Abstract
This article attempts to use the analytical framework of social choice theory for exploring the ethical foundations of population policies. It is argued that non-existence is not a state and therefore that different numbers problems are conceptionally different from same numbers problems that concern much theoretical welfare economics. By means of examples it is argued that we should not expect to find an overall ethical ordering of social states when the sizç of future generations is subject to choice.
This is a totally revised version of a paper (Dasgupta 1983) prepared for Professor Menahem Yaari’s workshop on Social Choice Theory and Welfare Economics at the Hebrew University, Jerusalem, in the Spring of 1983. It was also presented at the meeting of the Working Group of the US National Academy of Science Committee on Population Growth and Economic Development held during August 2–4, 1984 at Woods Hole, Massachusetts. One strand of this earlier version, with extensions, was subsequently published in the volume of the Working Group: D. Gale Johnson and R. D. Lee (eds) (1987). I have benefitted greatly from discussions over the past several years with Kenneth Arrow, Robert Aumann, Simon Blackburn, Charles Blackorby, John Broome, David Donaldson, George Garnett, Peter Hammond, John Harsanyi, David Kelsey, Marc Nerlove, Derek Parfit, John Rawls, Tim Scanlon, Paul Seabright, Amartya Sen, Robert Sugden, and Menahem Yaari. While preparing this essay I received an extended letter from Jan Graaff in which he reflected on some of the issues discussed in the earlier paper. This present version bears the impact of his comments.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Preview
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
References
Aristotle (1976) The Nicomachean ethics. Thomson JAK, Penguin Books, London
Arrow KJ (1963) Social choice and individual values, 2nd edn. John Wiley, New York
Bauer PT (1981) Equality, the Third World and economic delusion. Weidenfeld and Nicholson, London
Blackorby C, Donaldson D (1985) Social criteria for evaluating population change. J Publ Econ 28
Dasgupta P (1969) On the concept of optimum population. Rev Econ Stud 36
Dasgupta P (1983) Lives and welfare. (ICERD) Discussion Paper, London School of Economics
Dasgupta P, Heal G (1979) Economic theory and exhaustible resources. James Nisbet and Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
d’Aspremont C, Gevers L (1977) Equity and the informational basis of collective choice. Rev Econ Stud 46
Diamond PA (1965) The evaluation of infinite utility streams. Econometrica 33
Gaertner W (1987) Consistency in constant and changing environments: a note, mimeo. Department of Economics, University of OsnabrĂĽck
Gottlieb M (1945) A theory of optimum population for a closed economy. Chicago J Pol Econ 53
Graaff J de V (1962) Theoretical welfare economics. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Hammond PJ (1976) Equity, Arrow’s conditions and Rawls’ difference principle. Econometrica 42
Hare R (1973) Rawls’ theory of justice, Part IL Philos Q 23
Hare R (1981) Moral thinking: Its levels, method and point. Clarendon Press, Oxford
Hare R (1982) Ethical theory and utilitarianism. In: Sen AK, Williams B (eds) Utilitarianism and beyond. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge; Originally published in: Lewis HD (ed) (1976) Contemporary British philosophy. Allen and Unwin, London
Harsanyi J (1955) Cardinal welfare, individualistic ethics, and interpersonal comparisons of utility. J Polit Econ 63
Harsanyi J (1976) Essays on ethics, social behaviour and scientific explanation. Reidel, Boston
Hurka T (1983) Value and poulation size. Ethics
Johnson D Gale, Lee RD (eds) (1987) Population growth and economics development. University of Wisconsin Press, Wisconsin
Jones Lee MW (1982) The value of life and safety. North-Holland, Amsterdam
Kavka G (1975) Rawls on average and total utility. Philos Studies
Koopmans TC (1960) Stationary ordinal utility and impatience. Econometrica 28
Koopmans TC (1972) Representation of preference orderings over time. In: McGuire CB, Radner R (eds) Decision and organization. North-Holland, Amsterdam
Meade JE (1955) Trade and welfare, Oxford University Press, Oxford
Mirrlees JA (1982) The economic uses of utilitarianism. In: Sen AK, Williams B (eds) Utilitarianism and beyond. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Nagel T (1986) The view from nowhere. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Nerlove M, Razin A, Sadka E (1986) Household and economy: parental and filial equity. Academic Press, New York
Nozick R (1974) Anarchy, state and utopia. Basil Blackwell, Oxford
Nozick R (1981) Philosophical explanations. Clarendon Press, Oxford
Parfit D (1982) Future generations; further problems. Philos Publ Aff 11
Parfit D (1984) Reasons and persons. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Ramsey FP (1928) A mathematical theory of saving. Econ J 38
Rawls J (1972) A theory of justice. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Sen A (1973) On economic inequality. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Sen A (1977) On weights and measures: informational constraints in social welfare analysis. Econometrica 45
Sen A (1987) The standard of living. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Sidgwick A (1907) The method of ethics, 7th edn. Maxmillan, London
Sikora R, Barry B (1978) Obligations to future generations. Temple University Press, Philadephia
Sugden R (1985) Why be consistent? A critical analysis of consistency requirements in choice theory. Economica 52
Vickrey W (1960) Utility, strategy, and social decision rules. Q J Econ 74
Williams B (1973) A critique of utilitarianism. In: Smart JJC, Williams B (eds) Utilitarianism for and against. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Williams B (1981) Persons, character and morality. In: Williams B: Moral link. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Williams B (1985) Ethics and the limits of philosophy. Fontana, London
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 1988 Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg
About this paper
Cite this paper
Dasgupta, P. (1988). Lives and Well-Being. In: Gaertner, W., Pattanaik, P.K. (eds) Distributive Justice and Inequality. Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-73816-6_2
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-73816-6_2
Publisher Name: Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg
Print ISBN: 978-3-642-73818-0
Online ISBN: 978-3-642-73816-6
eBook Packages: Springer Book Archive