Abstract
Across the western and northern European range of diadromous Salmo salar (Atlantic salmon) during the Middle Ages (ca.500–ca.1500 CE), this fish was a highly prized object of elite human consumption, of intense seasonal fishing, of human competition, and, by the 1200s, a victim of evident depletion. What, then, enabled long traditional riverine fisheries in Scotland to become a major export producer in late medieval centuries? Provisional survey of published written records, some archival collections, and archaeological evidence establishes the great value Scottish kings and landowners placed on salmon fishing sites and their product. Knowledgeable workers for the holders of fishing rights caught salmon especially with beach seines and fixed weirs. Their catch went to elite households and urban markets for domestic consumption and was especially from the late 1300s packed in barrels for export to regions around the North Sea where diminished native runs failed to meet rising demand. Medieval Scots competed for the right to catch their salmon but did not complain that those catches were shrinking. From about 1200 royal judgments and by the early 1300s parliamentary legislation placed Scottish salmon fisheries under public regulation, prohibiting fishing at certain times and seasons and requiring all gear to permit passage of pre-migrant juveniles. Early imposition in Scotland of these limits to private fishing rights as well as an agrarian regime that (unintentionally) minimized barriers to migrants and preserved headwater spawning habitats may help explain the apparently greater sustainability of salmon stocks in Scotland than elsewhere in late medieval Europe.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
Only two partial exceptions to this generalization come readily to mind: a broken run of herring landed (tonnes) in Dieppe, with 32 annual entries between 1405/6 and 1491/2 (Mollat 1952, Annex 3); and an account book kept by the fisheries manager for the Teutonic Order (warrior monks) in Prussia, 1440–1445, which details weekly shipments of fish (several taxa) from the Order’s fishery in Lake Drużno (German Drausensee) to Order headquarters at Marienburg (Malbork) (Nowak and Tandecki 1997). The latter may represent actual catches. Even the published fourteenth century accounts from the trap on the Loire and seine on the Thames mentioned above (p. nn) do not enumerate the salmon taken and sold or those caught by lessees (Fournial 1967; Rogers 1866). Of course statistics for stocking and/or harvest from artificial fish culture enterprises in France, the German Empire, Bohemia, and England are reasonably common from and after the early-mid fourteenth century (for examples and discussion see Hoffmann 1995, 2000, pp. 376–393, 2008a; Hoffmann and Winiwarter 2010, and works there cited). The direct quantitative interest of medieval record-keepers was economic yield (expenditures and receipts), not natural science.
Assise Willelmi Regis, art. 10: “in tantum quo unus porcus trium annorum bene pastus est longus ita quod neque grunnus porci appropinquet sepi nec cauda…”.
“secundum leges et assisas regni nostri…”.
“…ne aliquis presumat piscari ad salmones vel salmunculos temporibus prohibitis super antiquam penam”. [always assuming the latter curious entry in the Coupar chartulary was not created by the monks to solve a later problem—but see below for the slow legislative process to eliminate all such privileges].
“quod omnes illi qui habent croas vel piscarias vel stagna aut molendina in aquis ubi ascendit mare et se retrahit et ubi salmunculi vel smolti seu fria alterius generis piscium maris vel aque dulcis descendunt et ascendunt, tales croe et machine infra posite sint ad minus de mensura duorum pollicium in longitudine et trium pollicium in latitudine ita quod nulla fria piscium impediatur ascendendo vel descendendo secundum quod libere possunt ascendere et descendere ubique”.
Fifteenth century parliamentary statutes no longer used Latin.
