On the relationship between nutrient use efficiency and fertility in forest ecosystems

Abstract

The concept of nutrient use efficiency is central in understanding ecosystem functioning because it is the step in which plants can influence the return of the nutrients to the soil pool and the quality of the litter. There are several ways to define nutrient use efficiency, but a common way within ecosystem ecology is as the ratio of litterfall production per unit nutrient to the litterfall nutrient content. However, this ratio is not a valid measurement to examine nutrient use efficiency in relationship to ecosystem fertility because there is a strong autocorrelation between litterfall dry mass per unit of nutrient and the amount of nutrients. More appropriate statistical analysis of the relationship between the fertility of ecosystems and the amount of nutrients in the litterfall are inconclusive, but indicate that, at least in some cases, there is (1) no pattern, (2) higher nutrient use efficiency at intermediate-fertility sites or (3) higher efficiency at higher-fertility sites. There is, however, no indication that nutrient use efficiency is greater in nutrient-poor ecosystems. This conclusion has important consequences for ecosystem nutrient cycling. Given the lack of a clear, consistent relationship between site fertility and litterfall nutrients, there is little likelihood that such a feedback mechanism plays an important role in ecosystem nutrient cycling.