Summary
In this review the efficacy of haemoperfusion in the treatment of paraquat poisoning is addressed. 42 reports containing sufficient information of paraquat-poisoned patients were evaluated. These reports, from 35 patients reported in the literature and 7 new cases, were chosen for the following reasons: the timed plasma paraquat concentrations were known, patient outcome was known, and details of haemoperfusion were available. In some cases, haemodialysis was also performed. The plasma paraquat concentrations and the specific times post-ingestion were plotted on a contour graph that predicts the probability of survival. Comparison of the predicted probability of survival versus the actual outcome showed that haemoperfusion, single or repeated, did not affect patient survival. None of the patients whose initial plasma concentrations were greater than 3 mg/L paraquat survived, regardless of the time after ingestion that the concentrations were measured, and despite haemoperfusion. Therefore, such patients might not be considered for haemoperfusion because of their uniformly bad prognosis, despite the procedure being used, and because of the morbidity, discomfort and costs associated with it. Clearly, the need for better techniques to remove paraquat and to prevent the consequences of the metabolic effects of the compound are required urgently before the treatment of the paraquat-poisoned patient will be successful.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Bismuth C, Fournier PE. Biological evaluation of hemoperfusion in acute poisoning. In Holmstedt et al. (Eds) Mechanisms of toxicity and hazard evaluation, Elsevier, North-Holland Biomedical Press, 1980
Bismuth C, Gamier R, Dally S, Fournier PE. Prognosis and treatment of paraquat poisoning: a review of 28 cases. Journal of Toxicology — Clinical Toxicology 19: 461–474, 1982
Bismuth D, Scherrmann JM, Garnier R, Baud FJ, Pontal PG. Elimination of paraquat. Human Toxicology 6: 63–68, 1987
Bismuth C, Scherrmann JM, Gamier R, Baud FJ, Pontal PG. Elimination of paraquat. In Chambers et al. (Eds) New concepts and developments in toxicology, pp. 347–356, Elsevier Science Publishers B.V., Holland, 1986
Dasta JF. Paraquat poisoning: a review. American Journal of Hospital Pharmacy 35: 1368–1372, 1978
Davies DS, Hawksworth GM, Bennett PN. Paraquat poisoning. Proceedings of the European Society of Toxicology 18: 21–26, 1977
De Broe ME, Bismuth C, De Groot G, Heath A, Okonek S, et al. Haemoperfusion: a useful therapy for a severely poisoned patient? Human Toxicology 5: 11–14, 1986
De Groot G. Haemoperfusion in clinical toxicology: a pharmacokinetic evaluation. Thesis, Rijks Institut voor de Volksge Zondheid, Bilthoven, 1982
Fairshter RD, Rosen SM, Smith WR, Glauser FL, McRae DM, et al. Paraquat poisoning: new aspects of therapy. Quarterly Journal of Medicine, New Series XLV 180: 551–565, 1976
Gamier R, Efthymiou M-L, Baud F. Haemoperfusion for paraquat poisoning. Lancet 2: 277, 1983
Hart TB. When is paraquat poisoning life threatening? Lancet 1: 395, 1985
Hart TB, Nevitt A, Whitehead A. A new statistical approach to the prognostic significance of paraquat concentrations. Lancet 2: 1222–1223, 1984
Hawksworth GM, Bennett PN, Davies DS. Kinetics of paraquat elimination in the dog. Toxicology and Applied Pharmacology 57: 139–145, 1981
Hoffman S, Jedeikin R, Korzets Z, Shapiro A-L, Kaplan R, et al. Successful management of severe paraquat poisoning. Chest 84: 107–109, 1983
Lohmann J, Pott G, Zidek W, Bertram HP. Plasma fibronectin in man after a severe paraquat intoxication. Archives of Toxicology (Suppl. 5): 295–297, 1982
Mascie-Taylor BH, Thompson J, Davidson AM. Haemoperfusion ineffective for paraquat removal in life-threatening poisoning. Lancet 1: 1376–1377, 1983
Mofenson HC, Greensher J, Caraccio TR, D’Agostino R. Paraquat intoxication: report of a fatal case. Discussion of pathophysiology and rational treatment. Journal of Toxicology — Clinical Toxicology 19: 821–834, 1982
Okonek S. Pharmacological and toxicological principles in the removal of drugs or pesticides by diuresis, dialysis and hemoperfusion. In Lemberger & Reidenberg (Eds) Proceedings of the second world conference on clinical pharmacology and therapeutics, Washington, D.C., July 31-August 5, pp. 691–709, American Society for Pharmacology and Experimental Therapeutics, 1983
