Abstract
The non-profit sector in the United States relies on fee-paying individuals for a high proportion of its revenue. Given this fact, non-profits and forprofits coexist in the same industry when each type of firm can find a stable market niche that rewards its own special strengths: ideological commitment in the non-profit sector; access to capital and the profit motive in the for-profit. Coexistence is also possible when the non-profit form is superior but there is a shortage of non-profit entrepreneurs. The paper next considers the entry of non-profits into sectors dominated by for-profits. Here one must distinguish between purely commercial activities and those designed to further the charity's basic mission. In the former, non-profits should behave no differently than their for-profit competitors unless subsidies designed for mission-related activities are diverted to these activities. In the latter, the non-profits may have an advantage which reflects not ‘unfair competition’ but a judgment that their activities are worthy of subsidy. In evaluating competition between non-profits and for-profits, one must separate the issue of the appropriateness of an organisation's tax-exempt status from the impact of its actions on for-profit firms.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Clark, Robert (1980) Does the non-profit form fit the hospital industry?,Harvard Law Review, 93, May, 1416–89.
Clarkson, Kenneth (1972) Some implications of property rights in hospital management,Journal of Law and Economics, 15, 363–84.
Dunlop, Burton David (1979)The Growth of Nursing Home Care, Lexington Books, Lexington, Mass.
Fama, Eugene and Jensen, Michael (1983) Separation of ownership and control,Journal of Law and Economics, 26, 301–26.
Foster, Richard (1987) Hospitals and the choice of organizational form,Financial Accountability and Management, 3, Winter, 343–65.
Frech, H.E. (1976) The property rights theory of the firm: empirical results from a natural experiment,Journal of Political Economy, 84, 143–152.
Frech, H.E. (1980) Health insurance: private, mutual or government, in Clarkson and Martin (eds)The Economics of Non-proprietary Organizations, JAI Press, Greenwich, CT.
Gapinski, James H. (1980) The production of culture,Review of Economics and Statistics, 62, 578–86.
Gapinski, James H. (1984) The economics of performing Shakespeare,American Economic Review, 74, 458–66.
Gapinski, James H. (1986) The lively arts as substitutes for the lively arts,American Economic Review: Papers and Proceedings, 76, 20–25.
Gray, Bradford H. (ed.) (1986)For-Profit Enterprise in Health Care, Institute of Medicine, Committee on the Implications of For-Profit Enterprise in Health Care, National Academy Press, Washington DC.
Hansmann, Henry (1981a) Non-profit enterprise in the performing arts,Bell Journal of Economics, 12, 341–61.
Hansmann, Henry (1981b) The rationale for exempting non-profit organizations from the corporate income tax,Yale Law Journal, 91, 54–100. Reprinted in Rose-Ackerman (ed.) (1986)The Economics of Non-profit Institutions: Studies in Structure and Policy, Oxford University Press, New York.
Hawes, Catherine and Phillips, Charles D. (1986) The changing structure of the nursing home industry, and the impact of ownership on quality, cost, and access, in B. Gray (ed.)op. cit.
Hodgkinson, Virginia Ann and Weitzman, Murray (1986)Dimensions of the Independent Sector: A Statistical Profile, 2nd edition, Independent Sector, Washington DC.
James, Estelle (1983) How non-profits grow: a model,Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, 2, 350–65. Reprinted in Rose-Ackerman (ed.) (1986)The Economics of Non-profit Institutions: Studies in Structure and Policy, Oxford University Press, New York.
Keyserling, M.D. (1971)Windows on Day Care: A Report on the Findings of Members of the National Council of Jewish Women on Day Care Needs and Services in their Communities, National Council of Jewish Women, New York.
Legorreta, Judith M. and Young, Dennis (1986) Why organizations turn non-profit: lessons from case studies, in S. Rose-Ackerman (ed.)The Economics of Non-profit Institutions: Studies in Structure and Policy, Oxford University Press, New York.
National Center for Health Statistics (1988)Advanced Data from Vital and Health Statistics of the National Center for Health Statistics, 147, 22 January.
Netzer, Dick (1986) Dance in New York: market and subsidy changes,American Economic Review: Papers and Proceedings, 76, 15–19.
Pattison, R.V. and Katz, H.M. (1983) Investor-owned and not-for-profit hospitals: a comparison based on California data,New England Journal of Medicine, 309, p. 347.
Pauly, Mark V. (1987) Non-profit firms in medical markets,American Economic Review: Papers and Proceedings, 77, 257–62.
Rose-Ackerman, Susan (1981) Do government grants to charity reduce private donations?, in M. White (ed.)Non-profit Firms in a Three Sector Economy, Urban Institute, Washington DC. Reprinted in S. Rose-Ackerman (ed.)The Economics of Non-profit Institutions: Studies in Structure and Policy, Oxford University Press, New York.
Rose-Ackerman, Susan (1982) Unfair competition and corporate income taxation,Stanford Law Review, 34, 1017–39. Reprinted in S. Rose-Ackerman (ed.)The Economics of Non-profit Institutions: Studies in Structure and Policy, Oxford University Press, New York.
Rose-Ackerman, Susan (1983) Unintended consequences: regulating the quality of subsidized day care,Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, 3, 14–30.
Rose-Ackerman, Susan (ed.) (1986)The Economics of Non-profit Institutions: Studies in Structure and Policy, Oxford University Press, New York.
Rose-Ackerman, Susan (1987) Statement on the unrelated business income tax,Hearings on UBIT, Subcommittee on Oversight, Committee on Ways and Means, US House of Representatives, 30 June.
Rose-Ackerman, Susan (1988) The market for loving-kindness: day care centers and the demand for child care, in C. Milofsky (ed.)Community Organizations: Studies in Resource Mobilization and Exchange, Oxford University Press, New York.
Salamon, Lester (1982) Non-profit organizations, in J.L. Palmer and I.V. Sawhill (eds)The Reagan Record, Ballinger, Cambridge, Mass.
Schlesinger, Mark (1985) The rise of proprietary health care,Business Health, 2, p.7.
Schlesinger, Mark, Blumenthal, David and Schlesinger, Eric (1986) Profits under pressure: the economic performance of investor-owned and non-profit health maintenance organizations,Medical Care, 24, 615–27.
Steinberg, Richard (1987) Non-profit organizations and the market, in W. Powell (ed.)The Non-profit Sector: A Research Handbook, Yale University Press, New Haven.
US Congress, House Committee on Ways and Means, Subcommittee on Oversight (1987) 100th Congress, 1st Session, Hearing on the Unrelated Business Income Tax, 30 June, Part 3, Serial 100–28, Government Publishing Office, Washington DC.
Weisbrod, Burton (1988)The Non-profit Economy, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Mass.
Young, Dennis (1983)If Not For Profit, For What?, Lexington Books, Lexington, Mass.
Young, Dennis (1985)Casebook of Management for Non-Profit Organizations: Entrepreneurship and Organizational Change in the Human Services, Haworth Press, New York.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Additional information
Prepared for the Research Conference on the Commercial Activities of Non-profits, New York University, November, 1988. I wish to thank Anne Buckholtz for helpful research assistance, and Woody Powell and Brad Gray for useful comments.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Rose-Ackerman, S. Competition between non-profits and for-profits: entry and growth. Voluntas 1, 13–25 (1990). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01398489
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01398489