Abstract
Children with Specific Language Impairment (SLI) have been observed to have production and perception difficulties with sentences containing long-distance dependencies, but it is unclear whether this is due to impairment in grammatical knowledge or in processing mechanisms. The current study addressed this issue by examining automatic on-line gap-filling in relative clauses, as well as off-line comprehension of the same stimulus sentences. As predicted by both knowledge impairment and processing impairment models, SLI children showed lack of immediate gap-filling after the relative clause verb, in comparison to a control group of typically developing children. However, on the off-line measure of comprehension of the same stimuli sentences, SLI children and TD children did not differ qualitatively. This finding is incompatible with knowledge impairment. We interpret the results to show that SLI children have impaired processing mechanisms (such as temporally delayed gap-filling) but are not impaired in their grammatical knowledge.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Brown L., Sherbenou R. J., Johnsen S. K. (1997) Test of nonverbal intelligence (3rd ed.). Pro-Ed, Austin, TX
Clifton C. Jr., Frazier L. (1986) The use of syntactic information in filling gaps. Journal of Psycholinguistic Research 15(3): 209–224
Clifton C. Jr., Frazier L. (1989) Comprehending sentences with long-distance dependencies. In: Carlson G., Tanenhaus M. K. (eds) Linguistic structure in language processing. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, pp 273–317
Daneman M., Carpenter P. (1980) Individual differences in working memory and reading. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior 19: 450–466
Deevy P., Leonard L. B. (2004) The comprehension of wh-questions in children with specific language impairment. Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research 47(4): 802–815
Dunn L. M., Dunn D. M. (2007) Peabody picture vocabulary test (4th ed.). Pearson Inc, Bloomington, MN
Frazier L., Flores d’Arcais G. B. (1989) Filler driven parsing: a study of gap filling in dutch. Journal of Memory and Language 28(3): 331
Friedmann N., Novogrodsky R. (2004) The acquisition of relative clause comprehension in Hebrew: a study of SLI and normal development. Journal of Child Language 31: 661–681
Gaulin C. A., Campbell T. F. (1994) Procedure for assessing verbal working memory in normal school-age children: some preliminary data. Perceptual and Motor Skills 79(1Pt1): 55–64
Håkansson G., Hansson K. (2000) Comprehension and production of relative clauses: a comparison between Swedish impaired and unimpaired children. Journal of Child Language 27(02): 313–333
Leonard L. B. (1998) Children with specific language impairment. MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts
Love T. (2007) The processing of non-canonically ordered constituents in long distance dependencies by pre-school children: a real-time investigation. Journal of Psycholinguistic Research 36(3): 191–206
Love T., Swinney D. (1996) Coreference processing and levels of analysis in object-relative constructions: demonstration of antecedent reactivation with the cross-modal priming paradigm. Journal of Psycholinguistic Research 25(1): 5–24
Love, T., & Swinney, D. (1997). Real time processing of object relative constructions by pre-school children [Poster]. In 10th Annual CUNY conference on human language processing. Santa Monica, CA.
Marinis T., Van der Lely H. (2007) On-line processing of wh-questions in children with G-SLI and typically developing children. International Journal of Language & Communication Disorders 42(5): 557–582
McKee C., Nicol J., McDaniel D. (1993) Children’s application of binding during sentence processing. Language and Cognitive Processes 8: 265–290
Montgomery J. W. (2000) Verbal working memory and sentence comprehension in children with specific language impairment. Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research 43(2): 293–308
Montgomery J. W. (2003) Working memory and comprehension in children with specific language impairment: what we know so far. Journal of Communication Disorders 36(3): 221–231
Nicol J., Fodor J., Swinney D. (1994a) Using cross-modal lexical decision tasks to investigate sentence processing. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory & Cognition 20(5): 1–10
Nicol J., Fodor J. D., Swinney D. (1994b) Using cross-modal lexical decision tasks to investigate sentence processing. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory and Cognition 20(5): 1229–1238
Nicol J., Swinney D. (1989) The role of structure in coreference assignment during sentence comprehension. Journal of Psycholinguistic Research 18(1): 5–19
Novogrodsky R., Friedmann N. (2006) The production of relative clauses in syntactic SLI: a window to the nature of the impairment. Advances in Speech-Language Pathology 8: 364–375
Roberts L., Marinis T., Felser C., Clahsen H. (2007) Antecedent priming at trace positions in children’s sentence processing. Journal of Psycholinguistic Research 36(2): 175–188
Rossion B., Pourtois G. (2001) Revisiting Snodgrass and Vanderwart’s object database: color and texture improve object recognition. Journal of Vision 1(3): 413a
Schuele C. M., Nicholls L. (2000) Relative clauses: evidence of continued linguistic vulnerability in children with specific language impairment. Clinical Linguistics & Phonetics 14(8): 563–585
Semel E., Wiig E. H., Secord W. A. (2004) Clinical evaluation of language fundamentals (4th ed.). The Psychological Corporation/A Harcourt Assessment Company, Toronto, Canada
Stavrakaki S. (2001) Comprehension of reversible relative clauses in specifically language impaired and normally developing greek children. Brain and Language 77(3): 419–431
Stowe L. A. (1986) Parsing WH-constructions: evidence for on-line gap location. Language and Cognitive Processes 1(3): 227–245
Swinney D., Ford M., Bresnan J. (1989) On the temporal course of gap-filling and antecedent assignment during sentence comprehension. In: Grosz B., Kaplan R., Macken M., Sag I. (eds) Language structure and processing. CSLI, Stanford, CA
Van der Lely, H. (2004). Evidence for and implications of a domain-specific grammatical deficit. In L. Jenkins (Ed.), The genetics of language.
Van der Lely H. (2005) Domain-specific cognitive systems: insight from Grammatical specific language impairment. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 9(2): 53–59
Van der Lely H., Battell J. (2003) Wh-movement in children with grammatical SLI: a test of the RDDR hypothesis. Language 79(1): 153–181
van der Lely H., Rosen S., McClelland A. (1998) Evidence for a grammar-specific deficit in children. Current Biology 8(23): 1253–1258
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
This research was supported by NIH grant 5R03DC006175 from the National Institute on Deafness and Other Communicative Disorders (NIDCD) to the first author, and by NIH grant 5R01DC003885-03 from NIDCD to Richard G. Schwartz.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Hestvik, A., Schwartz, R.G. & Tornyova, L. Relative Clause Gap-Filling in Children with Specific Language Impairment. J Psycholinguist Res 39, 443–456 (2010). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10936-010-9151-1
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10936-010-9151-1