References
Anthimus (1963) De observatione ciborum ad Theodoricum regem Francorum epistula. Eduard Liechtenhan (ed. and tr) Corpus medicorum Latinorum, vol 8:1. rev. ed. Academiae Scientiarum, Berlin
Bailey G et al (2008) Historical ecology of the North Sea basin: an archaeological perspective and some problems of methodology. In: Rick TC, Erlandson JM (eds) Human impacts on ancient marine ecosystems. A global perspective. University of California Press, Berkeley, pp 215–242
Balon J (1942) La pêche et le commerce du poisson dans le comté de Namur au Moyen âge. Namurcum 19:28–31
Barrett JH, Nicholson RA, Cerón-Carrasco R (1999) Archaeo-ichthyological evidence for long-term socioeconomic trends in northern Scotland 3500 BC to AD 1500. J Archaeol Sci 26:353–388
Barrow GWS (ed) (1999) The charters of King David I: the written acts of David I King of Scots, 1124-53 and of his son Henry Earl of Northumberland, 1139-52. Boydell Press, Rochester
Bathgate TD (1948/1949) Ancient Fish-Traps or Yairs in Scotland. In: Proceedings of the society of antiquaries of Scotland vol 83, pp 98–102
Batten EC (1877) The Charters of the Priory of Beauly with notices of the priories of Pluscardine and Ardchattan and of the Family of the Founder John Byset. McFarlane and Erskine for the Grampian Club, Edinburgh
Bernard A (ed) (1853) Cartulaire de l’Abbaye de Savigny suivi du Petit Cartulaire de l’Abbaye d’Ainay. vol 2. Collection de documents inédits sur l’histoire de France. 1. sér. Impr. Imperial, Histoire politique. Paris
Cerón-Carrasco R (2013) Fish and marine-shell remains. In: Addyman T, Romankiewicz T, Macfadyen K, Ross A, Uglow N (eds) The medieval kirk, cemetery and hospice at Kirk Ness, North Berwick. Oxbow, Oxford, pp 44–48
Cohen N (2011) Early Anglo-Saxon fish traps on the River Thames. In: Brookes S, Harrington S, Reynolds A (eds) Studies in Early Anglo-Saxon Art and Archaeology. Papers in honour of Martin G. Welch. BAR British series 527, Archaeopress, Oxford, pp 131–139
Cooper JA [Lord Cooper of Culross] (ed. and tr.) (1947) Regiam majestatem and Quoniam attachiamenta based on the text of Sir John Skene, J. Skinner for the Stair Society, Edinburgh
Cooper JA [Lord Cooper of Culross] (1957a) Curiosities of Medieval Scots Law. In: his Selected Papers 1922–1954, pp 93–107, Oliver and Boyd, Edinburgh
Cooper JA [Lord Cooper of Culross] (1957b) Early Scottish statutes revisited. In: his Selected Papers 1922–1954, pp 237–243, Oliver and Boyd, Edinburgh
Coy J (1989) Fish bones. In: Astill GG, Lobb SJ Roman and Saxon Deposits at Wraysbury. The Archaeol J vol 146, pp 118–120 & microfiche M1/68-74
Dalglish C (2012) Scotland’s medieval countryside: evidence, interpretation, perception. In: Christie N, Stamper P (eds) Medieval rural settlement: Britain and Ireland, AD 800–1600. Windgather Press, Oxford, pp 270–287
de Vitry J (1914) Die Exempla aus den Sermones feriales et communes des Jakob von Vitry. In: Greven J (ed) C. Winter, Heidelberg
Dietz K (1986) Modern English Cruive ‘wicker salmon-trap’. In: Kastovsky D, Szwedek A (eds) Linguistics across historical and geographical boundaries, vol I. Mouton, De Gruyter, Berlin, pp 277–291
Ditchburn D (2001) Scotland and Europe: the medieval kingdom and its contacts with Christendom, c.1245–1545. Vol I: Religion, culture and commerce. Tuckwell, Linton
