Abstract
Purpose
The aims of this meta-analysis were to determine the sensitivity and specificity of the Lachman, pivot shift and anterior drawer test for acute complete ACL rupture in the office setting and under anaesthesia. It was hypothesized that the Lachman test is the most sensitive and the pivot shift test the most specific. Secondly, it was hypothesized that the sensitivity and specificity of all three exams increases when the examination is performed under anaesthesia.
Methods
An electronic database search was performed using MEDLINE and EMBASE. All cross-sectional and cohort studies comparing one or more physical examination tests for diagnosing acute complete ACL rupture to an accepted reference standard such as arthroscopy, arthrotomy and MRI were included.
Results
Twenty studies were identified and included. The overall sensitivity of the Lachman test was 0.81 and the specificity 0.81; with anaesthesia, the sensitivity was 0.91 and the specificity 0.78. For the anterior drawer test, the sensitivity was 0.38 and the specificity 0.81; with anaesthesia, the sensitivity was 0.63 and the specificity 0.91. The sensitivity of the pivot shift test was 0.28 and the specificity 0.81; with anaesthesia, the sensitivity was 0.73 and the specificity 0.98.
Conclusion
In the office setting, the Lachman test has the highest sensitivity for diagnosing an acute, complete ACL rupture, while all three tests had comparable specificity. When the examination was performed under anaesthesia, the Lachman test still obtained the highest sensitivity, but the pivot shift test was the most specific.
Level of evidence
Meta-analysis of diagnostic test accuracy, Level II.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Anderson AF, Lipscomb AB (1989) Preoperative instrumented testing of anterior and posterior knee laxity. Am J Sports Med 17:387–392
Anderson AF, Snyder RB, Federspiel CF, Lipscomb AB (1992) Instrumented evaluation of knee laxity: a comparison of five arthrometers. Am J Sports Med 20:135–140
Benjaminse A, Gokeler A, van der Schans CP (2006) Clinical diagnosis of an anterior cruciate ligament rupture: a meta-analysis. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther 36:267–288
Bhandari M, Montori VM, Swiontkowski MF, Guyatt GH (2003) User’s guide to the surgical literature: how to use an article about a diagnostic test. J Bone Joint Surg Am 85-A:1133–1140
Bomberg BC, McGinty JB (1990) Acute hemarthrosis of the knee: indications for diagnostic arthroscopy. Arthroscopy 6:221–225
Crawford R, Walley G, Bridgman S, Maffulli N (2007) Magnetic resonance imaging versus arthroscopy in the diagnosis of knee pathology, concentrating on meniscal lesions and ACL tears: a systematic review. Br Med Bull 84:5–23
Dahlstedt LJ, Dalen N (1989) Knee laxity in cruciate ligament injury. Value of examination under anesthesia. Acta Orthop Scand 60:181–184
DeHaven KE (1980) Diagnosis of acute knee injuries with hemarthrosis. Am J Sports Med 8:9–14
Donaldson WF 3rd, Warren RF, Wickiewicz T (1985) A comparison of acute anterior cruciate ligament examinations. Initial versus examination under anesthesia. Am J Sports Med 13:5–10
Harilainen A (1987) Evaluation of knee instability in acute ligamentous injuries. Ann Chir Gynaecol 76:269–273
Hughston JC, Andrews JR, Cross MJ, Moschi A (1976) Classification of knee ligament instabilities. Part I. The medial compartment and cruciate ligaments. J Bone Joint Surg Am 58:159–172
Jonsson T, Althoff B, Peterson L, Renstrom P (1982) Clinical diagnosis of ruptures of the anterior cruciate ligament: a comparative study of the Lachman test and the anterior drawer sign. Am J Sports Med 10:100–102
Katz JW, Fingeroth RJ (1986) The diagnostic accuracy of ruptures of the anterior cruciate ligament comparing the Lachman test, the anterior drawer sign, and the pivot shift test in acute and chronic knee injuries. Am J Sports Med 14:88–91
Kim SJ, Kim HK (1995) Reliability of the anterior drawer test, the pivot shift test, and the Lachman test. Clin Orthop Relat Res 317:237–242
Learmonth DJ (1991) Incidence and diagnosis of anterior cruciate injuries in the accident and emergency department. Injury 22:287–290
Lee JK, Yao L, Phelps CT, Wirth CR, Czajka J, Lozman J (1988) Anterior cruciate ligament tears: MR imaging compared with arthroscopy and clinical tests. Radiology 166:861–864
Lintner DM, Kamaric E, Moseley JB, Noble PC (1995) Partial tears of the anterior cruciate ligament. Are they clinically detectable? Am J Sports Med 23:111–118
Liu SH, Osti L, Henry M, Bocchi L (1995) The diagnosis of acute complete tears of the anterior cruciate ligament. Comparison of MRI, arthrometry and clinical examination. J Bone Joint Surg Br 77:586–588
Losee RE, Johnson TR, Southwick WO (1978) Anterior subluxation of the lateral tibial plateau. A diagnostic test and operative repair. J Bone Joint Surg Am 60:1015–1030
