Abstract
Episodic memory is the ability to remember personally experienced past events (Tulving in Organization of memory. Academic Press, San Diego, pp. 381–403, 1972). In non-human animals, the behavioural criterion for episodic-like memory is remembering “what” occurred in conjunction with “when” and “where” (Clayton and Dickinson in Nature 395:272–274, 1998). We conducted tests for “what, where, and when” memory in a food-storing bird, the black-capped chickadee (Poecile atricapillus). In Experiment 1, chickadees found sunflower seeds and mealworms in concealed sites in their home cage. Birds later re-visited these sites after either a short (3 h) or long (123 h) retention interval. Chickadees normally prefer mealworms, but at the long retention interval mealworms were degraded in taste and appearance. Chickadees showed some memory for what kind of food they had encountered and where, but no memory for when food had previously been found. Experiment 2 followed a similar procedure, except that chickadees searched for hidden sunflower seeds and mealworms in trees in an indoor aviary. These more natural conditions increased both the spatial scale of the task and the effort required to find food. In this experiment, birds showed evidence for all three components of what–where–when memory. Unlike some previous studies of episodic-like memory, birds’ behaviour cannot be accounted for by differential memory strength for more recent events. The results show that memory for what, where, and when occurs in food-storing birds outside the corvid family, does not require food caching or retrieval, and that remembering “when” can depend on the nature of the task.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Babb S, Crystal J (2005) Discrimination of what, when, and where: implications for episodic-like memory in rats. Learn Motiv 36:177–189
Babb SJ, Crystal JD (2007) Episodic-like memory in the rat. Curr Biol 16:1317–1321
Bird L, Roberts W, Abroms B, Kit K, Crupi C (2003) Spatial memory for food hidden by rats (Rattus norvegicus) on the radial maze: studies of memory for where, what, and when. J Comp Psychol 117:176–187
Boisvert MJ, Sherry DF (2006) Interval timing by an invertebrate, the bumble bee Bombus impatiens. Curr Biol 16:1636–1640
Boisvert MJ, Veal AJ, Sherry DF (2007) Floral reward production is timed by an insect pollinator. Proc R Soc Lond B Biol Sci 274:1831–1837
Brodin A (2005) Hippocampal volume does not correlate with food-hoarding rates in the black-capped chickadee (Poecile atricapillus) and willow tit (Parus montanus). Auk 12:819–828
Brodin A, Ekman J (1994) Benefits of hoarding food. Nature 372:510
Busby J, Suddendorf T (2005) Recalling yesterday and predicting tomorrow. Cogn Dev 20:362–372
Church RM, Broadbent HA (1990) Alternative representations of time, number, and rate. Cognition 37:55–81
Clayton NS, Dickinson A (1998) What, where, and when: episodic-like memory during cache recovery by scrub jays. Nature 395:272–274
Clayton NS, Dickinson A (1999) Scrub jays (Aphelocoma coerulescens) remember the relative time of caching as well the location and content of their caches. J Comp Psychol 113:403–416
Clayton NS, Yu KS, Dickinson A (2001) Scrub jays (Aphelocoma coerulescens) form integrated memories of the multiple features of caching episodes. J Exp Psychol Anim Behav Process 27:17–29
Correia SPC, Dickinson A, Clayton NS (2007) Western scrub jays anticipate future needs independently of their current motivational state. Curr Biol 17:856–861
Cowie RJ, Krebs JR, Sherry DF (1981) Food storing by marsh tits. Anim Behav 29:1252–1259
Crystal JD, Shettleworth SJ (1994) Spatial list learning in black-capped chickadees. Anim Learn Behav 22:77–83
Dally JM, Emery NJ, Clayton NS (2005) Cache protection strategies by western scrub jays, Aphelocoma californica: implications for social cognition. Anim Behav 70:1251–1263
Dally JM, Emery NJ, Clayton NS (2006) Food-caching western scrub jays keep track of who was watching when. Science 312:1662–1665
de Kort SR, Clayton NS (2006) An evolutionary perspective on caching by corvids. Proc R Soc Lond B Biol Sci 273:417–423
de Kort SR, Dickinson A, Clayton NS (2005) Retrospective cognition by food-caching western scrub-jays. Learn Motiv 36:159–176
Dere E, Huston JP, De Sousa Silva MA (2005a) Episodic-like memory in mice: simultaneous assessment of object, place and temporal order memory. Brain Res Protoc 16:10–19
Dere E, Huston JP, De Sousa Silva MA (2005b) Integrated memory for objects, places, and temporal order: evidence for episodic-like memory in mice. Neurobiol Learn Mem 84:214–221