Dyer C (1997) Do household accounts provide an accurate picture of late medieval diet and food culture? In: Rassart-Eeckhout E et al (eds) La vie matérielle au moyen âge. L’apport des sources litteraires, normatives et de la pratique, Actes du Colloque international de Louvain-la-Neuve 3-5 octobre 1996. Université Catholique de Louvain, Publications de l’Institut d’Études Medievales, Textes, Études, Congrès, vol 18. L’Institut, Louvain-la-Neuve, pp 109–125
Easson DE (ed) (1947) Charters of the Abbey of Coupar Angus, 2 vols. T. and A. Constable for the Scottish History Society, Edinburgh
Enghoff IB (2000) Fishing in the Southern North Sea Region from the 1st to the 16th Century AD: evidence from Fish Bones. Archaeofauna 9:59–132
European Parliament (2000) Directive 2000/60/ec of the European parliament and of the council of 23 October 2000 establishing a framework for Community action in the field of water policy. Off J Eur Communities 22.12.2000, L:327/1-72
Fergus TD (ed. and tr.) (1996) Quoniam attachiamenta. The Stair Society, Edinburgh
Ford JS, Myers RA (2008) A global assessment of salmon aquaculture impacts on wild salmonids. PLoS Biol 6(2):e33. doi:10.1371/journal.pbio.0060033
Foster S, Smout TC (eds) (1994) The history of soils and field systems. Scottish Cultural Press, Aberdeen
Fournial E (1967) Les villes et l’économie d’échange en Forez aux XIIIe et XIVe siècles. les Presses du Palais Royal, Paris
Franck R (1694) Northern Memoirs calculated for the Meridian of Scotland to which is added, the Contemplative and Practical Angler writ in the Year 1658. [London]: Henry Mortclock[sic] for the author
Gemmill E, Mayhew N (1995) Changing values in medieval Scotland: a study of prices, money, and weights and measures. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Haidvogl G, Lajus D, Pont D, Schmid M, Jungwirth M, Lajus J (2014) Typology of historical sources and the reconstruction of long-term historical changes of riverine fish: a case study of the Austrian Danube and northern Russian rivers. Ecol Freshw Fish 23:498–515. doi:10.1111/eff.12103
Halard X (1983) La pêche du saumon en Normandie du XIe au XVe siècle. J Mediev Hist 9:173–178
Hale AG (2005) Fish-traps in Scotland: construction, supply, demand and destruction. In: Klápště J (ed) Water management in medieval rural economy. Les usages de l’eau en milieu rural au Moyen Âge, 119–126. Památky archeologické, Supplementum 17, Ruralia V. Institute of Archaeology, Academy of Sciences of the Czech Republic, Prague
Heinricsh D, Heidermanns F (2001) Lachs. In: Beck H et al (eds) Reallexikon der Germanischen Altertumskunde, vol 17, 2nd edn. Walter de Gruyter, Berlin, pp 528–532
Hoffmann RC (1985) Fishing for sport in medieval Europe: new evidence. Speculum 60:877–902
Hoffmann RC (1995) Carpes pour le duc…: the operation of fish ponds at La Perriére-sur-Saône, Burgundy, 1338-52. Archaeofauna [Madrid] 4:33–45
Hoffmann RC (1996) Economic development and aquatic ecosystems in medieval Europe. Am Hist Rev 101:631–669
Hoffmann RC (2000) Medieval fishing. In: Squatriti P (ed) Working with water in medieval Europe: technology and resource use. Brill, Leiden, pp 331–393
Hoffmann RC (2005) A brief history of aquatic resource use in medieval Europe. In: Lotze HK, Reise K (eds) Helgoland marine research 59:1 [special issue ‘Ecological history of the Wadden Sea’], pp 22–30
Hoffmann RC (2008a) Aquaculture in Champagne before the Black Death of 1348–1350. In: Béarez P, Grouard S, Clavel B (eds) Archéologie du poisson. 30 ans d’archéo-ichtyologie au CNRS. Hommage aux travaux de Jean Desse et Nathalie Desse-Berset, pp 67–82. XXVIIe rencontres internationales d’archéologie et d’histoire d’Antibes. Éditions APDCA, Antibes
