolution 22:817–825
Schaller GB (1977) Mountain monarchs: wild sheep and goats of the Himalaya. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Schaller GB (1998) Wildlife of the Tibetan steppe. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Shackleton DM (1985) Ovis canadensis. Mamm Species 230:1–9
Shrestha TK (1997) Mammals of Nepal: with reference to those of India, Bangladesh, Bhutan, and Pakistan. Bimala Shrestha, Kathmandu
Simpson GG (1949) The meaning of evolution. New American Library, Mentor Book
Sokolov VE (1974) Saiga tatanica. Mamm Species 38:1–4
Spinage CA (1968) The book of the giraffe. Collins, London
Stoner CJ, Caro TM, Graham CM (2003) Ecological and behavioral correlates of coloration in artiodactyls: systematic attempts to verify conventional hypotheses. Behav Ecol (in press)
Stuart C (1988) Field guide to the mammals of southern Africa. New Holland, London
Valdez R (1982) The wild sheep of the world. Wild Sheep and Goat International, Mesila, N.M.
Walther FR (1974) Some reflections on expressive behaviour in combats and courtship of certain horned ungulates. In: Geist V, Walther F (eds) The behaviour of ungulates and its relation to management. International Union for the Conservation of Nature and Natural Resources, Morges, pp 56–106
Walther FR (1984) Communication and expression in hoofed mammals. Indiana University Press, Bloomington, Ind
Wood RJ (1992) The propagation and maintenance of the Arabian tahr, Hemitragus jayakari, at the Omani mammal breeding centre, Bait al Barakah. Int Zoo Yearb 31:255–260
Wormer J van (1969) The world of the American elk. Lippincott, Philadelphia, Pa
Acknowledgements
We thank the McNair Scholars Program for supporting C.M.G., the University of California for supporting C.J.S., Janelle Vargas for help with coding variables, Sheila Montgomery for help with analysis of shape syndromes, and Joel Berger and two anonymous reviewers for comments. No experiments were involved in this study.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Communicated by M. Elgar
Electronic Supplementary Material
Appendix
Appendix
Data on shapes of horns and antlers and morphological, behavioral and ecological variables used in this study
M refers to males, F to females. In the body of the Appendix, 1 refers to presence, 0 to absence, ? to insufficient information, and a blank cell denotes not applicable (note neither sex in Hydropotes inermis has horns). In the column marked body size, only species included in our phylogenetic trees were used to calculate median body weights; other species are denoted by "a". L refers to greater than the median body weight for either cervids or bovids, S to less than the median body weight, M to the median itself.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Caro, T.M., Graham, C.M., Stoner, C.J. et al. Correlates of horn and antler shape in bovids and cervids. Behav Ecol Sociobiol 55, 32–41 (2003). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00265-003-0672-6
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00265-003-0672-6