Ferkin MH, Combs A, del Barco-Trillo J, Pierce AA, Franklin S (2008) Meadow voles, Microtus pennsylvanicus, have the capacity to recall the “what”, “where”, and “when” of a single past event. Anim Cogn 11:147–159
Friedman WJ (1993) Memory for the time of past events. Psychol Bull 113:3–20
Hampton R, Hampstead B, Murray E (2005) Rhesus monkeys (Macaca mulatta) demonstrate robust memory for what and where, but not when, in an open-field test of memory. Learn Motiv 36:245–259
Henderson J, Hurly TA, Bateson M, Healy SD (2006) Timing in free-living rufous hummingbirds, Selasphorus rufus. Curr Biol 16:512–515
Hitchcock CL, Sherry DF (1990) Long-term memory for cache sites in the black-capped chickadee. Anim Behav 40:701–712
Hoffman ML, Beran MJ, Washburn DA (2009) Memory for “what”, “where”, and “when” information in rhesus monkeys (Macaca mulatta). J Exp Psychol Anim Behav Process 35:143–152
Hoshooley JS, Phillmore LS, Sherry DF, MacDougall-Shackleton SA (2007) Annual cycle of the black-capped chickadee: seasonality of food-storing and the hippocampus. Brain Behav Evol 69:161–168
Kart-Teke E, De Sousa Silva MA, Huston JP, Dere E (2006) Wistar rats show episodic-like memory for unique experiences. Neurobiol Learn Mem 85:173–182
Kouwenberg A, Walsh CJ, Morgan BE, Martin GM (2009) Episodic-like memory in crossbred Yucatan minipigs (Sus scrofa). Appl Anim Behav Sci 16:5–172
MacDougall-Shackleton SA, Sherry DF, Clark AP, Pinkus R, Hernandez AM (2003) Photoperiodic regulation of food storing and hippocampus volume in black-capped chickadees, Poecile atricapillus. Anim Behav 65:805–812
Naqshbandi M, Feeney MC, McKenzie TLB, Roberts WA (2007) Testing for episodic-like memory in rats in the absence of time of day cues: replication of Babb and Crystal. Behav Process 74:217–225
Roberts WA (2002) Are animals stuck in time? Psychol Bull 128:473–489
Roberts WA (2006) Animal memory: episodic-like memory in rats. Curr Biol 16:R601–R603
Roberts WA, Feeney MC (2009) Comparative mental time travel. Trends Cogn Sci. doi:10.1016/j.tics.2009.03.003
Roberts WA, Feeney MC, Macpherson K, Petter M, McMillan N, Musolino E (2008) Episodic-like memory in rats: is it based on when or how long ago? Science 320:113–115
Schwartz BL, Hoffman ML, Evans S (2005) Episodic-like memory in a gorilla: a review and new findings. Learn Motiv 36:226–244
Sherry DF (1984) Food storage by black-capped chickadees: memory for the location and contents of caches. Anim Behav 32:451–464
Sherry DF, Hoshooley JS (2007) Neurobiology of spatial behavior. In: Otter K (ed) Ecology and behavior of chickadees and tits: an integrated approach. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 9–23
Skov-Rackette SI, Miller NY, Shettleworth SJ (2006) What–where–when memory in pigeons. J Exp Psychol Anim Behav Process 32:345–358
Smith SM (1993) Black-capped chickadee (Poecile atricapillus). In: Poole A (ed) The birds of North America online. Cornell Lab of Ornithology, Ithaca. http://bna.birds.cornell.edu/bna/species/039
Suddendorf T, Corballis MC (1997) Mental time travel and the evolution of the human mind. Genet Soc Gen Psych 123:133–167
Suddendorf T, Corballis MC (2007) The evolution of foresight: what is mental time travel and is it unique to humans? Behav Brain Sci 30:299–313
Tulving E (1972) Episodic and semantic memory. In: Tulving E, Donaldson W (eds) Organization of memory. Academic, San Diego, pp 381–403
Tulving E (1983) Elements of episodic memory. Clarendon Press, Oxford
Tulving E (1985) How many memory systems are there? Am Psychol 40:385–398
Tulving E (2002) Episodic memory: from mind to brain. Annu Rev Psychol 53:1–25
Vander Wall SB, Balda RP (1981) Ecology and evolution of food-storage behavior in conifer-seed-caching corvids. Z Tierpsychol 56:217–242
Zentall TR, Clement TS, Bhatt RS, Allen J (2001) Episodic-like memory in pigeons. Psychon Bull Rev 8:685–690
Zentall TR, Singer RA, Stagner JP (2008) Episodic-like memory: pigeons can report location pecked when unexpectedly asked. Behav Process 79:93–98
Zinkivskay A, Nazir F, Smulders TV (2009) What–where–when memory in magpies (Pica pica). Anim Cogn 12:119–125
Acknowledgements
Support for this research was provided by Discovery Grants from the Canadian Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council to William A. Roberts and David F. Sherry. We would like to thank Mark Petter and Nathalie Tordjman-Goodfellow for their help in carrying out this research.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Feeney, M.C., Roberts, W.A. & Sherry, D.F. Memory for what, where, and when in the black-capped chickadee (Poecile atricapillus). Anim Cogn 12, 767–777 (2009). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10071-009-0236-x
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10071-009-0236-x