Hoffmann RC (2008b) Medieval Europeans and their aquatic ecosystems. In: Herrmann B (ed) Beiträge zum Göttinger Umwelthistorischen Kolloquium 2007–2008. Universitätsverlag, Göttingen, pp 45–64. [http://webdoc.sub.gwdg.de/univerlag/2008/umweltkolloquium_2.pdf]
Hoffmann RC (2010) Elemental resources and aquatic ecosystems: medieval Europeans and their rivers. In: Tvedt T, Coopey R (eds) Rivers and society: from early civilizations to modern times. A history of water, series 2, vol 2. I. B. Tauris, London, pp 163–200
Hoffmann RC (2014) An environmental history of medieval Europe. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Hoffmann RC, Winiwarter V (2010) Making land and water meet: cycling of nutrients between fields and ponds in pre-modern Europe. Agric Hist 84:352–380
Huster-Plogmann H (2007) Fische. In: Deschler-Erb S, Bopp-Ito M, Hüster-Plogmann H, Die mittelalterlichen Tierknochen aus dem Kreuzgangbereich des Stiftes St. Arnaul. In: Herrmann H-W, Selmer J (eds) Leben und Sterben in einem mittelalterlichen Kollegiatstift. Archäologische und baugeschichteliche Untersuchungen im ehemaligen Stift St. Arnaul in Saarbrücken, pp 529–532. (n.p.), Saarbrücken
Innes C (ed) (1867) Ledger of Andrew Halyburton conservator of the privileges of the Scotch Nation in the Netherlands, 1492-1503. Her Majesty’s General Register House, Edinburgh
Jarecki W (ed) (1981) Signa loquendi: Die cluniacensischen Signa-Listen eingeleitet und herausgegeben. Saecula spiritalia, ed. Dieter Wuttke, vol 4. Koerner, Baden-Baden
Jenkins JG (1984) The trapping of salmon in the rivers of England and Wales. In: Gunda B (ed) The fishing culture of the world: studies in ethnology, cultural ecology and Folklore, vol I. Akadémiai Kiadó, Budapest, pp 239–250
Jones AGK (2012) The fish bone. In: Perry D, Murray H, Jones TB, Bogdan NQ (eds) Perth high street, archaeological excavation, 1975–1977, vol 4. Tayside and Fife Archaeological Committee, Perth, pp 53–57
Lampen A (1996) Medieval fish weirs: the archaeological and historical evidence. Archaeofauna 5:129–134
Lampen A (2000) Fischerei und Fischhandel im Mittelalter: Wirtschafts- und sozialgeschichtliche Untersuchungen nach urkundlichen und archäologischen Quellen des 6. bis 14.Jahrhunderts im Gebiet des Deutschen Reichs. Historische Studien, Bd. 461. Matthiesen Verlag, Husum
Lardin P, Jegou L (2004) La pêche en basse Seine à la fin du Moyen Age. In: Benoît P, Loridant F, Mattéoni O (eds) Pêche et pisciculture en eau douce: la rivière et l’étang au Moyen Âge: actes des 1res Rencontres internationales de Liessies: 27, 28, 29 avril 1998. [unpaginated booklet and CD-ROM] [Lille:] Conseil Général du Nord
Łęga W (1949) Obraz gospodarczy Pomorza Gdańskiego w XII i XIII wieku. Prace Instytutu Zachodniego, nr. 14. Instytut Zachodni, Poznań
Maitland PS (2007) Scotland’s freshwater fish: ecology, conservation and folklore. Trafford, Edinburgh
Major J (1892) A history of Greater Britain as well England as Scotland compiled from the ancient authorities by John Major…1521. Constable A (ed. and tr.). Printed at the University press by T. and A. Constable for the Scottish History Society, Edinburgh
McRoberts D (1959) Material destruction caused by the Scottish reformation. Innes Rev 10:126–177
Miéjac E (2004) La pêche en Loire dans la Généralité d’Orléans à l’Epoque modern. In: Benoît P, Loridant F, Mattéoni O (eds) Pêche et pisciculture en eau douce: la rivière et l’étang au Moyen Âge: actes des 1res Rencontres internationales de Liessies: 27, 28, 29 avril 1998. [unpaginated booklet and CD-Rom] ([Lille:] Conseil Général du Nord
