Abstract
Experimental observations of delamination growth in two stiffened-skin geometries are compared to predictions made using a three-dimensional crack tip element based approach. Each geometry consists of a six-ply graphite/epoxy skin co-cured to a six-ply, hat-shaped stiffener containing a preimplanted teflon delamination between the skin and stiffener at the stiffener termination point. One stiffened-skin geometry was loaded in three-point bending and the other had in-plane tension loads applied to the skin. To predict delamination growth, a three-dimensional crack tip element analysis was first performed on each geometry in order to determine the total energy release rate, G, as well as its mode I, II and III components, G I, G II and G III, respectively. These results were used to define a mode mix at each point along the delamination front, G s/G, where G s=G II + G III. To obtain the delamination toughness, G c, it was assumed that G c exhibits the same dependence on G s/G as on GII/G, where the results for G c versus G II/G were taken from an earlier experimental study. Next, a comparison of the energy release rate to the toughness at each position along the delamination front was performed, and these results were scaled appropriately in order to predict the sequence of loads and corresponding locations at which the delamination will advance. The predictions were then compared to experimental results that included c-scan images of the test specimens taken at each increment of observed growth, and very good quantitative and qualitative correlations were obtained for both geometries. These results indicate the practicality of, and considerable computational savings that may be achieved by, employing crack tip element analyses for delamination growth predictions in realistic structural geometries.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
B.D. Davidson (1990) ArticleTitleAn analytical investigation of delamination front curvature in double cantilever beam specimens Journal of Composite Materials 24 IssueID11 1124–1137
Davidson, B.D. (1994) Prediction of delamination growth in laminated structures, In: Failure Mechanics in Advanced Polymeric Composites, (edited by Kardomateas, G.A. and Rajapakse, Y.D.S.) AMD-Vol. 196, American Society of Mechanical Engineers, pp. 43–65.
Davidson, B.D., Altonen, C.S. and Polaha, J.J. (1996a) Effect of stacking sequence on delamination toughness and delamination growth behavior in composite end-notched flexure specimens. In: Composite Materials: Testing and Design (Twelfth Volume), ASTM STP 1274, (edited by Saff, C.R. and Deo, R.B.) American Society for Testing and Materials, pp. 393–413.
Davidson, B.D., Bialaszewski, R.D. and Sainath, S.S. (2004) A non-classical, energy release rate-based approach for predicting delamination growth in graphite reinforced laminated polymeric composites, To Appear in Composites Science and Technology.
Davidson, B.D., Fariello, P.L., Hudson, R.C. and Sundararaman, V. (1997) Accuracy assessment of the singular field-based mode mix decomposition procedure for the prediction of delamination. In: Composite Materials: Testing and Design (Thirteenth Volume). ASTM STP 1242, (edited by Hooper, S.J.) American Society for Testing and Materials, pp. 109–128.
B.D. Davidson S.J. Gharibian L. Yu (2000a) ArticleTitleEvaluation of energy release rate-based approaches for predicting delamination growth in laminated composites International Journal of Fracture 105 IssueID4 343–365
B.D. Davidson H. Hu R.A. Schapery (1995a) ArticleTitleAn analytical crack tip element for layered elastic structures Journal of Applied Mechanics 62 294–305 Occurrence Handle0850.73333
B.D. Davidson H. Hu H. Yan (1996b) ArticleTitleAn efficient procedure for determining mixed-mode energy release rates in practical problems of delamination Finite Elements in Analysis and Design 23 193–210 Occurrence Handle0875.73183
B.D. Davidson R. Krüger M. König (1995b) ArticleTitleThree-dimensional analysis of center delaminated unidirectional and multidirectional single leg bending specimens Composites Science and Technology 54 IssueID4 385–394
Davidson, B.D. and Yu, L. (2004) Energy release rate prediction in stiffened-skin structure using a three-dimensional crack tip element analysis, To Appear in Journal of Composite Materials.
B.D. Davidson L. Yu H. Hu (2000b) ArticleTitleDetermination of energy release rate and mode mix in three-dimensional layered structures using plate theory International Journal of Fracture 105 IssueID1 81–104
König, M., Krüger, R. and Rinderknecht, S. (2000) Finite element analysis of delamination growth in a multidirectional composite ENF specimen. In: Composite Structures: Theory and Practice. ASTM STP 1383, (edited by Grant, P. and Rousseau, C.Q.) American Society for Testing and Materials, pp. 345–365.
R. Krueger M.K. Civitkovich T.K. O’Brien (2000a) ArticleTitleTesting and analysis of composite skin/stringer debonding under multi-axial loading Journal of Composite Materials 34 IssueID15 1263–1300
Krueger, R., Minguet, P.J. and O’Brien, T.K. (2000b) A method for calculating strain energy release rates in preliminary design of composite skin/stringer debonding under multi-axial loading. In: Composite Structures: Theory and Practice. ASTM STP 1383, (edited by Grant, P. and Rousseau, C.Q.). American Society for Testing and Materials, pp. 105–128.
Li, J. (2000) Three-dimensional effect in the prediction of flange delamination in composite skin-stringer pull-off specimens. In: Proceedings of the 15th Annual American Society for Composites Technical Conference. (edited by Ochoa, O.O., O’Brien, T.K., Lagoudas, D. and Sue, H.J.) Technomic, 983–990.
Li, J, O’Brien, T.K. and Rousseau, C.Q. (1997) Test and analysis of composite hat stringer pull-off test specimens. Journal of the American Helicopter Society. 350–357.
Minguet, P.J. and O’Brien, T.K. (1995) Analysis of composite skin/stringer bond failure using a strain energy release rate approach. In: Proceedings of the 10th International Conference on Composite Materials, Vol. I: Fatigue and Fracture, (edited by Poursartip, A. and Street, K.) 253–260.
I. Vintilescu J. Spelt (1998) ArticleTitleMixed mode I, II, and III fracture characterization of adhesive joints Journal of Composites Technology and Research 20 IssueID2 129–139 Occurrence Handle10.1520/CTR10053J
L. Yu B.D. Davidson (2001) ArticleTitleA three-dimensional crack tip element for energy release rate determination in layered elastic structures Journal of Composite Materials 35 IssueID6 457–488
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Davidson, B.D., Yu, L., Lundberg, S.D. et al. Accuracy assessment of a three-dimensional, crack tip element based approach for predicting delamination growth in stiffened-skin geometries. Int J Fract 132, 1–32 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10704-004-8155-y
Received:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10704-004-8155-y