Summary
A psychiatrist and a pastoral psychologist considered the problem of guilt as a source of alienation in depressed and suicidal patients by using a four-dimensional approach in a group psychotherapy setting. This involved functioning as cotherapists representing theological and psychiatric orientations and utilizing both didactic and insight-oriented approaches to elicit and explore meaningful material related to guilt feelings. With a number of exceptions, the patients did not appear to make a sharp distinction between the cotherapists' roles. The didactic openings on guilt served to provoke ready discussion of personal conflicts involving guilt feelings, especially in the silent patients who were not easily drawn into spontaneous discussion.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Stein, E. V.,Guilt: Theory and Therapy. Philadelphia, The Westminster Press, 1968.
Block, S., “Multi-Leadership as a Teaching and Therapeutic Tool in Group Psychotherapy,”Comparative Psychiatry, 1961,2, 211–218. Gans, R., “Group Co-Therapists and the Therapeutic Situation: A Critical Evaluation,”Internat. J. Group Psychotherapy, 1962,12, 82–88. Mintz, E., “Special Values of Co-Therapists in Group Psychology,”Internat. J. Group Psychotherapy, 1963,13, 127–132. Solomon, A.; Loeffler, F., and Frank, G., “An Analysis of Co-Therapist Interaction in Group Psychotherapy,”Internat. J. Group Psychotherapy, 1953,3, 171–180.
Adler, J., and Berman, J., “Multiple Leadership in Group Treatment of Delinquent Adolescents,”Internat. J. Group Psychotherapy, 1960,10, 213–226.
Gottlieb, A., and Kramer, M., “Alternate-Therapist Group Meetings: An Approach to the Severely Ambivalent Patient,”Internat. J. Group Psychotherapy, 1965,15, 187–197.
Hulse, W., “Transference Reactions in a Group of Female Patients to Male and Female Co-Leaders,”Internat. J. Group Psychotherapy, 1956,6, 430–435 Singer, M., and Fischer, R., “Group Psychotherapy of Male Homosexuals by a Male and Female Co-Therapy Team,”Internat. J. Group Psychotherapy, 1967,17, 44–52. Sonne, J., and Lincoln, G., “The Importance of a Heterosexual Co-Therapy Relationship in the Construction of a Family Image.” In “Family Structure, Dynamics and Therapy,”Psychiatric Research Reports of the American Psychiatric Association, 1966,20, 196–205.
Solomon, J., and Solomon, G., “Group Psychotherapy with Father and Son as Co-Therapists: Some Dynamic Considerations,”Internat. J. Group Psychotherapy, 1963,13, 133–140.
Klapman, J., “Psychoanalytic or Didactic Group Psychotherapy?”Psychiat. Quart., 1954,28, 279–286.
Cameron, J., and Freeman, T., “Group Psychotherapy in Affective Disorders,”Internat. J. Group Psychotherapy, 1956,6, 235–257.
Wilson, D., “Group Psychotherapy and Manic-Depressive Psychosis,”Am. J. Psychiatry, 1954,110, 911–915.
Indin, B., “The Crisis Club: A Group Experience for Suicidal Patients,”Mental Hygiene, 1966,50, 280–290.
Kaiser, H.,Effective Psychotherapy. New York, The Free Press, 1965.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Motto, J.A., Stein, E.V. A group approach to guilt in depressive and suicidal patients. J Relig Health 12, 378–385 (1973). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01532426
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01532426