Mollat M (1952) Le Commerce maritime Normand a la fin du moyen age. Plon, Paris
Neville CJ (2010) Land, law and people in medieval Scotland. Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh
Nowak ZH, Tandecki J (eds) (1997) Liber rationum magistrorum piscaturae commendarum Marienburgensis et Christburgensis 1440-1445. Księga rachunkowa urzędów rybickich komturstw Malborskiego i Dzierzgońskiego 1440-1445. Towarzystwo Naukowe w Toruniu, Fontes 82. Towarzystwo Naukowe and Uniwersytet Mikołaja Kopernika, Toruń
O’Sullivan A (1995) Medieval fishweirs on the Deel estuary, Co. Limerick. Archaeol Ireland 9(2):15–17
O’Sullivan A (2001) Foragers, farmers and fishers in a coastal landscape: an intertidal archaeological survey of the Shannon estuary. Royal Irish Academy, Dublin
Oram RD (2010) Environmental change in West Highland and Hebridean Scotland, c. 1300 to c.1450. In: Cavaciocchi S (ed) Economic and biological interactions in pre-industrial Europe from the 13th to the 18th Centuries. Firenze University Press, Florence, pp 257–268
Pétursdóttir S (1998) God’s Gift. Salmon Fishing in Iceland in the Middle Ages. In: P Holm, DJ Starkey (eds) North Atlantic fisheries: markets and modernization. Studia Atlantica, 2. Fisheri- og Søfartsmuseets Forlag, Ejsberg, pp 59–76
Piekosiński F, J Szujski (eds) (1877–1878) Najstarsze księgi i rachunki miasta Krakowa od r. 1300 do 1400, 2 separately paginated parts in 1. Monumenta medii aevi historica res gestas Poloniae ilustrantia, vol 4. Polska Akademija Umiejętności, Krakow, Komisja Historyczna, Kraków
Public Record Office [PRO], Plea Rolls King’s Bench: England, KB 27/384 30E3, m13d, and KB 227/509 11R2, m1d
Regesta regum Scottorum [RrS] 1153–1424 [cited by vol. and #] Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh, 1960–2012: vol I Barrow GWS (ed) The Acts of Malcolm IV, 1153–1165; vol II Barrow GWS (ed) with the collaboration of Scott WW, The Acts of William I, 1165–1214; vol IV, pt. 1: Neville CJ, Simpson GG (eds) The Acts of Alexander III, King of Scots 1249–1286; vol V Duncan AAM (ed) The Acts of Robert I, King of Scots 1306–1329; vol VI Webster B (ed) The Acts of David II King of Scots 1329–1371 [other volumes have yet to appear]
Reichstein H (1981) Untersuchungen an Tierknochen von der Isenburg bei Hattingen/Ruhr: ein Beitrag zur Nahrungswirtschaft auf hochmittelalterlichen Burgen. H. Eversberg für den Verein zur Erhaltung der Isenburg u. den Heimat- und Geschichtsverein Hattingen, Hattingen
Renwick R (ed) (1887) Extracts from the Records of the Royal Burgh of Stirling, A.D. 1519-1666 with appendix A.D. 1295-1666. Glasgow: for the Glasgow Stirlingshire and Sons of the Rock Society
Rogers JET (1866) A history of agriculture and prices in England, vol I. Clarendon Press, Oxford
Rogers C (ed) (1879–1880) Rental book of the Cistercian abbey of Cupar-Angus, with the breviary of the register. vol 2. Printed for the Grampian Club, London
Ryder ML (1969) Remains of fish and other aquatic animals. In: Brothwell D, Higgs E (eds) Science in archaeology: a survey of progress and research, 2nd edn. Praeger, London, pp 376–394
Santucci M (1984) Nourritures et symboles dans le Banquet du Faisan et dans Jehan de Saintré. In: Menjot D (ed) Manger et boire au Moyen Age, I. Colloque de Nice, 1982. Publications de la Faculté des lettres et sciences humaines de Nice, no. 27-28, 1ére serie. Belles lettres, Paris, pp. 429–440
Schwab I (ed) (1983) Das Prümer Urbar, Rheinische Urbare, vol. 5, Publikationen der Gesellschaft für Rheinische Geschichtskunde, vol 20. Droste Verlag, Düsseldorf
