Regular Articles
Empire forestry and the origins of environmentalism

https://doi.org/10.1006/jhge.2001.0353Get rights and content

Abstract

When and where did the environmental movement begin? To understand how a public endued with the principles of laissez-faire reversed in such short order a century-old policy of government land disposal, this paper examines how public ownership of land came to be celebrated, with a newly defined professional corps of government foresters such as Dietrich Brandis and Gifford Pinchot feted as popular heroes. Hard-headed environmentalists and legislators found in empire forestry a ready-made model to construct vast areas of the public domain as a utensil for not only environmental but state purposes—industrial, settlement, and budgetary. The empire forestry matrix of government reservations, fire protection, and revenue-enhancing forests solved the tension between romantic preservationist notions and laissez-faire ideals and gave the compromise from which modern environmentalism emerged: it posed environmental problems and solutions as a means to construct the state. This article traces the international trail of modern environmentalism from India, under Lord Dalhousie's forest charter, to the British colonies in Africa and Australasia where it matured, and finally to Canada, the United States and other parts of the globe where environmentalism permanently entered the pantheon of democratic political creeds.

References (119)

  • The argument developed in this article is developed at greater length in G. Barton, Empire Forestry and the Origins of...
  • See the opening remarks of the Lord Mayor of London and Lord Lovat, The British Empire Forestry Conference (London...
  • Radical environmental strains that dissented with scientific forestry existed outside the conservation movement and...
  • Merriam-Webster's Collegiate Dictionary (New York 1979) defines environmentalism as “Advocacy of the preservation or...
  • Worster defines environmentalism as “a set of environmental ideals demanded by an urban, industrial society. The period...
  • See D. Kamper and C. Wulf (Eds), Looking Back on the End of the World (New York 1989) G. Myers Nineteenth-century...
  • B. Ribbentrop Forestry in British India (Calcutta 1900) 37,...
  • Ribbentrop Forestry,...
  • The great laboratory, Indian Forester 33 (1907)...
  • The first conservator of the Central Provinces is described as “a romantic who loved the wild woodland and every...
  • First published in Many Inventions, the story was republished in McClure's Magazine in June...
  • Kipling, The Jungle Books,...
  • Kipling, The Jungle Books,...
  • The aims and future of forest research in India, Indian Forester 33 (1907) 507. For the Utilitarian principles that...
  • Scientific forestry is defined as forestry methods based upon experiment and verification of principles. See Barbara...
  • Absolute state property rights logically extended the principles of private property to the state, a logic applied when...
  • Dietrich Brandis held the position of Inspector General of Forests between 1864 and 1883, followed by Wilhelm Schlich,...
  • The Provincial Service tended to attract the native foresters graduating from the newly established forestry school in...
  • Grazing and commutation in the C.P, Indian Forester 18 (1892) 415. Grazing in forest lands, India Forester 26 (1900)...
  • See N. L. Peluso The history of state forest management in Java, Forest and Conservation History 35 (1991)...
  • See S. Nigam The making of a colonial stereotype—the criminal tribes and castes of North India, Part I of Disciplining...
  • See M. Gadgil and R. Guha This Fissured Land: An Ecological History of India (New Delhi 1992)...
  • He also argues that the massive population explosion results in such a low per-capital return on forest use that...
  • See R. Guha The Unquiet Woods: Ecological Change and Peasant Resistance in the Himalaya (New Delhi 1989) G. B. Pant The...
  • Sivaramakrishnan, Colonialism and Forestry in India,...
  • F. Berkes I. Davidson-Hunt and K. Davidson-Hunt Diversity of common property resource use and diversity of social...
  • Berkes Davidson-Hunt and Davidson-Hunt, Common Property Resource Use,...
  • J. M. Baker The effect of community structure on social forestry outcomes: insights from Chota, Nagpur, India,Mountain...
  • The German model of forestry, utilized for technical expertise, did not merely transplant to India. For instance the...
  • The Control Journal of the Mudumalai Leased Forests and the Benne Reserved Forest (Madras Forest College 1924) 2, 7–8,...
  • Control Journal,...
  • Control Journal,...
  • Control Journal,...
  • Control Journal, 8. Proceedings of the chief conservator of forests, proceedings No. 23, 19 January 1923,...
  • Control Journal,...
  • Control Journal,...
  • Control Journal, 41,...
  • Control Journal,...
  • Insufficiency of the world's timber supply, Indian Forester 27 (1901) 397, 435 Timber needs of the EmpireJournal of the...
  • See Colonial Forestry Journal of the Society of Arts (henceforth, JSA) 24 (1886) 929. This article is an abstract of a...
  • The forests of Russia, Indian Forester 28 (1902) 323 Destruction of Greek forests, Indian Forester 28 (1902) 446...
  • E. P. Stebbing Forestry and the war, JSA 44 (1916) 350 360; Major-General Lovat, Forestry, JSA 49 (1921)...
  • There is no broad-based treatment of forestry in the nineteenth century on South Africa, but the Indian Forester, and a...
  • W. Schlich Manual of Forestry Forest Policy in the British Empire, vol. 1, (London 1906)...
  • J. F. Wilson Water supply in the basin of the River Orange, or Gariep, South Africa, JRGS 35 (1865)...
  • Wilson JRGS,...
  • Swellendam Conservancy of forests, Cape Monthly Magazine 16 (1878)...
  • Swellendam Cape Monthly,...
  • Schlich Manual, 137,...
  • Schlich Manual,...
  • Cited by (0)

    View full text