Okonek S, Baldamus CA, Hofmann A, Schuster CJ, Bechstein PB. Two survivors of severe paraquat intoxication by ‘continuous hemoperfusion’. Klinische Wochenschrift 57: 957–959, 1979
Okonek S, Hofmann A, Henningsen B. Efficacy of gut lavage, hemodialysis, and hemoperfusion in the therapy of paraquat or diquat intoxication. Archives of Toxicology 36: 43–51, 1976
Okonek S, Weilemann LS, Majdandzic J, Setyadharma H, Reinecke HJ. Successful treatment of paraquat poisoning: activated charcoal per os and ‘continuous hemoperfusion’. Journal of Toxicology — Clinical Toxicology 19: 807–819, 1982
Pond SM, Johnstone SC, Hampson EC, Bowles MR, Wright DM. Continuous arteriovenous hemofiltration for paraquat poisoning? Veterinary and Human Toxicology 28: 486, 1986
Proudfoot AT, Prescott LF, Jarvie DR. Haemodialysis for paraquat poisoning. Human Toxicology 6: 69–74, 1987
Proudfoot AT, Stewart MS, Levitt T, Widdop B. Paraquat poisoning: signifícance of plasma-paraquat concentrations. Lancet 2: 330–332, 1979
Rose MS, Smith LL, Wyatt I. Evidence for energy-dependent accumulation of paraquat into rat lung. Nature 252: 314–315, 1974
Russell LA, Stone BE, Rooney PA. Paraquat poisoning: toxicologic and pathologic findings in three fatal cases. Clinical Toxicology 18: 915–928, 1981
Saunders NR, Alpert HM, Cooper JD. Sequential bilateral lung transplantation for paraquat poisoning: a case report. Journal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery 89: 734–742, 1985
Siefkin AD. Combined paraquat and acetaminophen toxicology. Journal of Toxicology — Clinical Toxicology 19: 483–491, 1982
Smith LL. Mechanism of paraquat toxicity in lung and its relevance to treatment. Human Toxicology 6: 31–36, 1987
Smith LL. The identification of an accumulated system for diamines and polyamines into the lung and its relevance to paraquat toxicity. Archives of Toxicology (Suppl. 5): 1–14, 1982
Sofrank G, Mathes G, v Clarmann M, Beyer KH. Haemoperfusion through activated charcoal in paraquat intoxication. Acta Pharmacologica et Toxicologica 41 (Suppl.): 91–101, 1977
Sonoda Y, Kuwahira I, Kurata T, Kobayashi R, Konodo T. Paraquat poisoning: a review of four cases. Takai Journal of Experimental and Clinical Medicine 7: 489–496, 1982
Tabei K, Asano Y, Hosoda S. Efficacy of charcoal hemoperfusion in paraquat poisoning. Artificial Organs 6: 37–42, 1982
Vale JA, Crome P, Volans GN, Widdop B, Goulding R. The treatment of paraquat poisoning using oral sorbents and charcoal haemoperfusion. Acta Pharmacologica et Toxicologica 41 (Suppl. 11): 109–117, 1977
Van de Vyver FL, Giuliano RA, Paulus GJ, Verpooten GA, Franke JP. Hemoperfusion-hemodialysis ineffective for paraquat removal in life-threatening poisoning? Clinical Toxicology 23: 117–131, 1985
Van de Vyver FL, Van de Sande J, Verpooten GA, De Broe ME, Van den Heede M. Haemoperfusion ineffective for paraquat removal in life-threatening poisoning. Lancet 2: 173, 1983
Van Dijk A, Maes RAA, Drost RH, Douze JMC, Van Heijst ANP. Paraquat poisoning in man. Archives of Toxicology 34: 129–136, 1975
Vincken W, Huyghens L, Schandevyl W, Verbeelen D, Corne L. Paraquat poisoning and colchicine treatment. Annals of Internal Medicine 95: 391–392, 1981
Widdop B, Medd RK, Braithwaite RA. Charcoal haemoperfusion in the treatment of paraquat poisoning. Proceedings of the European Society of Toxicology 18: 156–159, 1977
Winchester JF, Gelfand MC, Schreiner GE. Haemoperfusion for paraquat poisoning. Lancet 2: 277, 1983
Yasaka T, Okudaira K, Fujito H, Matsumoto J, Ohya I, et al. Further studies of lipid peroxidation in human paraquat poisoning. Archives of Internal Medicine 146: 681–685, 1986
Yoshida K, Asano Y, Nakajima I, Iwama G, Shindou Y. The treatment of 10 cases of paraquat poisoning using charcoal haemoperfusion. Nippon Jinzo Gakkai Shi 22: 1001–1012, 1980
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Hampson, E.C.G.M., Pond, S.M. Failure of Haemoperfusion and Haemodialysis to Prevent Death in Paraquat Poisoning. Dis-Manage-Health-Outcomes 3, 64–71 (1988). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF03259932
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF03259932