Serrano Larráyoz F (2002) La mesa del rey. Cocina y régimen alimentario en la corte de Carlos III el noble de Navarra (1411–1425). Gobierno de Navarra, Pamplona
Shaw J (1984) Water power in Scotland, 1550–1870. Donald, Edinburgh
Smout TC (ed) (1993) Scotland since prehistory: natural change and human impact. Scottish Cultural Press, Aberdeen
Smout TC, Stewart M (2012) The Firth of Forth: an environmental history. Birlinn, Edinburgh
Stuart J et al. (eds) (1878–1890) Rotuli scaccarii regum Scotorum. The Exchequer Rolls of Scotland. vol 23. H.M. General Register House, Edinburgh
Stevenson D (1971) The English and the public records of Scotland. Stair Soc Misc [Edinburgh] 1:156–170
Taylor A (2009) Leges Scocie and the law codes of David I, William the Lion and Alexander II. Scott Hist Rev 87(226):207–288
The Records of the Parliaments of Scotland [RPS] to 1707, Brown KM et al (ed) (St. Andrews: 2007–2011)—on line edition http://www.rps.ac.uk/ (consulted 2011 September)
Von Brandt A (1984) Fish catching methods of the world, 3rd edn. Fishing News Books Ltd, Farnham
von den Driesch A (1982) Fischreste aus der slawisch-deutschen Fürstenburg auf dem Weinberg in Hitzacker (Elbe). Neue Ausgrabungen und Forschungen in Niedersachsen 15:395–423
Webster B (1975) Scotland from the eleventh century to 1603. The sources of history: studies in the uses of historical evidence. Hodder & Stoughton, London
Went AEJ (1984) Ancient Irish fishing weirs for salmon. In: Gunda B (ed) The fishing culture of the world: studies in ethnology, cultural ecology and folklore, vol I. Budapest, Akadémiai Kiadó, pp 455–468
Williams DH (1969) The Welsh Cistercians: aspects of their economic history. Griffin Press, Pontypool
Winchester AJL (1987) Landscape and society in medieval Cumbria. John Donald, Edinburgh
Wright Laura (1996) Sources of London English: medieval thames vocabulary. Clarendon Press, Oxford
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
This article is part of the special issue ‘Historical ecology of riverine fish in Europe’.
Richard C. Hoffmann, an environmental historian and medievalist, is Professor Emeritus and Senior Scholar in the Department of History, York University, Toronto, Canada. The research for this paper was carried out during tenure in Autumn, 2011, as Leverhulme Trust Visiting Research Professor (Reference Number: VP2-2010-032) in the Research Centre for Environmental History and Policy at the University of Stirling. The purpose of this appointment was to test the feasibility of Scottish inland fisheries for long-term historical and palaeoenvironmental investigation by the Research Centre. This paper presents results from pilot study of published and archival written sources, published archaeozoology, and observations on the ground of sites bearing upon Atlantic salmon in Scotland up to the (politically and archivally significant) Scottish Reformation of the sixteenth century. Thanks are due to the Leverhulme Trust for providing resources and to Alasdair Ross, now Senior Lecturer in Medieval Scottish History at Stirling, for being an unfailing mentor, minder, and manager throughout the sojourn in Scotland.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Hoffmann, R.C. Salmo salar in late medieval Scotland: competition and conservation for a riverine resource. Aquat Sci 77, 355–366 (2015). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00027-015-0397-4
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00027-015-0397-4