Lucie RS, Wiedel JD, Messner DG (1984) The acute pivot shift: clinical correlation. Am J Sports Med 12:189–191
Marshall JL, Wang JB, Furman W, Girgis FG, Warren R (1975) The anterior drawer sign: what is it? J Sports Med 3:152–158
Mitsou A, Vallianatos P (1988) Clinical diagnosis of ruptures of the anterior cruciate ligament: a comparison between the Lachman test and the anterior drawer sign. Injury 19:427–428
Muriuki MG, Tuason DA, Tucker BG, Harner CD (2011) Changes in tibiofemoral contact mechanics following radial split and vertical tears of the medial meniscus an in vitro investigation of the efficacy of arthroscopic repair. J Bone Joint Surg Am 93:1089–1095
Musahl V, Ayeni OR, Citak M, Irrgang JJ, Pearle AD, Wickiewicz TL (2010) The influence of bony morphology on the magnitude of the pivot shift. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc 18:1232–1238
Musahl V, Bedi A, Citak M, O’Loughlin P, Choi D, Pearle AD (2010) Effect of single-bundle and double-bundle anterior cruciate ligament reconstructions on pivot-shift kinematics in anterior cruciate ligament- and meniscus-deficient knees. Am J Sports Med 39:289–295
Musahl V, Bell KM, Tsai AG, Costic RS, Allaire R, Zantop T, Irrgang JJ, Fu FH (2007) Development of a simple device for measurement of rotational knee laxity. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc 15:1009–1012
Musahl V, Citak M, O’Loughlin PF, Choi D, Bedi A, Pearle AD (2010) The effect of medial versus lateral meniscectomy on the stability of the anterior cruciate ligament-deficient knee. Am J Sports Med 38:1591–1597
Musahl V, Voos J, O’Loughlin PF, Stueber V, Kendoff D, Pearle AD (2010) Mechanized pivot shift test achieves greater accuracy than manual pivot shift test. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc 18:1208–1213
Noyes FR, Bassett RW, Grood ES, Butler DL (1980) Arthroscopy in acute traumatic hemarthrosis of the knee. Incidence of anterior cruciate tears and other injuries. J Bone Joint Surg Am 62(687–95):757
Noyes FR, Grood ES, Cummings JF, Wroble RR (1991) An analysis of the pivot shift phenomenon. The knee motions and subluxations induced by different examiners. Am J Sports Med 19:148–155
Prodromos CC, Han Y, Rogowski J, Joyce B, Shi K (2007) A meta-analysis of the incidence of anterior cruciate ligament tears as a function of gender, sport, and a knee injury-reduction regimen. Arthroscopy 15(7):851–856
Sandberg R, Balkfors B, Henricson A, Westlin N (1986) Stability tests in knee ligament injuries. Arch Orthop Trauma Surg 106:5–7
Scholten RJ, Opstelten W, van der Plas CG, Bijl D, Deville WL, Bouter LM (2003) Accuracy of physical diagnostic tests for assessing ruptures of the anterior cruciate ligament: a meta-analysis. J Fam Pract 52:689–694
Schwarz W, Hagelstein J, Minholz R, Schierlinger M, Danz B, Gerngross H (1997) Manual ultrasound of the knee joint. A general practice method for diagnosis of fresh rupture of the anterior cruciate ligament. Unfallchirurg 100:280–285
Simonsen O, Jensen J, Mouritsen P, Lauritzen J (1984) The accuracy of clinical examination of injury of the knee joint. Injury 16:96–101
Slocum DB, James SL, Larson RL, Singer KM (1976) Clinical test for anterolateral rotary instability of the knee. Clin Orthop Relat Res 118:63–69
Strand T, Solheim E (1995) Clinical tests versus KT-1000 instrumented laxity test in acute anterior cruciate ligament tears. Int J Sports Med 16:51–53
Tonino AJ, Huy J, Schaafsma J (1986) The diagnostic accuracy of knee testing in the acutely injured knee. Initial examination versus examination under anaesthesia with arthroscopy. Acta Orthop Belg 52:479–487
Torg JS, Conrad W, Kalen V (1976) Clinical diagnosis of anterior cruciate ligament instability in the athlete. Am J Sports Med 4:84–93
Tsai AG, Musahl V, Steckel H, Bell KM, Zantop T, Irrgang JJ, Fu FH (2008) Rotational knee laxity: reliability of a simple measurement device in vivo. BMC Musculoskelet Disord 9:35
Wirth CJ, Kolb M (1985) Hemarthrosis and the isolated anterior cruciate ligament lesion. Value of clinical diagnosis. Unfallchirurg 88:419–423
Zantop T, Brucker PU, Vidal A, Zelle BA, Fu FH (2007) Intraarticular rupture pattern of the ACL. Clin Orthop Relat Res 454:48–53
Conflict of interest
Dr. Freddie H. Fu discloses that his department receives research and educational funding from Smith and Nephew, not directly related to the research presented in this manuscript. The other authors report no disclosures.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
van Eck, C.F., van den Bekerom, M.P.J., Fu, F.H. et al. Methods to diagnose acute anterior cruciate ligament rupture: a meta-analysis of physical examinations with and without anaesthesia. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc 21, 1895–1903 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00167-012-2250-9
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00167-012-2250-9